Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
^^ by whom?
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
If it is the right form of Bharatnatyam, sure I wouldn't mind even if your mother is the dancer. May be you just don't know what is being discussed here. This form of dancing is as pure and holy as you praying to Allah. Now, will you have any objection to your mom doing so?
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
so say you. she thankfully, thinks differently.
There is no burden to prove anything to anybody. They're doing a great thing of cultural value and the sensible parts of the community will help them if needed. Don't make the mistake of interpreting religion to others based on your limited and limiting way of life
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
and dancing is wrong?? in what way is whats happeneing to her right?... these stupid mullahs ahh I hate them fcking think they can say or make up their own effing rules when its their children and grandchildren who are out their getting piss ass drunk and screwed on a friday nite.... what is wrong with dancing, and especially when its the kind of dancing she is doing? they shud be proud of her and say oh look she being a muslim girl who's culture doesnt have classical dance is dancing and showing up everyone else??.... I bet the stupid mullahs are they ones who watch her at the temples... ahhh I swear topics like these really get me started.....
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
I would have every objection to my mom dancing any form of dance…My mother’s status in Islam too high for her to be the object of amusement for strangers…
But, judging from your posts, such is not the case with you…Whether the dance is Katthak, Bharatnatyam, Oppana, Mujra or whatever the heck forms of dances are out there, a dance is a dance…Some other Hindu can claim the same for Katthak and some can claim the same for Nirata…
As a Hindu you wouldn’t mind your mother amusing strangers, but as a Muslim, our mothers’ status border on the divine…Paradise is under the feet of our mothers whom you don’t mind yours tapping away for the amusement of others…A women is not an object to be decorated and trained to perform for the amusement of the masses…Islam condemns such behaviour as it cheapens the status of women…
While Hindus don’t mind women being treated as trained monkeys or even their mothers, Muslims can’t even imagine it…After all, you come from a religion that cremated living wives of dead husbands on the husbands funeral pyre…
Don’t feel left out though…Look in the thread and read every reply…There are Muslims in this thread alone who support your POV to degrade women…
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
^women rights in Islam..Not again..
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
You need to ask mummy daddy before posting your 'childish' comments. You have no idea what is being discussed.
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
What if someone comes to you and tell you he wants to see your mother dance whatever it is?
You will say:
A- Sure you want to call her or should I arrange for it?
B- No. She can only dance for the masses. Bring your friends and you can sit in front row.
C- What the heck are you talking about. its my mother you are talking about!
BTW we don't dance when pray for Allah. Read our religion if you can. try not to mix two religions.
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
Wasn’t ‘dance’ being discussed here? You asked the guy if he would mind if his mother dances, that question itself is highly uncultured and uncalled for. And then when he retaliates, you drag his religion into it and again speak in an uncouth manner. Go through this thread urself and ul see that though ppl have been discussing something, they haven’t gone ard insulting others’ faith.
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
You are emotional for no reason.
Someone made a comment and people are making him accountable for it. That's all.
Re: Muslim girl treated as outcast by moque community
Actually, so say those who oppose her…so, unh…the power of positive thinking can’t really warp reality to make them go away.
No need to resort to ad-hominem:halo:
It’s always okay in expecting consistency or coherence. Questions to that end should be answered, not wished away…cause they don’t go away.
In Islam, a basic principle…in fact, an axiomatic one is that no partners be ascribed to Allah. Now, a devotional dance that invokes other God’s is clearly questionable, if not perverse form a Muslim stand point.
What I hear back isn’t a counter-argument or any semblance of a rationale, but rather a ‘how dare you blah blah blah’.