Murgha Punishment

Arts & Culture Culture, Arts, Literature & Linguistics
1

In Pakistan, Murgha punishment is widely acceptable in schools. Police also use this punishment on criminals…

Is it common in other culture too?

What are others punishment in other cultures?

Does it really help?

2

Re: Murgha Punishment

i don't think 'murGhaa banaanaa" is even known in other cultures. yeh to 100% desii iijaad hai. :)

3

Re: Murgha Punishment

Who did invent(ejad) such a painful punishment?

4

Re: Murgha Punishment

I think that might be some northern invader

5

Re: Murgha Punishment


iijaad karnewaale ko kia takleef huii hogii...usko to dusroN kii takleef meN lutf aataa rahaa hogaa...yeh hii vo insaanii fitrat hai jo azal se maujood rahii hai aur abad tak maujood rahegii...jab tak yeh fitrat e insaanii insaan numaa Haiwaan meN rahegii bechaare kamzor iske nishaana bante raheNge. :(

6

Re: Murgha Punishment

Uthak Bhetak kis kis nay ki hai?

7

Re: Murgha Punishment


maiN ne...magar not as a punishment but as a game...we played 'LADDUL' [loading] card game and whoever lost had to do as many uTThak baiThak as he had card points in his hand...it was a fun game! :)

8

Re: Murgha Punishment

^ aur MurGhaa bhi banain hian?

9

Re: Murgha Punishment


nope! main kabhii school meN paRhaa hii nahiiN is liye kabhii sazaa kaa sawaal hii paidaa nahiiN huaa...maiN to pahli baar grade 10 meN school gayaa aur tab tak maiN baRaa ho gayaa thaa lol.

how about you? kabhii uTThak baiThak karvaaii gaii yaa kabhii murGhaa banaayaa gayaa aapko? :)

10

Re: Murgha Punishment

^ bas kuch na pocho....

11

Re: Murgha Punishment

A friend’s kids were visiting this summer. We were water fighting and one of the kids was cheating. To mainay usay murgha banaaya :cb:

12

Re: Murgha Punishment

:lajawab: Now… Western culture is also accepting our very own desi hathkanday of punishment…

13

Re: Murgha Punishment

Haha this isn't western culture. He was fresh from Pakistan :D

14

Re: Murgha Punishment

But he was punished at Western part of world....

15

Re: Murgha Punishment

I've got lots of observations and experiences on this matter (punishing students). Its never been useful and creates a resistance in victim. Sometimes, students start disliking the teacher and that results to leaving studies in between as well.

As I shared with you that I couldn't complete my Hifz e Quran and one of the reasons behind this decision was this attitude by a molana. When I decided that I won't go to that madarsa, many of representative came at our home for making me change my decision, but I refused to meet them. When I went for prayers in masjid, that molvi told me 'tum jehnami ho'. I stopped praying for years. My Dada and Dadi stopped talking to me as that was their wish that someone from their children become hafiz e Quran. I asked them I won't go to that Madarsa (it was the only deo-bandi madarsa in the town) and if they wish me to continue hifz e Quran, send me to other madarsa (that was bound to be non-deo bandi madarsa), they didn't accept it as for them that would probably result sectarian issue in small town.

16

Re: Murgha Punishment

I heard that Deobandi madrasas in Karachi hire Brelvi Qaries for their students… They are good in recitation… :hmmm:

17

Re: Murgha Punishment

baRi door ke lae hain aap. I don’t think its possible. My experience says that they consider barelvis as ‘Mushrik’, shia as ‘Munafiq’. I have heard students of Madarsa in their teenage saying ’ Khuda ka shukr hai us ne hamen deo-bandi banaya .. Mushrik o Munafiq nahin banaya’ followed by recitation of Sura e Bayyina (Lam ya kun ilazeen’… :bummer: I know this poison spread in roots of our society from my childhood.