New Ideological Battle in Pakistan: Traffic Circle’s Name

I have found the following article which speaks volumes about a young man from Lahore who was part of the freedom fight against the British, but is sadly forgotten in Pakistan. Pakistan’s attitude towards anyone non-muslims is dire. Bhagat Singh was a freedom fighter for all religions and creeds and should be celebrated as a hero of the great city of Lahore. Our politicians are too afraid of the mullahs to rename Shadman Chowk after him. Lahories should demand that this city’s hero should be recognised. It would be a great moment for Lahore if the Chowk was renamed on March 23rd on the anniversary of his martyrdom!

Shaheed Bhagat Singh chowk
Posted on March 22, 2011 by Haroon Khalid | 6 Comments
by Haroon Khalid

There are few people who have challenged the status of Gandhi as being the most famous leaders of the Indian Freedom Movement. Bhagat Singh at the age of 23 was able to do that. This name has received immense coverage in the recent years, courtesy of the Indian cinema. Had it not been due to the recent popular Indian movies, not many people in Pakistan would have been aware of this young revolutionary, who shook the foundations of the British Imperial Empire, and gave a new impetus to the freedom struggle. His methods and methodology was a marked departure from the popular modus ope***** of the Congress Party. Initially Bhagat Singh supported Gandhi’s cause, but after the sudden end to the non-cooperation movement following the Chauri Chaura incident, he was disillusioned by the non-violence of Gandhi, preferring doing things his own way. Bhagat Singh says in his writings that when the deaf can’t hear, their ears need to be pulled up; ‘To make the deaf hear’. His bombing of the Delhi Assembly was to achieve this purpose. The aim was not to kill anyone, as a low intensity bomb was used, and it was thrown at a vacant location, where minimum damage could be achieved. It was thrown only with the purpose of making their voice reach to the ears of the rulers. Gandhi rejected the ‘cowardly’ act; however both Jinnah and Nehru developed a romantic association with this young patriot and tried till the end to stop the hanging of Bhagat Singh.

Much has been brought in front of the public about the life and thoughts of the young revolutionaries by the movies; however what not many people in Pakistan know is that this part of India, which later became Pakistan, played a prominent role in the life of Bhagat Singh. He was born in a small village in the outer-skirts of Faislabad, where his ancestral house and primary school still stand. Bhagat Singh got his education from Lahore, and this is where he became a revolutionary in the true essence of the word. He also formed his Naujawan Bharat Sabha in Lahore. The office of the Party was in a small room in the precincts of Mozang. It is said that the room, where the office was still exists. Bhagat Singh was kept in Lahore Jail, which exists near Ichra today. At that time, the Jail was much bigger than what it is today, covering most of the area of Shadman, right up to the Hata Mul Chand Chowk.

Near the Main Market of Shadman, there is a roundabout, with a fountain, called the Shadman Chowk or Faware wala Chowk. It is said that the gallows of the jail were around this area, and this is where Bhagat Singh, along with his compatriots, Sukhdev, and Rajguru were hanged on March 23rd 1931.

The state of history in Pakistan is pitiable. Instead of being taught as a subject to illumine the mind of the pupil, it is used as a political weapon to mould the thoughts of the young. The results achieved so far have been more than satisfactory. It is bizarre how even the elitists’ schools in the country would begin teaching history from Indus valley, talk about Gandhara civilization and jump straight to the Mughals, leaving a void of more than a thousand years. The legacy of Bhagat Singh has also become a victim of this political victimization. Even though he is so closely associated with Lahore, not many people are able to make that connection. Despite receiving recognition from the founder of Pakistan, Bhagat Singh has failed to make an impact on the policy makers of the country, which sadly is not Bhagat Singh’s loss but our own. The reason seems to be the non-Muslim credentials of the martyr. Hopefully one day, we would be able to look outside of the pale of religious boundaries and admire and own people by their actions and thoughts and not by their dogmatic parameters.

There are nonetheless a few organizations and individuals in the country, who seem to admire the history of our land, and make an effort to own and disperse it amongst the people. On the 23rd of March every year, when most of the Pakistanis enjoy the Pakistan Day Holiday with their families, and friends, there are a handful of people, who protest at the Shadman Chowk. These people, who belong to the various Communist and Socialist groups of the city, have been gathering here on this particular day for many years. Their request is to change the name of this Chowk from Shadman Chowk to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk, in memory of the child of Lahore, who sacrificed his life for the desolate people of India, irrespective of their creed, color or religion.

