na'at and crossing the line

[Monk]

Re: na’at and crossing the line

@vroom

JazakAllah, without honesty its not even informative

Both, The people of truth and Islam are guided by Allah Ta’ala, and the Quran and Hadees which is also guidance supports them naturally.

1-This argument is too close to Christian argument about them being guided by holy spirit.
2-Not saying that is reason enough for this argument to be wrong.
3-I can accept that God did not let muslims go too far, as doing innovations which would put them out of islam. But Its hard to imagine that every action done by them is 100% guided.

Yes it does, but are we going to take the words ‘‘doon illah’’ (besides God) and apply it to everything? If I get sick is it permissible for me to go anywhere else for cure but Allah Most High?

In Sha Allah, we will both remain truthful

Sorry, but I cant help noticing this argument is how atheist find fault with concept of God.
This argument stems from illusion.
Asking for help from Doctor and from neighbour, is completely different domain from asking Allah(swt) to make things happen.