Re: Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani & IsLam
^^
the questions u are asking the basics of Qadyaniyat or Ahmadiyat u may call it. and these were the gateways of many other fakers like Mr. Mirza, some followers of those fakers still exist.
Anyway, The spriritual leader, the promised reformer is known as Imam Mehdi who is nothing more than a tale somehow penetrated in the traditions mostly from shia books in Sunni Muslim. and this very tale has produced many other religion from Islam it self, Qadyaniyat is a prime Example. There is no verse or Sahi hadess which call for this kind of reformer. i have proved that before i can prove this here, it is a lengthy and controversial topic and recommended for those who have wish to know the truth and follow the real path and not for those who according quran, follow some tradition because there ancestor followed it. so if anyone interested let me know, i'll initiate another thread on this topic only. I guess ur answer of REFORMER and SPIRITUAL leader has been answered.
As far as,Living and return of Masseeh is concerned, It is again a much debated issue, along with the above mentioned reformer, there are number of stances on the Life and death of Jesus (AS), again a lengthy and controversial debate... can be conducted if anyone interested.
But even if the above mentioned traditions have 1% truth in them, still Mr. Mirza is niether of them. as it is clearly mentioned in the tradtions and legends that, these are entirely different personalities, one will Land on earth, while Muslims forces in the leadership of The REFORMER preparing for the Battle with Dajjal, and the purpose of the 2nd one (reformer) is two bring the khilafah back to Ahl-e-Bait (a 1400 old Shia Dream)..
it is evident from the life of Mr. Mirza that, none of that happend, nor was the same circumstances, even according to those known traditions ( which are questionable in first place) one cannot prove him the promised massiha
yes one could have called him a reformer ( and as far as i know, he was called a reformer in his early days, like many other fakers who were known as promised massiha or the promised reformer), only if he had sticked to Quran and Hadees( by his words and actions) like the reformers before him did. none of them went and started their on kind of prophecies.
According to Islam, Quran is the only book, no other reformer will be sent to the people, preaching of ISlam is duty of Muslims, the preaching is not only to non-muslims but to muslims as well where one have to tell the difference between an islamic believe and some fake believe...