Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

**Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill
POSTED: 1:12 p.m. EST, November 8, 2006 **

MINNEAPOLIS, Minnesota (CNN) – In a political first, a Muslim has been elected to serve in the U.S. Congress.

Keith Ellison, a Minnesota state legislator and lawyer, reached the political milestone by defeating two other candidates in Minnesota’s 5th Congressional District, which covers the Minneapolis area.

His victory was part of the Democratic wave that seized control of the House of Representatives from the Republicans.

Ellison won 56 percent of the vote, defeating Republican Alan Fine and the Independence Party’s Tammy Lee, both of whom garnered 21 percent of the vote. A Green Party candidate received 2 percent.

With 99 percent of the precincts reporting, Ellison received 135,519 votes, Fine 51,896, and Lee, 51,250.

Ellison is also the first African-American from Minnesota to be elected to the U.S. House. He ran on the Democratic-Farmer-Labor ticket in a district that is heavily liberal.

Members of that party, a uniquely Minnesotan movement, describe the DFL as the state chapter of the Democratic Party.

**Ellison’s winning platform
Ellison’s views reflect Democratic ideals and discontent. **

He is opposed to the war in Iraq and on his Web site, he has called “for an immediate withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq.”

“I opposed the war before it began. I was against this war once it started and I am the only candidate calling for an immediate withdrawal of troops.”

His religious message is one of inclusiveness.

Regarding his Muslim faith, he said, “people draw strength and moral courage from a variety of religious traditions.”

“Mine have come from both Catholicism and Islam. I was raised Catholic and later became a Muslim while attending Wayne State University. I am inspired by the Quran’s message of an encompassing divine love, and a deep faith guides my life every day.”

Ellison’s position on the Israeli-Palestinian issue is supportive of the two-state solution and the road map to peace process. He has been critical of the Hamas movement.

“Peace is necessary for both Israeli and Palestinian people, and I wholeheartedly support peace movements in Israel and throughout the region,” he said in a statement on his Web site.

He was endorsed by the Twin Cities newspaper, the American Jewish World, which said, “In Ellison, we have a moderate Muslim who extends his hand in friendship to the Jewish community and supports the security of the State of Israel.”

Ellison is pro-choice and pro-labor, and supports “universal single payer health care” – long popular stances among liberals.

The seat Ellison won had been held by Rep. Martin Olav Sabo, the longtime Democratic incumbent, whose retirement sparked a wide-open race. Sabo won 70 percent of the vote for the House seat in 2004.

The most trusted name in news… CNN :smiley:

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

EDITED: American NEWS sensor media.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

This is good news...
however I don't understand how a muslim can be pro-choice..abortion is haram in Islam...
??

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

He is also pro-gay rights so you should judge him as a bad Muslim since you guys are perfect Muslims.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

no its not.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

utd u are right

i think ppl are ovrlooking the fact that votres elected a muslim. This is not a debate about how good or bad of a muslim he is by any specific person's viewpoint.

I wondered which party would send a muslim to capitol hill, and dems did it first. the fielded him and they won. It says something about the party as well as the voters and ppl supporting that party.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

I bet if he had run in the district of Jackson Heights, he had little chance to win. Good thing its MN.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

no point in arguing with the most "jhagraloo" person on GS - but as the issue stands, it is not allowed in islam and to be clear in sunni islam. The only case where some scholars allow it is when it is a clear danger to the life of the mother and other conditions apply.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

just because I am not going to take half baked statements as divine truth, sure call me jhagraloo. as long as I can then call you something too :wink:

it is also allowed in the cases of rape and incest.

so a blanket coment that abortion is not allowed, as your highness made, was too general, and completely false.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

No, only you are perfect. All Muslims are bad, specially the ones who don’t agree with neo-cons.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

MF ..:alhamd: u proved my point again…

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

yawn whatever. in future refrain from passing statements that are only half true :) I know it may hurt when someone corrects you and shows the error in your blanket statements and thus making your posts about me rather than the issue at hand. But you making statements about me rather than the issue at hand proves my point :)

shabash

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

you have no understanding of rulings of shariah...
you only argue..
how else to talk about the matter at hand..
when some one is just filling the threads with their own arguments that have no base in shariah rulings?

The basic rule is that "abortion is not allowed"
This is the basic rule. Can we say from this that a muslim is pro choice?
No, a muslim is against abortion. This would be in the light of the contemporary perceptioon of people. Where a girl will have sex and get preganant and then to save her name she will want to get an abortion. This is the context. Not the detailed mind twisting that you alway try to get into.

