Re: Mr. Jinnah's presidential address to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan
Well, well, we see the same mentality of Pakistani people in cricket and politics.
When a player fails they ask for his head, and when the replacement fails they want the sae player whom they wanted out to be back in the team.
You forgot to mention another side of Pakistani-Mentality that they don't see a matter from their own glasses but use those distributed for free. You have your views about Mr Jinnah because you never analysed Pakistan Movement and the persistent situation in this country, you have borrowed these ideas from the text books at schools and news articles - the propaganda machines.
Remember, heroes are carved in the same way as Mr Jinnah was made a hero; Shaykh Mujeebur Rehman is a Bengladeshi Hero, Columbus who was a pirate is a Western Hero.
[QUOTE]
Pakistan is best thing that happened to us. Muslims have neve been or could never be more than 1/3rd of Indian population. On top of that Muslims were poor, uneducated and discriminated against. What cud they have acheived. If Muslims cud really be happy in India, we wud never have seen teh Kashmir struggle.
[/QUOTE]
Well, so what is your achievement today in education in your Pakistan?
How many Muslims in Pakistan are rich without being the victim of discrimination?
And if you talk about Kashmir then know that your Father of the Nation agreed on Dogra's suggestion that he (the Dogra) will decide where Kashmir goes.
I mean, on what basis, you talk about Pakistan when this is one of the worst places in the world, with no security of life, wealth and honour.
[QUOTE]
The best buffer for Muslims of India wud be a strong Pakistan.
[/QUOTE]
So what your Strong and Atomic Pakistan did when Hindu Extremists were slaughtering Muslims in Gujraat and before that in Baabari Masjid riots?
[QUOTE]
Look at Israel, despiet being small it is strong and wields much influence in the region despite 20 bigger countries around us.
[/QUOTE]
Israel is not a SECULAR state as Mr Jinnah wanted Pakistan to be, Israel is a theocratic state, whose founders didn't work for British but they worked for their own Jews. That is why I say Jews and Christians are much better than the so called Muslims (Seculars), in many respects, whose job is to lick boots of their Western Masters.
[quote]
If we have failed despite getting a separate state, what wud have been chances of success if did not have one. If we have sucked as a country, don't blame the existance of country, that pathetic beyond beleif.
[/quote]
Well, Pakistan is a fact, you are seeing this for 60 years, you admit it is a failed state, with no rule of law, justice and peace, a heaven for corrupt people and criminals.
I don't disagree with you that there are chances, we can make this country better, and I am sure even those who opposed the creation of Pakistan before 1947, want a better and stronger Pakistan, but you have to see what ideas can bring us to the betterment. If they are those which Jinnah gave, then this is wrong, because Jinnah laid a wrong foundation of Pakistan with his sincerity towards the British.