Mohsin Naqvi's aggression as a shia zakir

Code_Red · January 5, 2009, 9:39am

Was quite astounding.

I came across one such old recording of him speaking to large gathering in karachi ( late 80s /early 90s ) . His style was full of aggression ( just like Z A Bhutto ) and connection to common people , again like Zulfiqar Ali bhutto.
The later being one of great orator, I have seen in my life.

I saw a reflection of his style in Mohsin Naqvi :k:

Who is you favorite orator / public speaker ?

Nancy_Drew · January 5, 2009, 11:31am

Re: Mohsin Naqvi’s aggression as a shia zakir

BB’s style of addressing was powerful n dominating :k:

armughal · January 5, 2009, 12:34pm

Re: Mohsin Naqvi's aggression as a shia zakir

i read great orator in one go and had just another meaning which is also associated with bhutto(s)....

desert_bird · January 5, 2009, 1:27pm

Re: Mohsin Naqvi’s aggression as a shia zakir

Mohsin Naqvi who was a poet and murdered brutally by terrorists in Lahore ??

Code_Red · January 5, 2009, 1:45pm

Re: Mohsin Naqvi's aggression as a shia zakir

^. Yes. He was murdered in moon market ,Allama iqbal town Lahore. It was a sectarain target killing.

Likewise Late Ghulam Murtaza was also very good in his talks

People say that Moulana Tariq Jameel is a class apart. I have not heard him much, so cant rate him.

Dr. Israar is good in his lectures, he has great command on subject and supliments his pov with poetry and stuff, brilliantly.

Talib Johry is the only other shia zakir who i enjoyed listening some times...

desert_bird · January 5, 2009, 1:53pm

Re: Mohsin Naqvi’s aggression as a shia zakir

I love Mohsin Naqvi poetry, brilliant :k:

Nancy_Drew · January 9, 2009, 4:58pm

allama rasheed turabi was the best orator i've ever heard

desert_bird · January 10, 2009, 5:02am

Re: Mohsin Naqvi's aggression as a shia zakir

I have seen almost all shia zakirs mostly play with difficult words , flowery language without giving emphasis on Husayn(ra) philosophy. Talib Jauhry pick up some quranic verse , put some philosophical twist and then relate it with Ahle-Bait or Ali(ra).

Sunni ulema specially Dr. Tahir Qadri gives importance to Ahadess, true historical refrences and ideology of Husayn(ra)

X2 · January 15, 2009, 5:26pm

Re: Mohsin Naqvi's aggression as a shia zakir

henry V-

firenze · January 15, 2009, 6:06pm

Re: Mohsin Naqvi's aggression as a shia zakir

Adolf Hitler. Who else has been able to inspire a nation to do things that normally any civilized nation would never, ever do?

Second choice will be FDR & Sir Winston Churchill.

aqeel123 · January 16, 2009, 12:20am

i listened to both, Talib Johry Picks very good points from Quran however Tahair ul qadri picks ahadees some very good and sometimes the ones that are only found in sunni books, dont wana compare based on there beleives but Tahir-ul-qadri's lectures and his belief dont fall together !

I love the way Z A Bhotto talked, George Galloway, Ali raza Rizvi (the way he talks), Irfan Haider abdi, Tahir al Qadri is a good speaker, Ahmed al Nijat ( i hope i spelled him rite ) jeremiah wright ( obama's pastor ).