No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Indians gone nuts…and it is not only me who is saying that..let me copy an excrept from the following article published in an indian newspaper:

“it is important to also state that we should not take our stand of self-confident assertion to the point of illogicality. It’s one thing for the country to stand on its own feet, it’s quite another for it to embrace a ‘Fortress India’ mindset. For instance, no great harm would have been done to India’s image in the world if UN Secretary General Kofi Annan’s visit to the tsunami-affected regi-ons of Tamil Nadu had been facilitated.”

http://www.indianexpress.com/full_story.php?content_id=62494&headline=India’s~no~to~Kofi
No to Kofi
It’s one thing for India to stand on its own feet, quite another to turn into a fortress

India’s stance that it has the requisite capacities and resources to deal with immediate relief, post-tsunami, has caused widespread international consternation. It somehow went against the grain, the stereotype, the common sense. How dare a country like India, with its “starving millions”, climb on to the high horse at a time like this — that at least seemed to mark the general tenor of the global response. India has since clarified that, one, it is in principle not opposed to accepting assistance during the second and more capital-intensive phase of reconstruction and that, two, it has no objection to international resources coming in through NGOs working in the field. India has also demonstrated its considerable ability to respond promptly and effectively to a crisis of this magnitude, both within its territory and in the neighbourhood.

But having noted this, it is important to also state that we should not take our stand of self-confident assertion to the point of illogicality. It’s one thing for the country to stand on its own feet, it’s quite another for it to embrace a ‘Fortress India’ mindset. For instance, no great harm would have been done to India’s image in the world if UN Secretary General Kofi Annan’s visit to the tsunami-affected regi-ons of T"amil Nadu had been facilitated. India could have chosen to have read this visit as a gesture of the world’s concern and left it at that. By virtually shutting the door on him, we have demonstrated not just indifferent diplomacy but a misplaced hypersensitivity at a time when the world is keenly observing us.

National self-confidence has several aspects to it. It makes for autonomy of thought, policy and action and it also makes for less insecurity. A self-confident India does not need to immure itself against the world or resort to a carapace, neither does it have to wear its sensitivities on its sleeve. Indeed, if the tsunami had one lesson for the world it was about the dividends of international cooperation, in terms of information, resources and best practices. In this globalised world, no country can afford to be an island.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

They think and behave as if they're the future kings of the world. Height of conceit. They just don't want to admit their real bhooka nangaa state. Like when the Brits lifted the veil on what India was really like when they went to Orissa to deliver aid.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

thank God the press is still alive.. nahin to yeh khabar pata bhi nahin chalta...

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

May be our Sikh PM has choosen to behave like a Sikh this time and has put aside all logics.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Too much brainwashing by the Shiv Sena is turning Hindustan into a Pagal Khana.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

I think it is good move not to allow him visit the affected area. its the time of reconstruction and saving lives, whatever can be done can be only done right now. If a high profile leader like kofi visits the place than all the resources will be consumed to take care of his visit.
He can come later on, people will be still there. I have nothing against kofi annan but you are talking aobut relief work right now.
India has done it before too, nothing new.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Guys,

did you know that even Mr. Singh has not visited the areas most badly affected. Sometime during Narasimha Rao's reign, it dawned on the politicians that having VIPs visit affected areas create more harm than good. Should the administration & police be bothered about relief work or cater to the security needs of the VIPs?

The affected people do need to receive the assurance that the head of the government is sensitive to their agony and expectations. Hence the top politicians need to visit the affected areas physically, but have to ensure that their visit does not affect relief work too badly. TV helps a lot.

Really, what can Kofi Annan really do?

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

^ I agree. Frequent visits from VIPs slows down the relief effort considerably. That's what happened in Indonesia. There were so many VIPs visiting that region that Airports were shutdown for several hours for relief flight. I think it's a good decision by Indian officials and it has no political motives behind it.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Can we atleast have tea with the nuts.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

indoneisa also dont want foreign troops on their soil

Indonesia wants foreign troops out, defends restrictions on tsunami aid
http://sg.news.yahoo.com/050112/1/3psy7.html

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Strategic thinking behind India not hosting Annan

TIMES NEWS NETWORK WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 12, 2005 11:57:07 PM ]

Sign into earnIndiatimes points

NEW DELHI: When US secretary of state Colin Powell indicated last week that he wanted to tour the tsunami-hit regions, it didn’t take long for the Indian government to launch a pre-emptive strike discouraging any thoughts of visiting India.

A similar fate awaited UN secretary-general Kofi Annan, who is no stranger to rejections from India. Annan’s office was politely informed that his energies were better applied elsewhere.

Why? The official reason given by the government is that while every hand is being utilised for relief and rescue operations, diverting these to receive VIPs is something the government believes it can do without.

India’s refusal to accept foreign aid in the recent disaster has resulted in a lot of criticism being directed its way. India has held firm because New Delhi’s reasons for refusing aid as well as stellar visits go a little beyond the argument that India can go it alone.

Some of the disaster zones in India are strategically important, particularly in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. Car Nicobar has a vital air base, listening post and is crucial to India’s force projection in the Straits of Malacca and in the Indian Ocean. Myanmar’s Coco Islands are close by, which are used by the Chinese for the same purpose.

It is unlikely that the India would want to jeopardise such important security considerations for the sake of a foreign VIP visit. Even foreign media could not access many of the affected areas. Its this reason that the relief effort here has been solely coordinated by the Indian Navy and Air Force.

A lesser consideration was that India has never really considered Annan to be well disposed to it. He had already been barred from coming here during the last India-Pakistan crisis in 2002 by NDA government, and UPA retains the same impressions of him. Therefore, the government did not really feel they had expended too much diplomatic goodwill in refusing to entertain him.

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Well…I think I can buy it…it makes sense to me now and i hope that the Indian government is “busy” in helping poor people for real…

(One may argue that the Indian Government is refusing to allow any big shot to visit the effected areas to hide some stuff i.e. poor management of the crisis, racial problems, religious and political fights among sufferers etc)

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

this is not nwfp anybody can visit

Re: No to Kofi -Indians Gone Nuts

Anybody can see these problems if they exist especially reporters. In fact , a VIP would not be able to see such problems because the govt. will try to hide it by allowing only certain people access .