Obama's Punjabi moment........

Will this cost Obama the presidency? Talk of a scathing Barack Obama campaign memo about Sen. Hillary Clinton’s ties to India continued to roil the Indian-American community yesterday, with some writing him off or demanding a direct apology and others pledging continued allegiance.

The Obama campaign fired up Indian-Americans with a research memo attacking Sen. Hillary Clinton’s ties to wealthy Indian-Americans that became public last week. The memo mockingly described Clinton’s political affiliation as (D-Punjab).

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/wn_report/2007/06/17/2007-06-17_bams_indiamemo_bomb_lingers.html

If a ‘Macaca Moment’ put paid to Republican senator George Allen’s presidential ambitions and Democratic aspirant Joe Biden’s brush with Indian Americans left him a bit dunked, there is no saying how hard the '‘Pun’Jab’ would hit rising black star Barack Obama.

Obama, chasing Hillary Clinton in the race for Democratic nomination, apparently had no idea what it means to take a ‘panga’ with the Indians when his campaign suggested that the former first lady was more of a senator from Punjab.

The Indian Americans were clearly not amused by Obama turning a recent joke by Clinton, that given her support among the Indians she could easily be elected from Punjab, into a political projectile.

US India Political Action committee, a body of Indian Americans, took umbrage at Obama campaign’s analysis of 'Hillary Clinton (D-Punjab)‘s Personal Financial And Political Ties To India’ suggesting that the Clintons have reaped significant financial rewards from their relationship with the Indian community.

What miffed them all the more was that Obama, who himself is trying to woo the Indian community, had chosen to take a leaf from 2004 Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry’s book to play the outsourcing card.

The Obama memo, initially sought to be passed to the media on a ‘don’t tell’ basis, accused former president Bill Clinton of investing tens of thousands of dollars in an Indian bill payment company, and Hillary herself of taking tens of thousands from companies that outsource jobs to India.

As the Indian community waited for Obama to respond to allegations that his campaign has been ‘promoting hurtful stereotypes against the Indian American community’, one wondered whether he would pay as heavy a price as Allen did for calling a Democratic Indian American campaign worker a ‘macaca’ or a monkey.

Or would he escape with a little rap on the knuckles as Joe Biden did after suggesting that one cannot visit a ‘Dunkin Donut’ shop in America without having a slightly Indian accent?

http://www.indiaenews.com/america/20070617/56515.htm

Re: Obama's Punjabi moment........

Democratic presidential contender Barack Obama (news, bio, voting record) on Monday said his campaign made a "dumb mistake" when it circulated a memo criticizing rival Hillary Rodham Clinton's financial ties to India.

In an interview with The Associated Press, Obama disavowed the memo which carried the headline — " Hillary Clinton (D-Punjab) — and referred to Bill and Hillary Clintons' investments in India; her fundraising among Indian-Americans; and the former president's $300,000 in speech fees from Cisco, a company that has moved U.S. jobs to India.

"It was a dumb mistake on our campaign's part and I made it clear to my staff in no uncertain terms that it was a mistake," Obama told the AP in a brief interview in which he referred to the memo as "unnecessarily caustic."

Re: Obama's Punjabi moment........

its too early and this is too minor to make any real impact. No matter how much some people want to make it an issue.

its in no way similar to allen's comment.

and if outsourcing is made an issue, the anti outsourcing guy will come ahead among most americans (indians being an exception)