Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Muslim man is accused of claiming to be a prophet

Muslim man testifies before court that he did not claim to be a prophet and that he bears witness that Mohammed (pbuh) is the last Messenger of Allah.

Muslim man is sentenced to death.

Yep, Pakistan’s Blasphemy law working as intended and doesn’t need to be changed.

http://www.dawn.com/2012/01/31/cleric-sentenced-to-death-in-blasphemy-case.html

CHAKWAL: A ‘blasphemy’ accused was sentenced to death and also to 10 years’ imprisonment on Monday, sources told Dawn.

Soofi Mohammad Ishaq of Talagang town had been facing the charge since 2009.

On Monday, an Additional Sessions Judge of Jhelum sentenced him to death and 10 years’ imprisonment and fined him Rs200,000.

Soofi Mohammad Ishaq was settled in United States where he worked as a cleric. He returned to Talagang in 2009 and was given a warm welcome by hundreds of his disciples. His followers also kissed his feet, but some people objected to the act of “bowing down before Ishaq” and later accused his followers of b*****ng him a prophet.

Later, Ishaq’s rivals launched a campaign against him and a young man named Asadullah, allegedly at the behest of his Deobandi mentors, lodged a complaint at the Talagang police station. He accused Ishaq of committing blasphemy.

Police booked Ishaq under sections 295A and 295C of the Pakistan Penal Code and his case was heard by Chakwal’s Additional Sessions Judge Sajid Awan.

After completion of hearing, the judge set a date for announcing the judgment, but later he wrote a letter to the Lahore High Court’s Rawalpindi bench, informing it that he could not announce the verdict because of security risks. “Judge Sajid Awan pleaded to the LHC that as he is deputed in Chakwal, he cannot announce the verdict because of security risks and, therefore, the case should be referred to another district,” said Advocate Chaudhry Mehmood Akhtar, the counsel of the accused.

The LHC referred the case to Jhelum’s district and sessions judge, who marked the case to his subordinate Additional Sessions Judge Chaudhry Mumtaz Hussain, who announced the verdict on Friday.

Informed sources told Dawn that Soofi Ishaq had been appointed Gaddi Nasheen of the shrine of Pir Fazal Shah. This, according to sources, infuriated complainant Asadullah, who belonged to Pir Fazal Shah’s family, and he used the opportunity to register the blasphemy case against Ishaq.

“My client pleaded to the court that he cannot even think of committing blasphemy.” He told the court that he believed that the holy prophet (peace be upon him) was the last Messnger of Allah,” Advocate Chaudhry Akhtar Mehmood said.

When contacted by Dawn, Asadullah claimed to have seen followers of Ishaq bowing their heads before him and heard them chanting slogans of “Yaa Rasool Allah”. When asked why other religious leaders did not move against Ishaq, he said: “I was the first to see the way Ishaq’s followers behaved and I recorded it on my camera. And Allah has given me the courage to move against the blasphemer.”

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

poor man.
right or wrong, no man deserves to be killed for things such as religion.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

How can court decide about religious matters?

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

That's what the blasphemy law gives the courts authority to do.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Main problem is that k kisi per jhota ilzam bhi lagh jayee tu samjhoo gaya. No court , lawyer will help him/her get acquitted. Such is the extremism in Pakistan.

Salman Taseer tried doing such and look what happened to him and his murderer is a hero....

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

This is horrible :/

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Horrible . A lawyer friend of mine in Pakistan told me that this law is the easiest way of getting rid of anyone . It doesn't require any concrete proof , but few false witnesses which you can get for couple of thousand rupees . Crazy stuff .

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

And then PPL complain about double standards of western powers

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Salman Taseer was right - this is a Black Law.

I believe that Pakistan does need an anti-blasphemy law, but the current one is defective in so many ways and it needs revision.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Asadullah and people like him are nothing but ‘Fitna’ and should be given same dose they like to give others … so:

I think someone should register a case of blasphemy against Asadullah too, claiming that Asdaullah considers himself Nabi (Prophet), as when he came to their house in group (tableeghi gasht) said that he is doing ‘nabion wala kaam’ (work that ‘prophet’ do), something these people claim all the time.

Let see what happens.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

As if Allah isn't powerful enough to take his life for such lies that he has made against HIM. These zalim mullahs/courts have reduced power of Allah to a peace of paper. Astaghfirullah!

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Anyone who thinks they need to defend the 'honor' of Allah by hanging/killing someone is the biggest blasphemer because they are trying to be god themselves.

