Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
so what changed eating habits over a century? increased wealth or improved metabolism?
Raeess loag hamaisha sai lavish khana khatay hain.
Aur improved metabolism ? Vo kaisay.
Ab to bad food quality ki vajah say sehat aur metabolism kharaab ho rahay hain.
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
decreased health improve appetite?
Decrease apitite
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Raeess loag hamaisha sai lavish khana khatay hain.
Aur improved metabolism ? Vo kaisay.
Ab to bad food quality ki vajah say sehat aur metabolism kharaab ho rahay hain.
and still people are going for multiple dish option from single dish option.. kiya ye khulla tazaad nahin?
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Hai to.
MoTaapay main bhook ziyaada lagti hai. 
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
MeeThay ki talab ho rahi hai.
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Now hadith here
“The son of Adam does not fill any vessel worse than his stomach. It is sufficient for the son of Adam to eat a few morsels to keep him alive. If he must fill it, then one-third for his food, one-third for his drink, and one-third for air.” (al-Tirmidhi –saheeh by al-Albaani)
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Now hadith here “The son of Adam does not fill any vessel worse than his stomach. It is sufficient for the son of Adam to eat a few morsels to keep him alive. If he must fill it, then one-third for his food, one-third for his drink, and one-third for air.” (al-Tirmidhi –saheeh by al-Albaani)
It convey the same message, but I was talking about a different hadees
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
It convey the same message, but I was talking about a different hadees
Exactly there are hadith but not that one in my knowledge you mentioned, thats why i want to know for ilm only.
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Read somewhere a Hadees which says that a Muslim, whose dastarkhwan always have not more than one dish will be sent to paradise.
I don't think this is followed in any of the Muslim country now.
We heard from elders that in their childhood, people used to have lunch by having subh ki roti with lassi or piyaz.
So who promoted multiple culture within a century?
Is it increase in wealth / prosperity that lead to change in eating habits or people improved metabolism across the globe?
In my family, we mostly make one dish per day. So roti with saalan or rice with saalan or raita. We don't make sweet dish often. If someone feels like it, they eat fruit as a snack. Sometimes, when there is leftover food, we'll use it the next day.
It's the same when we go out as a family. A 3-course meal is just too much food. We order a couple dishes to share.
The only times when we splurge is when we are hosting a dawat. I tell my mom not to go overboard but she doesn't listen and usually throws a big spread (rice, naan, roast, kebabs, salad, raita, 1 or 2 saalans and 1 or 2 sweet dishes, etc.) which I think is a waste of food. No one eats that much. But she does it because there is the expectation that guests will take some leftover food home.
The thing that annoys me most is when people order tons of food at restaurants and when they can't finish, they just leave it there instead of taking the leftovers home.
Also, I have heard of families where lunch menu has to be different than dinner menu. Or 1 dish is not enough and there has to be a variety to choose from. That seems like a waste to me (unless they actually like pehelwans and are able to finish everything).
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
In my family, we mostly make one dish per day. So roti with saalan or rice with saalan or raita. We don't make sweet dish often. If someone feels like it, they eat fruit as a snack. Sometimes, when there is leftover food, we'll use it the next day.
It's the same when we go out as a family. A 3-course meal is just too much food. We order a couple dishes to share.
The only times when we splurge is when we are hosting a dawat. I tell my mom not to go overboard but she doesn't listen and usually throws a big spread (rice, naan, roast, kebabs, salad, raita, 1 or 2 saalans and 1 or 2 sweet dishes, etc.) which I think is a waste of food. No one eats that much. But she does it because there is the expectation that guests will take some leftover food home.
The thing that annoys me most is when people order tons of food at restaurants and when they can't finish, they just leave it there instead of taking the leftovers home.
Also, I have heard of families where lunch menu has to be different than dinner menu. Or 1 dish is not enough and there has to be a variety to choose from. That seems like a waste to me (unless they actually like pehelwans and are able to finish everything).
I'm still trying to find the reason for the change of eating habits of society as a whole. from piyaz / lassi roti to sabzi, gosht, daal, raita, meetha in one go. Pakistan is said to be the biggest importer of cooking oil and related raw material. kar lo gal.
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
I'm still trying to find the reason for the change of eating habits of society as a whole. from piyaz / lassi roti to sabzi, gosht, daal, raita, meetha in one go. Pakistan is said to be the biggest importer of cooking oil and related raw material. kar lo gal.
Obviously paisa and offcourse hotel.resturant culture where cant find signal dish. Pehly shadiun mein bhi sirf biryani qorma hota tha now, shadi achi wohi jis main hazaron dishes huin
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
it was my imaginary sasural 
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
I'm still trying to find the reason for the change of eating habits of society as a whole. from piyaz / lassi roti to sabzi, gosht, daal, raita, meetha in one go. Pakistan is said to be the biggest importer of cooking oil and related raw material. kar lo gal.
well, we are foodies. Nothing more to it.
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
well, we are foodies. Nothing more to it.
But we were not always like that.
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
We knew. 
Varna aisa sussraal sisf imagination ya wishful thinking main hi ho sakta hai. 
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Jab real mai ho jayega tab mai bataongi 
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Topic ,
I have read decades ago
Perhaps in Ghania tul Talibeen by Pir Abdul Qadir Jilani RA
Quoted to our holy prophet SA
don't remember the word but prohibited to mix the meals
Khanon ko mila kar mat khao
That means more than one dish was allowed
Re: Multiple dishes and Hadees e Nabavi
Topic , I have read decades ago Perhaps in Ghania tul Talibeen by Pir Abdul Qadir Jilani RA Quoted to our holy prophet SA don't remember the word but prohibited to mix the meals Khanon ko mila kar mat khao
That means more than one dish was allowed
Multiple dishes are not prohibited, but to follow simplicity is encouraged. I'm sure most of us here are aware of Prophet's (SAW) dua:
Al-Tirmidhi HadithHadith 5244 Narrated byAnas ibn Malik ; AbuSa'id
The Prophet (peace be upon him) said, "O Allah, grant me life as a poor man, cause me to die as a poor man, and resurrect me in the company of the poor." Aisha asked him why he had said this, and he replied, "Because they will enter Paradise forty years before the rich. Do not turn away a poor man, Aisha, even if all you can give is half a date. If you love the poor and bring them near you, Aisha, Allah will bring you near Him on the Day of Resurrection."