mistakes in recitation!!

[Tahurra]

Re: mistakes in recitation!!

@psyah

Ah yes …

For 1. Khamsatu is mubtada here … we know this because first of all the sentence starts with a zarf and zarf can never be mubtada. However the general rule is that mubtada should be ma’rifa, but when it is nakira is appears after the khabar so the zarf here … 'inda plus ya mutakillim are zarf mudaafun ilay shibhu jumla khabar muqaddam. Here the khabar has come before the mubtada to allow the mubtada to be nakira. The final way to know it is nakira is because of the mudafun ilay “kutubin” - as the mudaaf ilay is nakira the mudaaf of it follows from that.

Likewise, in No. 8 the Sab’atu is indeed the khabar and like before because the mudaafun ilay is nakira the mudaaf follows from that … it is also nakira.

MashaAllah Tahurra you are progressing well may Allah (SWT) increase you in knowledge too.

Perfect brother, jazakAllah i havent thought in this way…now got it..

Ameen at dua..may Allah give us barakah in our knowledge…
JazakAllah for help and will ask if i stuck any where in future..or near future inshaAllah

Wama tawfiqi illah billah at progress..alhamdulilah need duas and guidance