National Geographic: Inside Mecca

National Geographic: Inside Mecca

October 22, 2003 7:00pm
October 23, 2003 2:00am

What do a successful executive from suburban Malaysia, a religious radio commentator from rural South Africa and an Irish-born college professor from the United States have in common? They’re all about to embark on the spiritual journey of a lifetime — the sacred Islamic pilgrimage to Mecca known as the hajj.

With privileged access to Islam’s holiest city, a NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC SPECIAL follows these three Muslims from different backgrounds as they embark on an epic five-day reaffirmation of faith and quest for salvation. “Inside Mecca,” airing on PBS Wednesday, October 22, 2003, (check local listings), captures the look and feel, spiritual uplift, claustrophobia, grandeur and grit of the largest annual gathering of Muslims in the world.

One of the five pillars of Islam, the hajj is required of all who can manage it at least once in a lifetime. Each year, Muslims from all over the world travel to Mecca to praise and give thanks to God, to ask pardon for their sins and renew their spiritual commitment through an elaborate series of rites and rituals.

“Inside Mecca” intimately documents the pilgrimages of Fidelma O’Leary, Ismail Mahbob and Khalil Mandhlazi, beginning with their preparations at home and carrying through to the climactic events of the hajj itself. For each, the journey presents a unique challenge. Mahbob, a successful Malaysian businessman, must leave behind his family and the material comforts to which he is accustomed in exchange for the austere lifestyle of a pilgrim. Mandhlazi, who takes to the radio each week to bring the teachings of Islam to his fellow South Africans, seeks a chance to see an ideal world of Islam in action, yet finds that even Mecca is not free from economic and racial discord.

Perhaps the most striking story is that of O’Leary. A blonde, green-eyed woman with a faint Irish lilt, she hardly looks the part of the stereotypical Muslim. Born in Ireland to a devout Catholic family, O’Leary converted to Islam while in college. Now, she embarks on hajj having fully embraced the faith, but there are moments when it seems her fellow pilgrims have difficulty accepting her as a peer.

“I had some women in my group try to tell me what it’s like to be a Muslim and ask me, ‘Are you really Muslim?’” said O’Leary. “I think they forgot for a moment that you can only be here if you’re Muslim. It gets a little bit tiresome day after day. It can be upsetting.”

Since hajj calls for a state of ritual sanctity and mental purity, pilgrims must be patient and persevere, not letting themselves be swayed by anger or frustration. Despite the physical and emotional challenges that each pilgrim faces on hajj, the spiritual rewards of performing the pilgrimage prevail.

“Inside Mecca” also tells the story of an ancient holy city that welcomes some two million visitors at the same time and accommodates everyone with relative ease and efficiency. Yet, behind the scenes in Mecca, planning for the hajj is a monumental effort that requires year-round planning.

“If you can imagine having 20 Super Bowls in one stadium, when two million will come to the same stadium, and if you add to it that these two million people will be taking part in playing the game as well … it may give you a glimpse of the preparations needed for … that mass movement represented by … hajj,” says Iyad Madani, Saudi Arabia’s Minister of Hajj. “Sometimes I have a hard time convincing people that we never stop preparing for hajj. We prepare for hajj every single hour. During hajj. Immediately after hajj. Before hajj.”

Truly, Mecca is a city like no other. At its heart is a great mosque called the al-Masjid al Haram, and at its center is the Kaaba, the 50-foot tall, black-draped shrine that is Islam’s most revered structure. While there are many stories detailing its origins, according to Islamic teachings God commanded the Prophet Abraham to raise the foundations of the Kaaba as a place for worship. Thousands of years later, after the Kaaba had become a center of pagan worship, the Prophet Muhammad cleansed it of its many idols and rededicated it to the worship of the one God, who in Arabic is called Allah. Today, pilgrims retrace the steps of Abraham and Muhammad as they perform the rites of the hajj with their fellow pilgrims.

Part of Mecca’s mystique stems from the fact that non-Muslims are strictly prohibited from entering the city. For this reason, very few non-Muslims have ever witnessed the rites and rituals of the hajj. To gain access to the city for “Inside Mecca,” National Geographic assembled an all-Muslim production team. Led by Anisa Mehdi, who, in 1998, was the first American woman to report on the hajj on location in Mecca for U.S. television, the team obtained many never-before-seen images that capture the essence of Islam’s remarkable pilgrimage.

a nice thought....
will no doubt be of great significance to the viewers....

i had kept an eye on it for so long...but seems like, i wont be able to watch it...if they re-telecast it after 24 Oct, then i will consider myself lucky...

Wow...This must have been awesome to see...Especially for those interested in Islam...

Usually those interested in Islam have at one time been interested in other religions too, so they would know all that it takes to reach go on their pilgrimages...Hindus, Buddhists even monasteries...Many might have even gone there themselves...

But for the first time these guys would get a first person view of the Hajj...

Still, it's not the same as being there yourself and rushing with thousands of others chanting "Labaik, Allahumma labaik" and the ground literally reverberating with the impact of hundreds of thousands of feet...

Soon InshAllah...

^^ “I have da same feelings..” :k:

Sounds interesting.

There was something similar on tv here, years ago, they were following a muslim couple of Surinam doing hadj. It was very interesting.

I'm sure this will be worth watching.

It was aired yesterday on PBS, again.

