aap kii koshish achhi hai..lekin ghazal kii kuchh technicalities hoti haiN like radif, qafia, bahar etc..aap ne radif ka khyal nahin kiya hai es ghazal meiN...I just wanted to tell you nothing else..please don't take it otherwise we all are still learing here..
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Pramod: *
Dilsay sahab,
aap kii koshish achhi hai..lekin ghazal kii kuchh technicalities hoti haiN like radif, qafia, bahar etc..aap ne radif ka khyal nahin kiya hai es ghazal meiN...I just wanted to tell you nothing else..please don't take it otherwise we all are still learing here..
[/QUOTE]
First of all thanks for your advise and concern and second the things you have mentioned i have no clue what they are i just write joo dill main ata hai kabhi is batao ka khiyal nahi kiya aur karoo behi tu kasay jaab mujahay pata hee nahi... i am not a poet baas jo dil main ata hai lekh deeta hoon....
aap kay comments will help me and as well to those who think i am the poet.....
Pramod bhai. I think you are talking about Qafian and not the Radif.
Radif is “Chaltay” in this Ghazal. and Dilse bhai has used it.
But the problem I found with this Ghazal is the Rhythm. I am not saying that is not there, but I cant find it. There is a way everyone read poerty and while I am reading this Ghazal, my flow breaks at time.
But this could be my lack of understanding to Dilse bhai. :k: Good Job. Keep them comming.
wow dilsay:k::k::k: tumhare sub ghazals/nazams/shers mein se yeh mere fav ho gaye hai. its really deep and touchey:k:
keep it up and thanks for sharing:flower1:
Sorry ! I meant to say Dilsay sahab has not used Qafia correctly. Radif “Chalte” is fine but even if you see the first three ashars, the radif looks to be “kasay Chalte” which he left the last two shers. Even if I consider “Chalte” as radif, kafia is completely ignored in this whole ghazal. I just wanted to bring this into the notice of Dilsay sahab, in case he was interested.