Muslim lesbian couple from Pakistan defies life threats, becomes first to get married

[Zafra]

Re: Muslim lesbian couple from Pakistan defies life threats, becomes first to get mar

@Ghost14

Where did I say that the Saudis or OBL are not Muslims? Quote me.

I said that they could be accused of committing Fitna, in essence, that they can be called “bad” Muslims. You could say the same thing about lesbian women, and that’s fine, but it’s awfully presumptuous of you to say that they’re not Muslims because that’s for God to decide.

I don’t need to quote your words. You are basically using the argument that OBL and the Saudis among others are worse Muslims than this lesbian couple. You are passing judgement which you said earlier that was not your role.

I would imagine that most gay people don’t think it’s okay to be gay, but realize that they’re are committing a sin. That would make it fasq. **No one is suggesting that Islam permits homosexuality, what I am saying was that **their lifestyle is their choice, and it’s up to Allah to decide whether they are Muslim or not, or good people or not. This was in response to someone saying that it’s all fine because they are not Muslim anyway. It’s probably a personal struggle for them. It would be pretty hard to just turn off your sexual urges.

---

Basically its unfair for us to judge the Lesbians as bad. But its perfectly okay for you to imply and state that OBL and Saudis are worse Muslims.