Milk after eating fish

Did your parents ever tell you that you can get vitiligo (pale spots on skin) if you drink milk after fish?

I was told that all my life. I’m not sure if I believe it, but I WOULD NEVER drink milk after just in case.

I know its an idiopathic autoimmune disorder (that is we’re not sure about the a cause- we know its autoimmune though). Do any you have vitiligo? (it effects one percent of the population). Do you think it was caused by the milk-fish?

I ask this, because I’ve recently been seeing a lot of desis with this…

Re: Milk after eating fish

It doesn't have anything to do with milk and fish. Now there are some types of fish that may cause stomach indigestion if taken with milk due to protein interaction, but that't it. It doesn't cause spots or any such disorders.

Anyhow, my kids each fish a lot and drink milk right after. They are OK, no issues, even digestive. Same in my case.

Re: Milk after eating fish

I don't know specifically of any cases where the correlation between milk and fish has resulted in pigmentation disorders and neither has it been proven.

The milk/fish consumption rumour originates from Jewish belief. Strict Jewish observers do not mix the two during the same meal and tend to keep even the dishes they use for these two foodstuffs seperate. This is in accordance with Jewish dietary laws.

Yh some ppl told, i wonder if its true or not? :hmmm:

Re: Milk after eating fish

I am lactose intolerant so I do not even drink direct milk.

Re: Milk after eating fish

I think this stereotypes comes from the fact that during the fish's breeding season, they produce this chemical that causes vitiligo. Don't know about other countries but that's why Canada has banned fishing during summer months, i.e. their breeding season.

You guys correct me if I'm wrong. Thanks.

Re: Milk after eating fish

Humm dar kay maray risk naheen letay.

Re: Milk after eating fish

I don't eat fish because of the smell...and the way fish looks..i.e. before death/after death un cut..and when i do eat thora sa because my parents force me, then i don't drink milk or eat it with yogurt which is how i normally eat my food.

Re: Milk after eating fish

:hmmm:

Re: Milk after eating fish

i've been told that too, i don't believe it since there's no scientific evidence for it, but i still dont want to take any risk. so i never drink milk/yoghurt with fish :)

There is a specific fish which is commonly used in Pakistani dish of fried fish. If you drink duud patti or direct milk? then you get vitiligo.

My meternal far-family relatives doughter got it for some reason after eating fish and having milk under 24 hours.

Thats why I never had fish nor direct milk. Even tought both are individually taken for certain strength.
I do love shrimps crabs and lobsters though...wo duud ke saath bhi mix kiye jaa saktay hain.

Re: Milk after eating fish

My mother forbids me of that.I dont want white spots on my face so there is no harm in taking precautions

If your mom says it, and she's originally from the subcontinent then its most likely superstition i.e. a wife's tale.

Re: Milk after eating fish

Its only a myth. There is no scientific proof of vitiligo and consuming milk and fish together or one after other have any relation.

Yougurt and milk are used commonly with fish all over the world and specially yougurt is used in Pakistan to marinate fish.

Vitiligo has many reasons and one explanation is that it is autoimmune disease against melanin (pigment) producing cells.

Re: Milk after eating fish

I was told not to take angRa'ee (stretch yourself) after eating werna sara khana tumhaaray pait se kuttay ke pait main chalaa jataa hai ..

I even remember sketching a picture of me strecthing myself and food from my tummy transfering to a dog's tummy in the form of a dotted line connecting both our tummies

Re: Milk after eating fish

^^^ :omg:


Feel sorry for the poor dog. Your potty in his tummy. Arghhh!!!! Dog is the innocent victim in all this. :(

Dard kah mary lasi pee sakty hain

hmmmm yeah ..I have two real characters for younger brothers and when we were kids they would eat and then stretch and ask me..hey..you must be full now. yeah?

Re: Milk after eating fish

^^^ :omg:

So were you :faizy: