ehsan Bhai - one needs to have patience, I knew this was going to happen. Moin wasn't ready for this, but selectors thought he was and everyone had huge expectations. As expected he failed and now everyone wants him out of the team and give chance to the youngster. This policy is never going to work esp if you do that to youngsters.
I was against his selection, but When you have given him a chance, then let him play with this team, practice with this team for couple of months and he will improve. If you remove him now and bring Akmal or farhat - then at least stick with them for for couple of tournament/series to know their full potential.
Arey bhai, when we were happy he came back you were fighting with us that he should not come back because he has got butter fingers and we should try some others. Now after two tests we agree with you and you are saying give him a chance to settle down because he is rusty.
Kabhi toh hamari baat maan liya karo. :)
[/QUOTE]
Its not just about picking and dumping, but if you have brought someone back from the wilderness, he should be given a proper opportunity to show his worth.
I was against Moin's inclusion, but since he is here, he should be around for a while to get used to keeping to Sami and Akhtar.
The Indian Selectors' decision to bring in young blood in Parthiv Patel appears to be paying off dividends. By the time India and Pak play, the young Patel will have had considerable number of first class games under his belt... experience that will stand him in good stead, no doubt.
Maybe its now time for the Pak selectors to also bring in new blood?
Ramazan Mubarak every1....
i think that they should stick with Rashid for the mean time, gve him another chance, as he has been playing.
If they decide 2 change then Humayun Farhat Should be bak, bcoz he can bat n keep.
I think leaving aside moin and rashid.... Humayun Farhat is a very good wicket-keeper and also he can bat well...
Give him a chance like Atiq-uz-zaman and Kamran Akmal got..
Give him a chance and I think he will improve as he will play.....
I think Moin's selection paid off today. At least with the bat. But I am still of the opinion that a young keeper with equal credentials as a batsman needs to be groomed, be it Humayun Farhat, Taufeeq Umar or Kamran Akmal. We will need to model him on Aussie Adam Gilchrist.