Re: Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani & IsLam
[QUOTE]
1. Promised Messiah (as) did nothing by call people back to Quran. You have to read his books to realize the great service he has done for the service of Quran.
[/QUOTE]
Please briefly define His services for Quran
[QUOTE]
2.Promised Messiah (as) wrote 100+ books.. None of them are considered scripture by any means. Even his revelations are not considered scripture...
[/QUOTE]
Well Look what Mr. Mirza has to say about that;
" aur Khuda ka kalaam iss qadr mujh per (nazil) howa hay kay agr woh tamaam likha jaye tu 20 juz say kam nahi hota ( Rohani Khazain)
Now it is contradictory Issue within the qadyanies as well,
earlier Mr. Mirza and his Companions use to say that Like Prophet Haroon (AS) Mr.Mirza also didn't had a book.
Then Mr. Mian Mehmood Ahmed said, One cannot be a prophet who do not have Shairat. and Qadyanies are in middle of no where, some time they declare Brahin-e-Ahmadia as their book and some time Khutba-e-Ihamia and sometime Albushra.
So in a Annual Convention, Mr. Mian Mehmood, ordered to gather all the "ilhamat" of Mr. Mirza and asked the followers ( qadyanies ) to recite them, and finally concluded that their is no Quran but the one revealed on Mr.Mirza...
( Ajra-e-Nabuwat ka fitna-e-Azeem, by Dr. Basharat Ahmed Qadyani)
[QUOTE]
4. There are two main purposes of Prophets. a. To bring scripture and b. To implement scripture. Only a few propehts brought shariah.. The rest were only there to implement the current Shariah.
[/QUOTE]
No doubt about it!!! Not all the prophets are the one with Shariah. but there were some common characterstics of the Prophets ( to which we will come later in this discussion), which Mr. Mirza Lacked.
[QUOTE]
5. The purpose of Mirza Sahib's prophecy was to renovate the faith and revive the last Shariah sent for mankind.
[/QUOTE]
Now here is Contradiction ( thats y i never answered the Quranic Verse ( sura-e-Noor) u mentioned earlier in this post), the same task ca be done by Imams, then y a Prophet is required? and it is evident from the history if Islam that Imams have done it ( all the four Imams of Ahl-e-Sunnah, and many others are there), little before and/or same time of Mr. Mirza, few were in the subcontinent, and it was there efforts which saved Muslims from losing their faith and tradtions. None of them, accepted the Prophet-hood of Mr. Mirza.
(there is a law kind of thing in Qura-e-Yaseen, if more than one prophets exist in his time, and how their prophet-hood is verified from the Imams/wali of that time. We don't see that in the lifetime and after the life of Mr. Mirza.
[QUOTE]
6. achievements of Promised Messiah (as): Defense of Islam. Defeating christianity. Reviving the true ISlam which was covered up in dust of centuries.
[/QUOTE]
How and where? details please
[QUOTE]
7. Prophets are the guided persons of their times. Intelligence does not necessarily mean that the person will be guided one as well.. Abul Hakam was Abu Jahal too..
[/QUOTE]
Later in this post, we will check from the evidences that how much Mr. Mirza was divinly guided.