thanks for the sympathies guys :D punjabi rose, i really like that eyeliner, i think you should def. try it out. i have tried MAC's fluid line before and it made my eyes red for some reason, and DID NOT last through wazu :( and it dried in the jar (which was tightly closed) even before i used up less the quarter of the product.
sorry if i misunderstood, but not just the eyeliner all makeup has to be washed off before doing wadu. if someone did wadu over makeup it's not valid.