Muslims converting to other religouns?

[deedawar]

Re: Muslims converting to other religouns?

@Razea

abkmujahid brother, i have one more question

…she has abandoned it all together. So..if a person has never actually “accepted” Islam..but was born a muslim…how would we deal with them? We would naturally expect a born muslim to just accept that they are muslim..but she says…“well razea..if my heart was never into it…and I never in my life accepted it…why should i follow it?” This is why I am asking all these questions..because she keeps on telling me that she never actually accepted it..so I don’t know what to say to her. I’m trying to talk to her and help her..but she just brushes me off.

Well, this is a good example of someone who still does not w make it public and tols a friend when asked…if I got the correct impression from Razea.

This friend in my opinion does not deserve any punishment. If she remains quiet and follows whatever she believes I am Ok and will let Allah decide on it. I would however not break any ties with her if she wants and be nice and pray for her return or change whaever you call it. Her parents are to be blamed here but no judgement should be passed for their punishment ot whatever.

Its Allah’s decision to forgive anyone or not. We cannot say since Allah said this or that then Allah is ‘bound’ to do that. I know Allah keeps his promise but who are we to judge.

On the other hand if she tries to go on public and hurt our views and feelings then we have a right to think of her whatever we know based on Islamic view and we may not believe her that she was never a muslim by heart to begin with! In other words if we are giving her benefit of doubt then she do the same.

Hope I am right. If not correct me.