who is denying it :)?
The fact that Allah categorically elaborates how He raises Apostles and Prophets from the people themselves, in itself is an evidence against your theory.
According to your theory, Either:
- Suleman (AS) was not a prophet although Quran calls him a prophet.
OR;
- The Sunnah of Allah mentioned in Quran about the Prophets is wrong (Naa’oozu billah)
Take your pick and see what you are doing in either cases…
again no one is denying that… In fact, there is a hadith in Bukhari narrated to Ibn-e-Abbas:razi: to whom Prophet:saw2: mentioned about another world other than this with the creatures similar to humans…
Are we challenging that?
The WHOLE point is about the Satanic theory proposed out of proportion and out of the context of Quran. Sure Allah has made and can make creature smarter than us (though He calls humans be the best of his creations -REF: Surah Teeen) … The objection is on declaring Prophet Suleman(AS) be a prophet not from this world. It’s like nations of most prophets asking and wondering why an angel was not sent to them as a Rasool and why a human being like them…
Read up on the people of the time of Suleman (AS) … They were given knowledge of the book and were friend with Jinns… Do we see the same behaviour in this time? Are Jinn normally visible and live among the mankind like they used to?
Read up in Qasas-ul-Anbiya how Syedana Izrael(AS) used to join the darbaar of Suleman (AS) and people could see him and recognize him as Malik ul Maut… Can you do that in these times?
Indeed… does not help you in your point though…
Are you inspired by some Pandit?
If you did not, then, Lo and Behold, you are declaring Dawood (AS) from outside of this world too…
Oh boy, it’s getting interesting… !