Over the years this particular group has been able to get its self recognition from local politicians, and the media. Some years ago, the Governor Punjab Lt. General (Ret.) Khalid Maqbool conceded to their demand verbally. However since this issue is for the local government and not for the Governor, the order could not be implemented. Some year ago somebody decided to call this roundabout the Chaudary Rehmat Ali Chowk and a board sprang up here from nowhere stating this name. On the 23rd of March 2010, the Bhagat Singh fans pained that chowk red and wrote Bhagat Singh chowk over it. In a couple of weeks the name was changed once again. Salman Rashid in an article pointed out that names of modern day chowks come up arbitrarily, generally based on the whimsical desire of the people and the criminal indifference of the concerned authorities and the people. However, it appears that when it doesn’t suit the authorities they are prompt in taking actions against these names.

There is another interesting story related to this area. The British rule was that at the hour of persecution there needed to be a Magistrate present at the gallows. However such was the support of these three people that no Magistrate in whole of India wanted to take the risk. The British in desperation turned to Nawab Muhammad Ahmad, who was an Honorary Judge from Kasur. He was present at the time of their hanging, and then their bodies were taken to the bank of river Sutlej, where they were cremated in his presence. Later on people build them Smadhis to mark the area. These are present on the Indian side of the border, and are visible from the Ganda Singh, Pakistan. The Irony is that later during Bhutto’s tenure, when Nawab Muhammad Khan returned to Shadman for a wedding procession, he was fired at and killed. His son Ahmad Raza Khan Kasuri launched a FIR against Z A Bhutto at the Ichra police station for the murder of his father. Later Zia-ul-Haq hanged Bhutto for the death of Nawab Muhammad Ahmad. He is buried in Kasur inside Bulleh Shah’s tomb. On one side of Sutlej is the grave of this magistrate and on the other are the Smadhs of the Shaheeds. Ahmad Raza Khan Kasuri is the same lawyer, whose face was blackened by the lawyers during the Lawyer’s Movement outside of the Parliament, as he was fighting the case for the Government.

Being a historical location and closely associated with Bhagat Singh, it is a reasonable demand on the part of the citizen’s of Lahore to rename this Chowk after Shaheed Bhagat Singh. In a city, where anybody can name a Chowk on his/her name, it would indeed be a pity if the name of Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk is not accepted by the authorities, and the populace.

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

Hmm, heard about Bhagat Singh but never knew that he was a Lahori. Has the project for renaming Shadman Chowk been shelved?

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

:eek: Blasphemy

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

^ if you add Shaheed, then yes… :hehe:

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

Bhagat was orginaly from Lyallpur, not lahore

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

Lyallpur is now Faisalabad.

Ok he was killed in Lahore, maybe near Shadman Chowk thats why the movement for renaming.

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

I know because my ancestors were from Lyallpur and Multan that now names have changed and so have cities :)

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

Well, I am sure the present government would consider the request if you propose "Shaheed Bhagat Singh Bhutto Chowk".

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

Multan is still Multan :p

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

see…

Varsity status: city colleges to be affiliated with Pims | Newspaper | DAWN.COM

President Asif Ali Zardari on Monday advised the federal government to consider upgrading the institute and naming it after former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto…

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

I wont be surprised even if this govt will rename Pakistan to Bhuttoistan :)

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

Once overheads and underpass are built around the shadman choNwk it will be renamed to " Miaan Nawashrif Chowk"

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

It will be a great gesture such patriots sacrificed themselves for the people whether they were Muslim, Hindu or Sikh. There will always be extremists who will want to erdicate the memory of those from other religions, but such a thing will be against the laws of humanity and truth.

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

It is sad that people and govt of Pakistan do not have the integrity to do this. All this because he was a Sikh?

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/31/world/asia/plan-to-rename-traffic-circle-provokes-outcry-in-lahore-pakistan.html?ref=global-home&_r=1&

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

I would say that Faisalabad should also be renamed to Lyalpur.

New Ideological Battle in Pakistan: Traffic Circle’s Name

I find it amusing that people who were against the creation of Pakistan are the same people who are fighting against renaming traffic circle after Mr. Singh.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/31/world/asia/plan-to-rename-traffic-circle-provokes-outcry-in-lahore-pakistan.html?_r=0

By SALMAN MASOOD
Published: March 30, 2013

LAHORE, Pakistan — If ever a squabble over a street name could sum up a nation’s identity crisis, it is happening in Lahore, Pakistan’s cultural capital.

