na'at and crossing the line

[vroom]

Re: na’at and crossing the line

@Monk

1-This argument is too close to Christian argument about them being guided by holy spirit.
2-Not saying that is reason enough for this argument to be wrong.

This reply does not make sense, I will try to explain; I said ‘the people of truth are guided by Allah’ and you have said it is too close to the Christian argument

Either you have some preconceived idea that you are applying or you have another suggestion of where guidance comes from

3-I can accept that God did not let muslims go too far, as doing innovations which would put them out of islam. But Its hard to imagine that every action done by them is 100% guided.

We will need Allah Ta’ala to be merciful to us

Sorry, but I cant help noticing this argument is how atheist find fault with concept of God.
This argument stems from illusion.
Asking for help from Doctor and from neighbour, is completely different domain from asking Allah(swt) to make things happen.

It was a question about permissibility which you did not answer simply. We are discussing Islam, and you mentioned doon illah/besides Allah,
So in your opinion asking help from a doctor/neighbour is ok, and is completely different domain from asking Allah Ta’ala

I’ll accept that, so asking from doctor/neighbour is ok but what happened to doon illah? Has Allah Ta’ala given you permission to call upon doctor or neighbour??