Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Wah ji..Roshan khyals at their best.

Mohsin Babbar

ISLAMABAD: The National Assembly witnessed uproar on Tuesday following a controversial interpretation of a Quranic verse by Dr. Sher Afgan Niazi, federal parliamentary affairs minister, saying “men are authorised to thrash wives having bad character”. The statement and its subsequent endorsement by some Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal lawmakers, especially Liaquat Baloch and Maulana Chitrali, were so provocative that all the women MNAs set aside their political associations to show a rare harmony against this wrong interpretation of Quranic verses. Representing the disgruntled lot, Samia Raheel Qazi, the daughter of MMA chief Qazi Hussain Ahmad said, “There is no explicit verse in the Quran that directs men to beat their wives, even if they are of bad character.” But this was not endorsed by her fellow male MNAs. In fact, the uproar was seen after MNA Sherry Rehman from the opposition benches moved a bill, The Prevention of Domestic Violence Bill 2006 for discussion in the House. And once the bill was tabled, National Assembly speaker Chaudhry Amir Hussain asked parliamentary affairs minister Dr Sher Afgan whether or not he was opposed to the tabled piece of legislation. Strongly opposing the bill, Afgan created a stir in the House by declaring that the bill “goes against the basic principles of the Holy Quran and Sunnah”, arguing “under the Islamic laws, a man is authorized to thrash his wife if she is of bad character or not loyal to him”. “If she does not change conduct, her husband is allowed to bash her again and even he has the powers to throw her out of the house by divorcing her,” Afgan maintained.

As Afgan was going ahead with his wrong interpretation of Quranic verses, MNA Maulana Chitrali of the MMA raised slogans in the minister’s favour and assured him of “complete support of the ulemas” on the matter by visiting him in person.

Also a good lawyer, PPPP MNA Aitzaz Ahsan defended the bill that according to him ensures provision of equal rights to men and women as mentioned in Article 25 of the Constitution. Proposing voting on the issue whether the bill should be debated in the House or not, he remarked, “Let’s see who is with the wife-bashers and who is not.”

Seeing the things going out of his control, the speaker called Liaquat Baloch for help. But instead of helping the speaker, Baloch stoked up the pandemonium by stating while raising his fingers towards protesting women MNAs that “these are the women against which Islam has given the bashing verdict.”

But on being directed by the speaker, Baloch made an apology. However, the protesting MNAs turned their guns towards Afgan. Making a wise move, the speaker ordered voting on the discussion on the bill and there came a majority vote in favour on the debate that will take place in next private member’s day on Tuesday.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

how do such jahils get into the government??

don't people have to be educated and qualified to be members of parlaiment? i'm not too sure of how the pakistani political system works, but it seems like anyone can become a politician.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

He's in good company. Many on gupshup also will say the same thing.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Dr. Sher Afgan Niazi,
He is an enlighted Muslim like our Mushy,Graduate+,(dont know where he bought his degree)but he has no manners.Just a silly and fool.
We need a big change,otherwise we have same peoples again and again in pakistani politics and government.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Zakk, using internet forums to vent out your repressed frustration is sick, to put it simply. It's as if you sift through all the media coverage which comes out of Pak, and post the vilest to satisfy your inner angst against this nation. Mind quitting this Pakistani forum as well?

Ever heard of something called a "troll"?

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Yeah, brush everything under the carpet, blame others for your faults, we are the chosen ones.....

Sher Afghan represents the male dominated society of Pakistan, what he said probably was just what the male egoist in Pak wud love to hear.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

FG I think stalker supports spousal bashing?

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

I am at a loss with Asian/Islamic culture.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

The sad reality is that the people elect representatives who reflect their views. I wonder, were you to poll Mr. Afgan's constituents, whether or not a majoprity of them would in fact endorse his views.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

In all of these incidents Islam gets the blame. He is a Federal Minister for crying out loud, for one of the most secularist regime in the history of Pakistan, and Islam gets the blame. Why dont people ask General Musharaf if this is how he wants to promote his moderately enlightened Islam. But you know what, General Musharaf can not say a word to people like this, because he need them to stay in power.

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Musharraf is not a secularist in the true sense. He just pretends to be for the sake of the West.

And did you notice that some of the MMA people agreed with Niazi?

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

The MMA believe that, thats why they are with Niazi, but do you think that one who pretends to be something for his own sake (rule) is better than the one who speaks his mind?

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Goras beat their wives or vice versa more than any one else. So what is the fuss? If gori cheat her husband she gets not only beating but also shafting through courts in divorce cases. What Quraan says about how to deal spousal cheating is universal. I don't find any thing different what others do in spousal cheating.

FARID

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

Goes to show you the mistreatment of women and the overall mysoginstic behavior has very little to do with Mullahs, but the deep ignorance, general psyche and cultural inherent in some ethnicities in Pakistan...

Re: Minister says: Men can thrash wives having bad character

and wat about the men having bad character? :rolleyes: