NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid
http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2005\10\18\story_18-10-2005_pg1_5

  • MPAs unhappy with distribution of relief supplies

By Zakir Hassnain

PESHAWAR: The NWFP Assembly unanimously passed a resolution on Monday demanding the federal government hand over all foreign and domestic donations for Frontier quake victims to the provincial government for relief work.

Both government and opposition lawmakers expressed dissatisfaction with the aid distribution mechanism, saying it was not reaching many people desperate for relief in inaccessible areas.

Abdul Akbar Khan, parliamentary leader of the Pakistan People’s Party Parliamentarians (PPPP), moved the resolution which thanked foreign governments and foreign and domestic organisations for their aid contributions and demanded the central government give all foreign and domestic aid to the Frontier government, as well as compensation for the hospitals, schools, basic health units, roads and other infrastructure destroyed in the affected areas.

Mr Khan said the government was ill-prepared to handle the quake, despite it being well known that the area was prone to earthquakes. He said rehabilitation was the job of the provincial government and so the federal government should give it financial assistance to rebuild people’s lives and the damaged infrastructure.

Maulana Nizamuddin of the Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal (MMA) said aid was not reaching shelterless people in Shangla. “They need food, water, tents and medicines and the provincial and the federal government and the NGOs are not paying them any attention,” he said.

Nadir Shah of the MMA complained that aid from the central and provincial government was not reaching many people who were sleeping in the open without basic needs. “At least 500,000 to 600,000 tents are needed to save the affectees from torrential rains and coming snow,” he said.

The US, the World Bank and other foreign donors had given plenty of aid but it had not reached the people who needed it. “Money is coming but there is no distribution. People are looting aid and some are stocking it in their homes,” said Bashir Ahmed Bilour, parliamentary leader of the Awami National Party (ANP). Mr Bilour said the provincial government had not given any grant to hospitals treating the injured.

Riffat Akbar Swati of the PPP-Sherpao said Afghan refugees and Kohistanis were looting relief goods. “They also attacked us and we handed them over to the army,” she said. Opposition leader Shahzada Gustasip said there was plenty of aid but no distribution mechanism. He said the last deadly earthquake in the region destroyed Bisham, in the same area, but the government had not learnt from that. Anwar Kamal Marwat, parliamentary leader of the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), criticised the lack of management of aid distribution. Another MMA woman member said aid had still not reached 500 villages. She accused the army of “not helping in rehabilitation”.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

Perhaps it will be better to make a comittee of trusted people including gov+opposition members to handle this fund.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

I don't know...Knowing that Afghan refugees are involved in loot Khasoot....This is mind boggling....

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

^^ These Mullahs want to take credit for sending "big trucks" to Kashmir. Then they turn around and say people are sleeping in the open.

These Mullahs should declare how much money they collected in the name of the victims.

Also the mosques should get their funds declared.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

^ thats a separate point..the provincial government does have a right over the relief fund..after all its not like the federal government isn't (going to be) using aid resources for its favourites.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

NWFP should not have control of anything....and I am anything. It seems like for 50 years they have not been able to do anything positive with the province why should the federal government give them the benefit of the doubt.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

^ compared to what the federal government has done for NWFP over the last 50 years..pulasee..at least the MPA's are accountable to their constituents ..I think at the very least the province should have aid funneled through it...

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

^^ No Zakk baboo! Mullahs are the last place to throw Saudi money at.

These MAToos have created so much fasaad in Wazirastan. They will go build more Hujraaz and do the londay-baazi. No babba no. Mullahs are not getting a single riyal this time.

It is good to see that the clamp down on riyal flow to Mullahs is working. Otherwise they won't be salivating on these funds.

Development is done by local baboos be they in Sarhad or Punjab or Sindh. Those local baboos are going to take their share no matter what. Blaming feds for that is a simple cop-out.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

^ NWFP has been budgetary starved for ages anti.. the solution is give the province a rightful share (audited tightly and those who embezzle should be punished by NAB) regardless of who runs it..just because you don't like a political group is not a reason to discriminate when it comes to rights. In the end its simple common sense people who are local stakeholders know more about whats going in Manshera than people sitting in Isloo

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

Ages! Man you should be the last person to use the divisive lingo of petty politicians.

NFC award is based on per capita. Sarhad gets its share just like anyone else in the country.

There has been talk by Sarahadi nationalists to “Sarhadize” a dam or two. That is very kommie leftie approach.

Instead Sarhad should improve its taxation system. Feds are not forcing Sarhad to have a 200 years old patwari system. Feds are not preventing Sarhad to streamline property tax collection in the cities. Above all Feds can’t and won’t stop Sarhad from setting up tax-free zones. Haven’t you been to bara and other smugling centers?

p.s. Talk is cheap, improving fiscal policies and tax structure is mighty difficult.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

The point is, that if you go to Sarhad it seems like stepped back in time. For crying out loud improve your self!

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

anyone with even basic common sense knowledge of development aid knows you need locals involved..and since schools, hospitals and basic sanitation are provincial government responsibility ..the provincial government rightfully has a claim on development works done in the area.

anti I will leave the NFC out of this..and use some simple logic..you and others who agree with you.. don't want the feds to give a rightful share to the provincial goverment because you don't like who rules the province..that is the definition of discrimination. and at a time of a human tragedy to play politics with aid is quite unfortunate.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

Oh that’s news to me. Unless you are a dear friend of one-eyed Mullah Umar, Sarhad’s best interests are protected by the rest of the Pakistan. If it was upto MaToos, we’d see Bannu, Kohat, Peshawar being brunt to ground just like Kabul, Kandhar, and Jalalabad.

As I said locals do get involved in development. What are the Nazims doing these days. If they are eunichs, then why are you electing them?

This thread is very specific to the rehab of areas impacted by earth quake. Mullahs want the money and spend on terrorism. That’s where I oppose them.

Had Sarhad elected a moderate government it was OK to give them quake money.

You are the one expanding this discussion way beyond earth quake relief.

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

I smell greed !

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

It seems a well known fact that dissolving authority to the grass roots or even close to it is a way to improve govt function.
Who would know better how to spend the relief then the people who live in the province?

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

Aren’t Federal “Ministers”, MNAs selected from provinces who live there?

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

Im talking about giving the resources to the Provincial GOVT so that they can handle the probelm in their own area. The fedral govt is over stretched, it makes sense to hand over some responsibility to the Provinces.
Also, this might become excuse by all the anti govt anti Pak people in the province who simply thrive on such things. So this can also be seen as nipping the problem in the bud by not giving anyone an excuse to accuse the govt of one thing or another.
And you know aswell as I that the representatives in Islamabad have no real authority...

Re: NWFP Assembly wants control of quake aid

I defn. back Zakk on this one.
Who know what Musharraf and the boys will do with the aid, the best bet we have that it will reach the people is by wirking with provincial authorities.