There is absolutely no need for any kind of blasphemy law!

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Open blasphemy is considered treason - so a law needs to be there ... but the wind in the sails of the blasphemy is taken away when the accused denies all blasphemy under oath ... by uttering a statement that contradicts his charge.

For example accused is blamed for "saying he is a prophet in Islam" then the rectification to this is to "publicly announce under oath that he is not a prophet in Islam"

The only law for blasphemy that should lead to treason is if

a) The person insists under oath that what he is accused of saying and says the allegations are true
b) He publicly propagates that belief and states under oath that he will continue doing so

Otherwise his statement under oath undoes the charge ... All people should be given a chance to clarify their position. If people announce "Ya RasoolAllah" it does not necessarily have to be directed at him and surely he is not the one saying the words ... they are being said by his followers ... They should be stopped by him and his word about his own beliefs is what matters ...

For sure a person who "does believe something that others find to be blasphemy" he will never recant his blasphemous claim under oath, because it will ruin his claim. So to get him to clarify, even recant i.e. seek forgiveness for an error on his part is enough to cancel the charge.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

You are right but you should know that there is idiom (Mahawara): ‘Latoon kay bhoot baton say nahi mantay’ ... and these Fitna-creators are ‘latoon kay bhoot say bhie dheet hain’ so they should be dealt in same way.

For instance: A group should file a case against ‘Mumtaz Qadri’ of Blasphemy that when he killed Salman Taseer he considered himself ‘Allah’ or ‘Prophet’ ... or that he considered himself above ‘prophet’.

Actually, there should be group of vigilantes in Pakistan (and hopefully government should support them too) who should make their duty to file cases of blasphemy against all those Mullahs and so-called scholars (especially eminent and renowned ones) who support blasphemy law. Cases should be so frequent, indiscrete and widespread that it should take S* out of these Fitna-people. Punishment for them should be severe too, from hanging to years of harsh prison and title of blasphemer attached to their name.

I think the best situation would be when each and every proponent of Blasphemy law should have a case filed against them of Blasphemy, than only these people would get to senses.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

What you mentioned is 'Islamic principle' but these dheet Fitna-gar people are not even proper Muslims. They are quacks claiming to be guardian of Islam.

On the other hand, in Islam, state has nothing to do with individual’s personal beliefs and deeds (hence blasphemy law is unislamic ... imposed in subcontinent by British to control tension between emotionally charged-up population ... something Zia modified to make it worse and his spiritual son Nawaz introduced into it capital punishment). State can only interfere in mamlaat (dealings of people with each other).

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

From one extreme to another ...

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Yes ... beliefs become mamlaat if they are propagated using the liberties of the system ... if the system is Islamic then the propagation against the religion of the state is considered treason.

Again I state all it requires is for someone to deny any accusation and by Islamic law he should be let free ... even if he was doing it ... he repents ... he should be let off.

By the way who are the fitna-gar the accused or the accusers or both :) ???

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

So now its Deobandi vs Brelwi blasphemy. Few months ago a deobandi cleric was put on trial for blasphemy bcoz he removed the Milad posters from his house.

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

Brother ... Not true what you said ... beliefs is not mamlaat and could never be considered treason in Islam or Islamic state. Each individual is going through test of his own beliefs and would be answerable to Allah of his own beliefs after death. One can preach whatever one wants to, and others have right to accept or reject the preaching without fear or pressure. Truth always prevails and only those whose beliefs are false and shaky get scared from freedom of preaching beliefs.

Mamlaat is state duty because state is guarantor of peoples’ rights and protector of peoples’ life and property, and mamlaat always deal with these things.

As for calling ‘Ya Rasul-Allah’ all know that no Muslim addresses anyone by that phrase except they addresses Prophet (SAW). Calling ‘Ya Rasul-Allah’ is Islamic and a person cannot be Muslim if that person does not say ‘Ya Rasul-Allah’ (same as Oh Rasul-Allah) ... because it is part of salaat to say ‘Ya-Rasul-Allah’. A Muslim say that every time a Muslim do Salat and read At-taheeyat ... where when he says ... As-salaamu alaika Ayeoha an nabio ... it means ... Aye Nabi tum per Salaam ho (Peace be on you ya-prophet).

Re: Muslim Cleric sentence to death for blasphemy

You are right ... we have people from both sects abusing blasphemy law according to their liking, and thus both should get treated with same stick.