So for any one us to say we are pro choice mean we are negating the basic rule.
Then if some one asks a "what if" situational question then you say yes islam allows it under such and such conditions.
For example a person is not allowed to kill some one. So the law is that a person cannot kill another free person in society. But if a person kills someone in self defence and they had no other choice, then the court will let them go. Does that mean the court should call itself pro-murder from this?

So my dear Mr. F, you are lost in your maze of construed thiking and analysis where as the matter is simpler.
Jazak Allah Kher. And please go an and say whatever you want now.

Any further talk on this does not belong in this thread...

We all appreciate that a muslim has been elected and InshAllah it will give some voice to muslims in congress. See my original post.

Salams.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

Antumul alona nay farmaya..

you have no understanding of rulings of shariah...

sure I dont, but then you are not some qualified sheikh either.

*you only argue.. *

I argue when I see an erroneous statement, which yours was..

*The basic rule is that "abortion is not allowed"
This is the basic rule. Can we say from this that a muslim is pro choice?
No, a muslim is against abortion. This would be in the light of the contemporary perceptioon of people. *

what you stated was that 'abortion is not allowed' which is an inaccurate statement. if someone was reading it it would read as a universal truth from an islamic perspective. had you qualified it by adding the statement "unless mothers liufe is in danger, or it is because of rape or incest, or because the child is deemed unviable etc" then your statement would be true.

*Where a girl will have sex and get preganant and then to save her name she will want to get an abortion. This is the context. Not the detailed mind twisting that you alway try to get into. *

I am not going into any detailed mind twisting. I am just pointing out a flaw in your statement which is flawed no matter which way you look at it.

*So for any one us to say we are pro choice mean we are negating the basic rule. *

Islam is pro-choice under a number of circumstances, do you understand the basic difference in the arguments of pro-choice and pro-life politics? the pro-lifers dont want abortions...period.

*Then if some one asks a "what if" situational question then you say yes islam allows it under such and such conditions. *

No, you dont wait until someone asks a what if question. It does not kill anyone to edit their initial statement in a way that says "Islam prohibits adoption except in certain scenarios" .. that is a more accurate statement.

*For example a person is not allowed to kill some one. So the law is that a person cannot kill another free person in society. But if a person kills someone in self defence and they had no other choice, then the court will let them go. Does that mean the court should call itself pro-murder from this? *

speaking of mind twisting, there you go

*So my dear Mr. F, you are lost in your maze of construed thiking and analysis where as the matter is simpler. *

Indeed the matter is simpler, your statement was not accurate and especially in the context of this discussion was meant to misdirect..

Jazak Allah Kher. And please go an and say whatever you want now.

I said my piece

Any further talk on this does not belong in this thread...

good approach :)

*We all appreciate that a muslim has been elected and InshAllah it will give some voice to muslims in congress. See my original post. *

not all, it appears some are already beginning to question his musalmaniyat :)

Salams.

Wa aalaikum As-salam wa Rehmat Allah e wa Barakatahu

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

Talk about a digression in discussion! the news of a Muslim making it to Capitol Hill was pleasant sounding to say the least.

I hate to add to the sidetrack argument on abortions but just thought I’d add my dow aaney worth of say…

The fact remains that although there is no actual approval of abortion in the world of Islam, there is no strict, unanimous ban on it, either! Most people just interpret Islam’s disapproval of killing other humans, and extrapolate that to the issue of abortion as well.

From what little I know from readings on the various fiqhs, both the Hanafi and the Shafi schools allow abortions to take place until the 120th day; and the Maliki and Hanbali schools deem abortion to be permissible with the consent of both parents up to day 40. Furthermore, all schools also provide “good cause” provisions including those already mentioned by Fraudia.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

^ no one disagrees with that Umar. its how some one perceives a "slogan". There is no pro choice slogan in Islam. It is if any a "pro life" one for most cases. Kher its always nice to hear from you.

Re: Minnesota voters send first Muslim to Capitol Hill

A good development, I think.

Regarding the abortion issue, whatever one's personal beliefs, the pro-choice argument IS NOT pro-abortion. It simply allows for choice. Though some people believe abortion is illegal in Islam, that doesn't mean that a representative has the right to impose that personal belief on others.

You can believe in one thing while allowing others to make their own choice.