Late last year, a group of Lahoris made progress in getting local officials to rename a busy traffic circle for Bhagat Singh, a Sikh revolutionary who was hanged at the site by the British in 1931 after a brief but eventful insurrection against colonial rule. They see it as a chance to honor a local hero who they feel transcends the ethnic and sectarian tensions gripping the country today — and also as an important test of the boundaries of inclusiveness here.

But in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, questions of religious identity also become issues of patriotism, and the effort has raised alarm bells among conservatives and Islamists. The circle was named in 2010 for Chaudhry Rehmat Ali, a Muslim student who coined the name Pakistan in the 1930s, and there was an outcry at the news that it might be renamed for a non-Muslim.

“If a few people decide one day that the name has to be changed, why should the voice of the majority be ignored?” asked Zahid Butt, the head of a neighborhood business association here and a leader of the effort to block the renaming.

The fight over the traffic circle — which, when they are pressed, locals usually just call Shadman Circle, after the surrounding neighborhood — has become a showcase battle in a wider ideological war over nomenclature and identity here and in other Pakistani cities.

Although many of Lahore’s prominent buildings are named for non-Muslims, there has been a growing effort to “Islamize” the city’s architecture and landmarks, critics of the trend say. In that light, the effort to rename the circle for Mr. Singh becomes a cultural counteroffensive.

“Since the ’80s, the days of the dictator Gen. Zia ul-Haq, there has been an effort that everything should be Islamized — like the Mall should be called M. A. Jinnah Road,” said Taimur Rahman, a musician and academic from Lahore, referring to one of the city’s central roads and to the country’s founder. “They do not want to acknowledge that other people, from different religions, also lived here in the past.”

A recent nationwide surge in deadly attacks against religious minorities, particularly against Ahmadi and Hazara Shiites, has again put a debate over tolerance on the national agenda. Though most Sikhs fled Pakistan soon after the partition from India in 1947, the fight over whether to honor a member of that minority publicly bears closely on the headlines for many.

A push to honor Mr. Singh has been going on here for years. But it was not until the annual remembrance of his birth in September that things came to a head. A candlelight demonstration to support renaming the traffic circle had an effect, and a senior district official agreed to start the process. As part of it, he asked the public to come forward with any objections. The complaints started pouring in.

Traders of Shadman Market, the local trade group led by Mr. Butt, threatened a strike. Chillingly, warnings against the move were issued by leaders of the Islamic aid group Jamaat-ud-Dawa, largely believed to be a front for the militant group Lashkar-e-Taiba. Clerics voiced their opposition during Friday Prayer.

The issue quickly became a case for the city’s High Court, which said it would deliberate on a petition, initiated by Mr. Butt and a coalition of religious conservatives, to block the name change. That was in November, and the case still awaits a hearing date. The provincial government has remained in tiptoe mode ever since. “It is a very delicate matter,” said Ajaz Anwar, an art historian and painter who is the vice chairman of a civic committee that is managing the renaming process.

Mr. Anwar said some committee members had proposed a compromise: renaming the circle after Habib Jalib, a widely popular postindependence poet. That move has been rejected out of hand by pro-Singh campaigners.

Mr. Rahman and other advocates for renaming the circle paint it as a test of resistance to intolerance and extremism, and they consider the government and much of Lahore society to have failed it.

“The government’s defense in the court has been very halfhearted,” said Yasser Latif Hamdani, a lawyer representing the activists. “The government lawyer did not even present his case during earlier court proceedings.”

The controversy threatens to become violent. On March 23, the anniversary of Mr. Singh’s death, police officers had to break up a heated exchange between opposing groups at the circle.

Mr. Rahman and the other supporters have vowed to continue fighting, saying it has become a war over who gets to own Pakistan’s history.

“There is a complete historical amnesia and black hole regarding the independence struggle from the British,” Mr. Rahman said, adding of the Islamists, “They want all memories to evaporate.”

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

I agree with you
It was great nonsense to change the names of cities , roads and institutions .

Re: Shadman Chowk should be renamed to Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk

do you disagree with the name changes that took place during the past 5 years?

Re: New Ideological Battle in Pakistan: Traffic Circle’s Name

I dont understand what the issue is? Will our faith be threatened if we honor our past hero?