Anyway, it is a great documentary that tries to give a very realistic picture of the events of modern day Hajj. While it touches on the complexity of organizing an event for massive amount of people, the spiritual significance, the devoted believers they also talk about the usual chaos & at times confusion that surrounds it all.

PBS has been showing quiet a few documentaries on Islam, Muslims and the modern day Arabs. They showed one on the Ottomans the other day and a really good one on Lawrence of Arabia.

i missed it :mad: :mad: :mad: Will they be showing it again, on PBS i mean?

it's supposed to be a gathering where everyone is 'equal'.. alas class system finds it's way into the ritual of Hajj.. the 'VIP sections' are a disgrace.. what's the point of donning similar clothings to denote equality and then retiring to your VIP accommodations while other hajjis sleep in tents shared by hundred others??

PA

as a kid and young teen I had an opportunity to go to Hajj many times. we always went with a group of people and picthed our own tents in muzdalfah. but this was mid 80's. Things have changed with all the hotels around..dont knwo what its like to do hajj that way.

but you raised an interesting point, about differences...and as equal as people are, even back then there were differences..how big of a tent did u put up, what were you able to afford to eat..how nice were your sandals..

No matter how hard you try, the differences do prop up somewhere. whther intentional or not.

One interesting thing I noticed was that during tawaf & prayers, their was no physical segregation between men & women, which is odd for Saudi Arabia.

PA Bhaijaan,

Do you have any ideas how this discrimination can be dealt with?

I can only suggest that the government shouldn't assist in the VIP/Premium treatment of Hajjis. In other words, the state shouldn't provide the services based on the money a Hajji can spend. If someone cannot sleep in a tent of 100, they should be allowed to set up a tent of their own, but their shouldn't be tents already available by the state based on how much money they are willing to spend.

At the same time, some Hajjis might have medical problems and some elderly or women with younger children will need more assistance, which should be cared for even if they can't afford it.

I saw the special it was very well done I think.

Micahel Rosenthal the producer for this and the PBS specials on Muhammed, legacy of a prophet as well as american muslims has been working with Michael Wolfe and other muslims to present islam in a different light. The intersting thing is that he's Jewish too!

My brother recorded it...:D

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by PakistaniAbroad: *
it's supposed to be a gathering where everyone is 'equal'.. alas class system finds it's way into the ritual of Hajj.. the 'VIP sections' are a disgrace.. what's the point of donning similar clothings to denote equality and then retiring to your VIP accommodations while other hajjis sleep in tents shared by hundred others??
[/QUOTE]

It's not just the VIP section. How about the guy from S.Africa who couldn't share the S.Africa tent because he was black and had to go to the Hitian tent? How about the American woman who was forced to get a letter from a man "permitting" her to attend Haj? (she ended up getting a letter from her son).

And it's perfectly in character with what right here in this thread - I wrote the same thing you wrote and it was removed. But when you write it, it is allowed to stay.

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by amelie: *
**Micahel Rosenthal the producer for this and the PBS specials on Muhammed, legacy of a prophet as well as american muslims has been working with Michael Wolfe and other muslims to present islam in a different light. The intersting thing is that he's Jewish too!
[/QUOTE]
*

i wasn't aware Rosenthal is Jewish. Michael Wolfe reverted to Islam some years ago; his books on his travels to Morocco and on his experience of performing Hajj, are really good books in my opinion. He also wrote a historical book regarding Hajj; it's a collection of first-person accounts from different Muslims who had performed Hajj within the last 300-400 years... Muslims from very different nationalities, both males and females. Very very interesting first-hand accounts... takes you back to the times when pilgrims performed Hajj by riding on camels for months, upto the present time, and what the journey means for each Muslim.

He writes in an extremely downtoearth, honest manner. It's a very moving book, i'd highly recommend it to anyone.

i saw some parts of it .. JHALLKIYAAN .. and it was great..
-Salman

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by Nadia_H: *
*

i wasn't aware Rosenthal is Jewish.
[/QUOTE]

Yes, isn't it cool? I was invited to a sneak preview at our local PBS affilate for the community where both Micahael's were present and talked about their experience. michael rosenthal spoke about how the research into islam during the making of the documentaries led hiim to study more of his Jewish text and history.

Michael Wolfe mashallah is such gentle soft spoken gentleman. Very nice and doing wonderful things.

I saw it today…:smiley:

It was nice but could have been better, but then I am critical…The people chosen for the documentary were well chosen from very differing backgrounds…

I learnt things which I as a Muslim didn’t know about the Hajj…But the lady from Texas explained it best when she said, ‘it’s not a vacation’…

Although for the faithful the Hajj is a journey of faith for which they would be willing to traverse oceans and mountains (and do), for the average non-Muslim it must have looked hard…

But for those that have done it in my family and the way they described it to me, they couldn’t have been happier had they been trampled to death over there, in fact a couple of them were sad to have come back alive…:D…To die in Hajj in a state of Ihram…

Anyways, I liked it…They did a good job of capturing the essence of Hajj…:k:

^ I'm surprised you call it essence of haj. How can discrimination against women (permission slip from son), blacks (cannot stay in same tent of white countrymen but can stay in tent of blacks from another country), poor (VIP tents and service for more money) and other religions (non-muslims not allowed).....be the essence of haj which is supposed to be a purifying spiritual journey? If it is, not even God can save it.