MMA not trustworthy, says PPP - rule out cooperation

The PPP accepted General Zia’s constiutional changes when they first came to power in 1988, and have by their own admission been talking to the military since 2002, so this criticism is a bit hypocritical. But nevertheless it shows the level of antipathy between the two major opposition parties in Pakistan.


MMA not trustworthy, says PPP

The People’s Party Parliamentarians on Thursday declared the Muttahida Majlis-i-Amal (MMA) as “untrustworthy” and ruled out any possibility of cooperation between the two opposition alliances in future. “We are not ready to trust the MMA at all and cannot join them in any protest movement,” said PPP secretary-general Raja Pervez Ashraf and information secretary of the party’s Punjab chapter, Farzana Raja, while speaking at a news conference at the PPP media centre here. Mr Ashraf alleged that it was the MMA which had imposed a military general on the nation by extending its support to the government in the passage of the 17th constitutional amendment only to save their two provincial governments and to get the office of the opposition leader in the National Assembly. “The whole opposition was united in opposing the Legal Framework Order (LFO) of General Musharraf, but it was the MMA which stabbed it from back,” he alleged. The PPP leader said the nation could not forget the past of the MMA leaders who were directly responsible for the present crisis being faced by the country.

He said the MMA leaders through their acts had proved that they could not be trusted. He said that first they announced to quit the Balochistan government after the murder of Baloch nationalist leader Nawab Akbar Bugti, then said that they would resign from the National Assembly in protest against the passage of the Women Protection Bill and recently they had announced to boycott the proceedings of the National Assembly. However, he said, the MMA leaders did not implement any of the decisions. Mr Ashraf also flayed MMA chief Qazi Hussain Ahmed for his criticism on the PPP over the reports of a possible deal with the regime. “Qazi Sahab should know that the PPP never accepted ministries under military ruler General Ziaul Haq,” he said in his obvious hint to the Jamaat-i-Islami’s past decision of supporting the general. He said the MMA leaders always joined the present members of the Musharraf’s cabinet in criticizing the PPP. Mr Ashraf refuted all reports regarding any deal between the PPP and the regime. He said the federal ministers themselves claimed that the deal was about to be signed with the PPP and then they themselves denied such reports He said that Railways Minister Sheikh Rashid Ahmed had even made a claim that the deal would be finalised in three days. Mr Ashraf said the PPP leaders and activists would be present outside the Supreme Court building under the leadership of party president Makhdoom Amin Fahim to express solidarity with Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry and the protesting lawyers.Replying to a question, Mr Ashraf said the PPP could hold protest together with the Pakistan Muslim League (PML-N) on Friday, but not with the MMA.

http://www.dawn.com/2007/04/13/nat3.htm

Re: MMA not trustworthy, says PPP - rule out cooperation

The PPP has made a sensible decision to keep away from the MMA, and instead adopt a pragmatic stance in negotiating with the government. But that does not stop a desperate and constantly humiliated Nawaz Sharif from cosying upto to the mullahs.

MMA set to cash in on Benazir-Nawaz differences

By Rauf Klasra

LONDON: The Muttahida Majilis-e-Amal (MMA) leadership is set to gain political benefits from the sharpening differences between the two exiled prime ministers — Benzir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif —** as an electoral alliance, on the pattern of the Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI), is on the cards ahead of the coming general elections. The new alliance, comprising parties headed by Nawaz Sharif, Qazi Hussain Ahmed, Maulana Fazlur Rehman and Imran Khan, after seat adjustments, might contest the polls on a common platform both against the Pakistan People’s Party Parliamentarians (PPPP) and Pakistan Muslim League (PML) in the coming elections, said a political source. “For understandable reasons, if anyone is jubilant at the widening differences between Nawaz and Benazir after General Musharraf, this is the MMA leadership. “The religious leaders are set to get a timely pat on their backs before elections from Nawaz despite voting in favour of the general to stay as president and army chief,” confirmed a top source close to the PML-N camp. The source said Nawaz’s desperation to form an alliance with the MMA even after making massive compromises on his own principles —not to sit with those who were friends of Musharraf — can now be judged from the single fact that in the recent weeks, MNA Hafiz Hussain Ahmed is the third top leader of the MMA, after Maulana Fazlur Rehman and Senator Sajid Mir, who is now meeting Nawaz Sharif in London on Wednesday to further discuss the possibility of an alliance against pro-Musharraf parties, including Benazir’s. In her last week’s interview to Geo TV, Benazir for the first time indicated that her party might contest the coming elections independently, and above all, she was convinced she could sit with a uniformed general. This has convinced Nawaz to drift towards his old friends in the MMA with whom he feels more comfortable. “That is why, the tone of Nawaz was very aggressive and bitter in the following interview with Dr Shahid Masood in which he even declared that whosoever would negotiate with Musharraf was a traitor — an indirect indication towards (Benazir) Bhutto,” the sources said.**

The source said although differences between Nawaz and Benazir had been brewing for some time despite being signatories to the much trumpeted charter of democracy and their public statements of working together to get rid of dictatorship, they surfaced in public during their respective television interviews with Geo. The widening gap between Benazir and Nawaz has come as a major “political relief” to the MMA leaders ahead of the general elections, sources said, claiming the MMA leadership was in search of some space among the main political parties to revive its lost credibility and image in the public after it voted in favour of Gen Musharraf’s decision to stay as president and army chief. Strangely, Nawaz, who otherwise was very rigid towards those politicians who had sided with Gen Musharraf after his departure from Pakistan in 2000 and always declared them “traitors”, has a different set of policies towards the MMA. A source said the very fact that the MMA had voted in favour of an amendment that barred both Nawaz and Bhutto from becoming prime minister a third time was not even a serious issue anymore for Nawaz, who, otherwise, never failed to act as a “principled politician” who doesn’t make compromises, come what may. Instead, Nawaz remained hectically engaged in convincing Bhutto to give “legitimacy” to the MMA by incorporating it in the proposed grand opposition alliance in the name of getting rid of Gen Musharraf, forgetting his own tall claims of not accepting anyone who gave validity to a uniformed general, the sources said. But, the sources said, Benazir Bhutto always took the stance that the political forces could not forget “political crimes” and “betrayal” of the MMA when it voted in favour of Musharraf in parliament to validate his controversial Legal Framework Order (LFO). In return, Benazir, too, was ready to ditch Nawaz and replace the space created by the MMA and sit with Musharraf.** Sources said for Nawaz now “principles” did not matter anymore as he thought that the “past was past” and like a shrewd politician he should now exploit the existing political strength of the MMA and effectively build pressure on Musharraf. “It’s a marriage of convenience between Nawaz and Qazi Hussain Ahmed and the rest. Both have different political goals to achieve. MMA leaders badly want to emerge as a major opposition party despite being a strong ally of Musharraf in all these last seven years. In return, Nawaz desperately needs their power to return to Pakistan and deal with Musharraf and his cronies, including Bhutto,” a senior politician said.**

http://thenews.jang.com.pk/daily_detail.asp?id=51388