Re: Mothers are more apathetic towards their children if they were CSDs
Peace Gemini the Great
Humans are capable of intuiting from the experiences of other people and learning from data. Bringing strange irrational arguments do not help furthering progress.
If being able to do something is the criteria for deciding whether or not it should be done in a certain way by others then you are effectively saying this:
Judges like Simon Cowell is not a valid judge for singing, because he cannot sing himself
Football coaches are not as a good as footballers for the strategies used on the field
Generals should not tell their armies where to fight from, because they are not on the front lines themselves
An ugly person is not qualified to talk about what is or is not beauty
A woman who can’t reach low notes in singing is not allowed to comment on the quality of a male bass vocalist
And so on
If I could give birth - I would choose the natural way and try to ease the pain whilst maintaining birthing efficiency as much as possible. I would not want to prolong labour, but I would also not want to compromise the health of the baby and I would seek out information that would help me make that decision. Because I genuinely feel for the safety of mother and child - I will not recommend something out of unnecessary intervention in case that an oversight causes issues.
Conversely I do not expect women to do the opposite of what I think is good purely because I am a man advocating a certain method and they wish to exercise their womanly judgment - that is best shown by doing the opposite of what is being advocated … Irrational responses are irrational and often wrong.