Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

** Wants policy of supporting Musharraf reviewed, more attention towards Nawaz than Benazir

  • One ‘punitive step’ could be increasing engagement in Afghanistan and CARs*

*By Iftikhar Gilani

*NEW DELHI: After declaring a tough stance against Pakistan in the wake of the Mumbai serial blasts, the Indian establishment is now in a dilemma over what “punitive steps” to take against Pakistan.

Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh has made the job more complex after his return from the G-8 meeting. Although Dr Singh has said that there is a need to reflect on relations with Pakistan, he has made it amply clear to his officials that he does not want permanent hostility, a source told Daily Times on Wednesday. Therefore, while a repeat of Operation Parakaram in 2001, when India deployed thousands of troops along the LoC and western border, is being ruled out, Indian officials are considering a series of diplomatic and political responses to convey an anti-terrorism message “with full force and full determination”, the source added.

The source said the first step being deliberated is to review the policy of supporting President General Pervez Musharraf, who was seen as the best bet for peace by a sizable section within the government. Security advisers are now asking the government to pay attention towards the exiled political leadership of Pakistan, the source said, adding that the advisers are betting more on PML-N leader Nawaz Sharif than the vocal pro-India leader Benazir Bhutto.

The source said the most important “punitive step” India could take against Pakistan is increasing engagement in Afghanistan and Central Asian countries. India is thinking not only of increasing its military strength to neutralise Pakistan’s strategic depth in the region, but also increasing financial assistance and indulge in other social activities in countries surrounding Pakistan. A move is also being made to increase the staff strength at the Indian consulate in Jalalabad, the source added. Islamabad has accused the consulate in Jalalabad of “subversive activities” in Balochistan and “undue” interference in the political affairs of the Northern Areas. The source said that this step would force Pakistan to retain and increase its military presence along the 2,500-kilometre Afghan border. He added that Indian officials believed that Pakistan had earlier decided to withdraw troops from the border to press them into action in Balochistan.

While it is clear that there will be no immediate official engagement with Pakistan, the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) believes that the government should continue talks with Kashmiri political parties and whichever Kashmiri militant organisations willing to talk. Ruling out any reduction in troops or counter-terrorism measures, officials are planning a three-pronged formula.

“Target militants with full force, take legal action against over ground workers (OGWs) who provide shelter and incite people to take out processions in favour of militants, and finally, address the ideology of radicalisation,” said a senior official. India is also encouraged at the world’s response, particularly the G-8 statement on the Mumbai blasts. “We would have taken a different stand if the world had treated Mumbai any different from London or Madrid,” officials said. They believe that world leaders have shown their readiness after the blasts to undertake all necessary measures to bring to justice the perpetrators, organisers and sponsors of terrorism.

Sources said that India hoped to build a campaign so that the world takes up the Dr AQ Khan issue besides sending stern reminders for restoration of democracy in Pakistan. Analysts in Srinagar, however, believe that the attacks have provided an excuse for India to delay negotiations on Kashmir. Kashmir’s ace political analyst and writer Tahir Mohuddin says that only a strained atmosphere could have provided India an excuse to withdraw from negotiations. Others believe that militancy increased after New Delhi rejected Musharraf’s proposals on Kashmir.

Pakistan, which was earlier relying on the Hurriyat and other pro-freedom groups, now has vocal supporters in two important pro-India political parties — the National Conference and the Peopless’ Democratic Party (PDP) — besides other smaller groups in the Jammu and Kashmir Assembly. These parties maintain that Musharraff’s proposals should have been considered. Most of these pro-India leaders had even warned that India’s refusal is inviting the revival of militancy.

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2006\07\20\story_20-7-2006_pg1_1

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

This is what happens when you cry wolf all the time..

http://www.dailypioneer.com/indexn12.asp?main_variable=front_page&file_name=story2.txt&counter_img=2

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

Nice read Abdali :slight_smile:
Something similar was published in dailytimes as well:

India failed to prove Pakistani hand in Mumbai blasts

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2006\07\20\story_20-7-2006_pg7_36

%between%

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

Is India preparing another “decisive war” against Pakistan, like they threatened in 2002? :rotfl:

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

Punitive actions my foot!

Even when Pakistan is much smaller compared to Bharat,
Or Israel is much smaller compared to Arabized areas,

Pakistan has guts to take on 10 times bigger enemy.
Same way Israel has guts to take on 10 times bigger enemy.

Pakistan doesn't beg Bharatis for its right to exist
Israel doesn't beg Arabs for its right to exist.

Pakistan uses its strong military to enforce its rights.
Israel uses its strong military to enforce its rights.

So any Arab lackeys eyeing Israel,
Or any Bharati lackeys eyeing Pakistan.

Beware, our shoe will fall on your head if you are planning any pursuit hot or cold!

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

as usual, reactionary pakistanis dancing and chest thumping over "news" headlines penned by their own eminent journalists. nothing in what manmohan singh said hints at "punitive steps". anyhow, continue with the mujra.

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

^^ That’s true. My man-mohan Singh has not talked about punitive steps. The DT writer is just quoting **sources **in Dilli. That’s just yellow journalism.

However Bharati newspapers are also involved in yellow $hitey journalism. Almost all the news items immediately link the bombers to being Bharati-Muslims who “may have” visited Pakistan. Some may go as far as saying Pakistan’s military was “training” these Bharati Muslims.
http://www.itv.com/news/index_3ed8e915363fe27d04930b24cfabe929.html

So I guess journalists on the two sides of Pak-Bharat border are more like “generalists” creating anxiety and anger in the two countries.

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

:D

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

The world is too wrapped up with what is happening in the Middle East to listen to some Indian's ranting and raving about "punitive steps" against Pakistan.

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

yeh ok..

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

so did you hear back from the belted 'martyrs' about how many 'virgins' they actually got in their post blast harem? is it all at once or in weekly installments?

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

You lost every war with India, boy you are a glutton for punishment.

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

Ah yes, Indoos have won every war with musllas, pakis, chinis, hell! even commie dalits are on the run… Did I said only in reverse? :slight_smile:

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

Kuch jyada sense nahi kar rahen ho. Magar yeh tau aapki purani aadat hain.

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

For sense to penetrate one needs sense, but please continue your mujra… Thanks..

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

Bring um on, lets settle this once and for all...

Re: Mumbai blasts: India plans ‘punitive steps’ against Pakistan

after the creation of pakistan, the indians believed that pakistan was too weak to survive, and that sooner or later india will take over and pakistan will merge back with india.

as somebody said it before, pakistan is 10 times smaller than india. smaller economy, smaller navy, smaller army, smaller airforce. STILL, india hasn't been able to solve its "pakistan problem" in 60 years and after three wars, left its 10 times smaller enemy to make nukes, weapons, tanks and now fighter jets, it left it to come out stronger than ever.

if any thing those wars did, it only made pakistan stronger.

only God knows what would have happened to india if pakistan was equal in military and economy, or india was the size of pakistan and pakistan was the size of india. :)