Re: Muharram Starts!!! Some Important Questions to Ask (Exclusive)
Agree with you ... but you criticize *him for the *"Facts" *which i used to say *"Dastan-e-Ameer hamza" *almost all written by the **same iranis and iraqis shias **of ancient times in this *"hatred" *of **persian nationalism **as i have proved above from **your own sources *... so **indirectly, you are also criticize him as "Qissays" written in those books ....
I have no idea about 'Dastan e Ameer Hazma' and I dont give a damn about persian nationalism. I criticize those companions for their behaviour after the demise of the Holy Prophet (s). I believe I dont need to belabor exactly what they did. They are well known.
Shiaism, as you may be alluding to, was not a political movement - whatsoever. It was not the product of some legendary figure such as a Jewish rabbi nor was it the result of some 'fitna' which eventually resulted in the killing of hz Usman. If you analyze the history of Shiaism you will find that the foundations of 'Shiaism' were laid on purely religious grounds. No doubt there were hypocrytes who allied themselves with Ali a.s. for purely political reasons. Nevertheless Shiaism had ardent supports as well. So to conclude that 'Shiaism' originated from 'persian nationalism' is an oversimplification of a very complex history.
[quote]
In great detail :D
i have even never heard thier name from any shia..... are they not te sons of ali(ra) and hussain(ra) ... why not even name then.... The same *"formula" **of *"Taqiyya" **, my dear brother !!!!!
[/quote]
yeh IN great detail :) Ok so would you believe me that these names were mentioned in the recent majlis I attended?