Salam,
I have a question regarding Hajj. My husband performed Hajj when he was 18 , with his grandmother and uncle some years ago. He was living in the middle east at the time, and went via car, so the expenses were minimal,but they were covered by his father (he was in school back then) . Now I have the impression that his Hajj is was a Nafli Hajj (correct me if im wrong ) because he wasnt exactly independent and earning for himself and that he still has an obligatory hajj yet to perform ? would that be right? can some one clarify?thanks
Re: Nafli Hajj
i think he was an adult and his Hajj was valid. you don't always have to spend your own money to perform Hajj. if he performs Hajj again with his own money, it will be great. as far as his previous Hajj, i'm sure that he has fulfilled his obligation to perform Hajj at least once in his life time.
Re: Nafli Hajj
Agree with Khalil. Instructor who perform hajj alongwith his group, his hajj is also accepted although he's there only for guidance his group.