milaad

[TLK]

Re: milaad

@AikPakistani

I respect your opinion. Though, by that broad definition of Biddat, all six books of hadith collection including Sahih Muslim and sahih Bukhari, fall into the category of Biddat (innovation).

Hazrat Abu Bakar compiled about 3000 hadees that he later destroyed with the fear that what if he quoted something wrong. Hazrat Abu Hurraira lived with prophet for many years and recorded every hadess (6000 on his credit), plus remember that i used the word of ‘need’ in my deifnition and there was no need to compile hadees in book form during the life of prophet.

@aqeel123

Again y not only times of Prophet s.a.w ? why later in time of Sahaba, wasnt islam complete at times of Prophet s.a.w ? … the means were available, there was a need of a leader after Prophet s.a.w as Prophet s.a.w knew he wasnt gona stay in this world for long, but if Prophet didnt appoint one, then for rest Appointing a caliph wud be bidah !

Sahaba; because they lived with prophet so if they were the best followers and role models for all of us. If they did not do anything, there is no need for us to do.

BTW, my argument is going to clash with your basic beleif so I am not going to further argue on Caliphs comment of yours but Prophet did appoint Abu Bakr as the next leader of ummat. When he asked Abu Bakr to lead the prayers during his last times, he indicated that Abu Bakr is going to be the next caliph