Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

I have observed that many people consider Mulla as a burden on society. They are blamed for keeping people away from religion instead of attracting towards religion.

I have also observed that parents normally send those children to Madarsa, whom they think are not able to survive in conventional education. There are sharp and intelligent religion scholars, but the majority of the Pesh Imam rendering Khutba and speech before Juma prayers emphasize on rituals. They don’t talk about current situation and when they refer to history Zaid becomes the owner of Bakr’s goat.

What do you think is the responsible for such situation? Mulla or society?

Are we ready today to send our children in Madarsas?

Are we satisfied with the Mullas having control over our Masajid?

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

:hayaa:

Itna inflammable thread…:smiley:

but we should remember that due to these ulemas our society has so much knowledge of islam…

we are way ahead of other religious groups as far as knowledge of our religion is concerned and credit goes to ulema…

IMHO madaris are best education institutes in the world…I had seen too many spoiled children turned gentlemen due to education of madaris…:slight_smile:

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

Point taken ninja :) But I'm not criticizing them, I just wanted to discuss who is responsible for making Mulla a liability on society.

How do you see the culture of sending less intelligent children to Madarsas?

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

I think this culture must be developed after increased importance of english language....

I think for development of this culture poor economical condition of small town and village mulla/imam is responsible...

In my town they earn less than a farm laborer................:(

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

Yes economically Mulla is backward compared to other professions. In English Period, Mulla was categorized as Kammi Kammen (lower cast). But the question again remained unanswered, why we have handed over an important thing like religion to such persons and didn't provide them with support (financial as well as moral) so that they can contribute positively. An economically dependent Mulla may give fatwa for Wajib ul qatl for any person.

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

Because economical support was compulsory then lot of greedy people might be ended up being Alim-e-din....

Thats what i think but in this era of economical growth we need prosperous scholars of Islam.....

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

But this economical suppression compelled Mulla to use religion for economic purposes. It started from chaska of Halwa and now reached getting finances for arms used for sectarian killings :(

This raises a question, do people avoid restriction of religion and therefore handover religion to the persons who can act according to their agenda?

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

Ist tell me who U consider Mulla

One wearing maya wala soot with a big tond

aur

One wearing average clothes and slim or average
:smokin:

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

I always feel that very few are true follower of shariah...otherwise all other are users of shariah..............:)

so i agree with your point that sometimes people manage poor alims by asking them to say what reach people want others to hear.....:)

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

ek jumla bas: society

agar society hippy ban jaaye to jo bhii laundromat kholegaa na to uskii chalegii, na uskii koii qadr o manzilat hogii aur na hii usko ahmiyat dii jaayegii!

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

The need of Madrassas is reform, they should revert back to teaching science, history, geography, languages etc, student having just religious education won't survive in competitive globalized world. Secondly there can be competitive exam on all the above subjects before teachers are appointed.Once madrassas start producing right results financial problems will also resolve:)

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

Janissary - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Once upon a time…madarees used to teach architecture,medicine,logic and as i heard as much as 57 ulum…

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

M.S. Mission School, Hasan Nagar offers Hifz-e-Quran Course. | Siasat

MQM High School

But we dont call them madarees only difference of nomenclature

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

Ninja. My saas got educated in Madrassa in Baramula, as there were no government school then, her mother was mathematics teacher there, now when I visited that place last time, hardly there were any talk about geography, economics, mathematics etc:). If muslim in India press for, both reform and funding of this is possible but just like any other indian community, Rushdie is our problem not poor education in general masses, if muslim community shows response and dharna pradarshan for education just like Rushdie even illiteracy will fade away:)

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

so was first president of india Dr.Rajendra Prasad was...............:)

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

And probably India's RAW's first spymaster:)

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

:eek: really…

Re: Mulla, Mazhab aur Muashira

I was told so by her daughter:) but when it comes to this organization I hardly believe in anything they say:)