Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

An impressive economic turnaround, historic movements to peace with India, and an ever freer media.

**Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist **

In a clear boost to Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf who wants to keep his uniform and seek a second term, a British magazine says he is more popular than former prime ministers Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif who are challenging him from exile. Quoting the findings of a survey, Economist says Musharraf has ‘generally proved much better at running the country than either Nawaz Sharif or Benazir Bhutto’, who are attempting a political comeback ahead of next year’s general elections. In dealing with arch rival India too, the magazine gives full marks to Musharraf. ‘Remarkably, given a career spent fighting India, he had done more to make peace than any his predecessors,’ the report noted. The magazine praised the economic reforms introduced by Musharraf that had helped the country achieve seven percent growth despite the fact that when he took over, the economy was in a crisis. But the survey asserts that these sensible reforms have almost all only been partially or corruptly implemented. It adds that Musharraf is clinging to his job by manipulation and with the backing of the army, and that by sabotaging Pakistan’s fragile democracy to meet his own ends, he may have made the country even more dangerous’. The economy has become ‘tigerish’, it says, but notes that foreign investors are still keeping away.

‘General Musharraf inherited an economy in crisis. Shackled by sanctions and parched of capital, Pakistan had defaulted on foreign debts,’ said The Economist, adding: 'Thanks partly to continued fiscal prudence and some sensible reforms, Pakistan has notched up average growth of seven percent over the past three years, about the same as India. ‘Six years on, General Musharraf is still in charge and the economy has been transformed,’ the magazine noted. In the financial year to mid-2005, it grew by 8.6 percent, the highest in two decades, followed by a 6.6 percent rise in the financial year ended June 30, The News daily said, carrying details of the survey conducted for the magazine by James Astill. On Musharraf’s initiative to start a dialogue with India, the magazine said peace in South Asia is now more possible than in the past. ‘He then surprised many by throwing himself into peacemaking with India.’ Peace on the subcontinent is still hard to imagine, but it may be more possible than at any time since the Independence in 1947, it said. Referring to the Siachen glacier, The Economist said: ‘One big test of good intentions for both sides is the Siachen glacier in Kashmir, the world’s highest battlefield, from which they have been talking of withdrawing troops.’ It said if both Pakistan and India ‘can reach agreement on Siachen, they can probably settle a couple of smaller border disputes as well.’

As till also applauds Musharraf for the pledges that he has made to crack down on extremism and to promote ‘enlightened moderation’. Whilst Musharraf denounces extremism, he has proved reluctant to crack down hard on the killers. The survey indicates that the reason for this is two-fold. Musharraf, A still states, distinguishes between truly dangerous militia and those he thinks he can control. The other reason is that General Musharraf is afraid of the potential support that the extremist groups can muster. But some liberal progress may emerge from General Musharraf’s rule. **He has liberated the media, meaning that Pakistanis now have more access to information about the world outside Pakistan. TV viewers can increasingly watch foreign channels, including those from India, the magazine notes. **

http://in.news.yahoo.com/060710/43/65s2b.html

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

This is just terrible news for the democrats of pakistan!! More freedom of speech under dictatorship than under democrats.. oh this is just terrible :frowning:

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

Mushy has been widely positive.

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

In a recent interview to a pvt channel Mush said his autobiography is ready to be launched in September. I hope it's a detailed and straightforward account, like the person himself.

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

abay u simpletons dont you know the economist is a state controlled military run ISI publication that blah blah blah..

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

If you trust Economist then you are lost. Thats only I can say.

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

thanks for posting this. its obviously the truth

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

nawae waqt par trust karein phir, ya takbeer par?

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

^ :hehe:

No one is perfect. And Musharraf certainly isnt. But you cannot deny his achievements (unless you are pmln or mma supporter). He has his shortcomings and failures to learn from. Economist is doing nothing but stating facts that are well presented and documented since a while. So Hats off to mushi. :salute:

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

Thats a great news.. now Mushy should take off the army uniform immediately and contest as a civilian as he has suddendly become so popular :D though i doubt he would know exactly how popular he is without the uniform.. where would all his dumb and greedy PML-Q run to save themselves..

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

follow the lead of other bhagoray and go hide in dubai or london :wink:

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

may be but they may be effectively consumed by some new dictators with a slogan of clean government as was the case with Musharaf !

But popularity of Myusharaf is such a big joke.. if thats thge case he should immediately allow Benazir and Nawaz to come in country and contest elections.. he can easily defeat them even without the uniform :)

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

Musharraf may not be the best of leaders but he is far better than Benazir and Nawaz. If Benazir was so great and loved by Pakistanis then let us see her win an election in Lahore. The same can be said for Nawaz and see if he wins anywhere outside of Punjab. Both are corrupt and all they care about is themselves, their family and perhaps their "braderi". They are not worthy to be called leaders of a great country like Pakistan.

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

An army general drives strength from army and politicians drive their strength from public support. Army comes from people and thus there if a politician would be popular amongst people, they would be popular amongst army too. That is why, an army general even though having command of whole army, do not dare to depose a politician.

Army general can only depose politician in power is when that politician is unpopular amongst people and army. Since other politicians also have supports amongst people, most of the time army general try to befriend these politicians to keep balance.

When politicians are corrupts like BB and NS and other politicians along with BB and NS have lost all supports amongst people, then only a general (like Musharaf) not only take over the power but kick them hard too.

If these politicians have any support amongst the people, they have to bring it out on the road to change the situation, else they, with their supporters should keep their corrupt mouth shut. As they do not have support, now it all depends on the charity and courtesy of President Musharaf to let them in power ever, keep kicking them and making them stay abroad or imprison them after luring them into Pakistan.

In such situation (as it is present in Pakistan now), if President Musharaf wants to, he can keep ruling all his life or if decides, he can give up and let them corrupts come back again.

[What I know, last time opposition tried to gather people in Islamabad, from 160 million population of Pakistan, they manage to gather 35 or so people].

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

Every time a military general has taken power from detested and corrupt politicians there has been huge celebrations all over Pakistan. Jalebi and mithai is on offer free for many days. :p:D

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

So if the Army only overthrows the corrupt..what does that say about when they ousted Ayub, yahya and probably Zia?

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

The Pak government apparently isn’t happy with this economist article

Pakistan’s problems
SIR – Both your leader on and survey of Pakistan were unduly harsh and unfair to the country, its leadership and its people, to say the least (“The trouble with Pakistan”, July 8th; A survey of Pakistan, July 8th). The contention that Pakistan is not doing enough in the campaign against terrorism and extremism is contrary to the facts, which include 700 al-Qaeda operatives captured (including important targets, such as Khalid Sheikh Mohammed), 90,000 Pakistani troops deployed along the border with Afghanistan, and continuing operations in the tribal areas.

For further evidence, one could point to a ban on militant groups, the crackdown on hate literature and the registration and reform of madrassas. For you to think that the witches’ brew of problems left behind after the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan are amenable to a quick fix shows a lack of comprehension about the complexity of the challenges.

Furthermore, sweeping statements such as “Osama bin Laden is widely believed to be in Pakistan” (believed by whom?), and baseless presumptions such as that President Pervez Musharraf’s supporters will “rig” the next national election, bring no credit to The Economist. You did not cite the giant strides Pakistan has made in trying to empower women, open up the electronic media and create more press and cultural freedoms. These actions have strengthened civil society and reinforce Pakistan’s democratisation process.

Imran Gardezi

High Commission for Pakistan

London

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

You mean the "life chair persons" who dare never to allow their own party members vote to elect them into power? Those who cannot even practice democracy within their own parties should not preach to the population at large.

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

Nawaz Sharif never won a fair election in his life. The 1990 election was totally rigged, and the 1997 election was a complete farce, hence he has very limited support (Lahore etc) but not widespread national support. Though his overthrow by Musharraf was welcomed all over the country, a clear demonstration of support for the military. Additionally, the lack of any sort of large scale demos for Nawaz or Benazir shows people are largely content with things as they are.

Re: Musharraf more popular than Benazir, Nawaz: Economist

hey I just answered your question about where bhagoras should go. you did not address that except with a maybe and then everything after the BUT just went in a different direction.