Members of One Body

So, some of you may know how I love my ‘editorial and opinion’ sections of newspapers… so, here’s a little ray of sunshine to add to the already very very sunny day:

I fail to understand why Muslims are expected to openly distance themselves from and condemn perpetrators of violence who happen to be Muslim. They are no mor responsible for the terrorists than I am for the behaviour of the BNP and other white racists. It is for all of us to condemn, as one community. When we yoke all Muslims together and imply their difference from other British citizens we are racist ourselves.
Julia West, Wallingford, Oxforshire
Friday 15 July 2005, The Independent

Not to say that it is wrong to condemn the bombers - but the woman has a point… :blush:

Re: Members of One Body

very well said - which newspaper? Im a guardianite.

Re: Members of One Body

the independent... i'm not in the habit of buying newspapers usually - my mum buys this one quite regularly but i'm not such a big fan of it... i like the guardian too :)

Re: Members of One Body

My dad buys the times and the daily mail to bug me.

Re: Members of One Body

:flower2: sigh if only this applied to the masses

Re: Members of One Body

hiccup… would bug anyone :rolleyes:

phati… you’re right, it’s a case of small fish in a big pond :bummer:

Re: Members of One Body

Well said and in the best paper in UK. I switched from Times to Independent during the Iraq war.

Re: Members of One Body

Yeah, some of the stuff is really controversial and you just gotta take it with a pinch of salt :blush:

Re: Members of One Body

Huggable woman. :hug:

Muslims in the UK are really getting it from a lot of people now, it didn’t really effect us when it was the WTC or Madrid because the Brits just didn’t give a fcuk, it was like a joke to most of them, but now that it’s on their own soil it’s personal and Muslims are having an hard time in this country, even most of the otherwise good people are turning into knobs.

Re: Members of One Body

i know… i have first hand experience of it :bummer:

Re: Members of One Body

The ‘members of one body’ approach isn’t going to fly any more. I know The Times has become quite right wing these days but this article surprised me in it’s anger. You can almost feel the vitriol rising from the page:

Re: Members of One Body

^^ I know what you mean... there was something similar in The Independent too

There's no fighting with the ignorant I'm afraid

Re: Members of One Body

These are hardly ignorants, these aren’t tabloids, they are writers for respected newspapers. Not sure why Birchill’s brought such a racial element into this subject but it’s interesting nonetheless.

Re: Members of One Body

Ouch article.

Re: Members of One Body

Just because they are writers of respected newspapers doesn't mean that they're not ignorant - we all are ignorant to some extent, some more than others

hiccup....... ouch is right

Re: Members of One Body

I just realised what it must be like to be a Muslim in India.

I want to go to Pakistan, untill then I'm a Latino. :p

Re: Members of One Body

It’s not like what she says doesn’t have SOME truth to it, but I kinda object to a few individuals having the strength to paint a whole community by their actions. Plus she sounds like she’s ready to let loose with a grenade launcher at Bradford which can’t be healthy.

Re: Members of One Body

Islamofacist. bearded men. dead infidels...that too coming from a somehwat respectable paper..wow good job...this is just going to further alienate the brits muslims...

Re: Members of One Body

another reason brit muslims are going to take more heat is cuz the bombers were actually british..they were bron & bred there..in contrast to 9/11 where the suicide bombers came from Saudia..Brits muslims need to fix themselves and quick..

Re: Members of One Body

It goes both ways Lussi. In my opinion the European model of multiculturalism with no emphasis on integration is also to blame as much as the mindset of some fundo muslims. If you do not allow for cultures to integrate, make it fkin mandatory, conditional for entry and living in the land...**** like this owuld happen. Look at the muslim populations in the Uk and France and Germany and even Denmark. Highly ghettoized, kept in their own cocoons all the in the name of multiculturalism. How many people do british guppies know in Bradford or Luton or parts of Manchester where you see people who can hardly speak english, even after being in the coutry for over 20-30 yrs?