Music in Islam (merged)

[Crescent]

Re: Is Music Haraam?

@PyariCgudia

No its not beautiful in all places. But what you’re talking about is music videos. Music videos are made by video directors and heavily influenced by music producers. These people do not play instruments. Nor is the instrument getting up on its feet and saying “Hey, I’m your guitar, and you gotta listen to me, make a video with lots and lots of sex and the music YOU composed using me as instrument will sell like hotcakes”.

If people are abusing the music industry, that’s not the fault of the guitar, nor has the guitar enticed anyone to produce nasty videos.

Yes you fail to understand clearly from the hadith and Fuqhis that the musical instrument itself (i.e. the Guitar) is responsible, the sex and profanity is just an add on.