Yaad rahkiye ga Pakistan ke Tahrikh koi mamooli Tarikh na thi yea on 8 crore muslim ke awaaz thi Jo ek Aisi Mumlikaat chahtay thai Jahaan Islami Shariyaat Nafiz kar sakayeen Woh main appp ko bata doon ga ke yahaan shariyaat kion nafiz na hoo saki aur is ke kitny zarooraat thi.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Re: Maudodi Sahab
No one should take Maududi serios, he is notorious for criticising the Sahabas, even Prophet.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Not only Prophet and sahaba he also criticized Allah in 1 of his books i will also post it
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Ok. would you please post some references -
all these articles are from a book (i guess) and we don't even know the auther - maybe the auther is a biased one.
Because I've read a couple of his books and those were very well-written.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
I m giving all refrences of his books
Musalmaan Aur moojada sisyaasi kashmakash Hissa Soom Aur doom
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Because I've read a couple of his books and those were very well-written.
Maudodi sahaab was mentally Ill person.Jaab pakistab baan gaya tu in ko politics main paisa nazar aayaa pahlay tu in hoonay ek scheme soochi ke politics main Loogo ke himmayaat Kaisay hasil ke jaye in hoonay is ke liye Islam ka sahra liya kion ke pakistan hasil is liye kia gaya tha ke pakistan main islami shariyaat nafiz ke jaa sakay.App agar in tahreer ghoor se parhain gaye tu khud samjh ajayee ga wase bhi Maudodi sahaab Koi parhay likhay adami thai hi nahi Bus woh Kitaboo ke siyasaat karty thai matlab yea ke on hoonay riwayaati siyasaat ke jo ke humhari Riwayoot Main Hazat Ali ke sooraat main IZbah ikhtilafh ke sooraat main ayee thi in hoonay Hazat Ali ke shaan main bhi bhoot ghoostakiyaan ke thi Pahlay in ko Kashmir ka jahaad Ghair islami laga phir daikha ke Tahrikh ko is ke naam per bara chanda mil sakta hai tu college aur university main Jahaad ka Naaraa lagaya.Financially toor per is ko mazbood kia abhi bhi daikh lain Agar country main Danga fasaad karaana hoo Jamaat ko Sirf Islami tahreekh nazar aty hai Islam ke naam per hi yea danga fasaad karty hai.Yea Quid e Azam Ko kafir e Azaam kahtay thai.Abu ALa Maudodi ke naam KA matlab Hai ALLAH KA BAAP nazobillah is waja se Dr israr sahab Jamat e islami se ALaag hoye thai aur Aiman ISlahi aur Jawed Ahmed Ghamdi sahaab aur in hoonay barmala kaha tha ke Yea Adami zahni beemaar hai.Aur tu Aur Haider Maudodi sahaab jo ke in ke farzand hai ek dafa kaaha tha ke mere Walid nay 120 kitabain Tahreer ke thi jin main se 80 books woh humhe read hi nahi karnay daitay thai jis main Jahad sarfariz tha.Mere Mulk ke noojawanoo k liye Jahad ka toofa aur Apni ulaad ke Liye AMerican Taleem is hi policy per Humhare Qazi sahab bhi karam farma hai in ke bhi bachoo ne america se taleem hasil ke aur yea America ke sab se zada khilaf hai.Yea muslim ke shakaal main Muafiq
Allah maf karay
Re: Maudodi Sahab
another person jealous of maududi (ra)....
why do u hate him and lie against him????
if u and the mullahs u follow cud not achieve even half of what maududi (ra) did in his life, does not mean that u start such propagandas agsint him....
Re: Maudodi Sahab
why do u hate him and lie against him???? if u and the mullahs u follow cud not achieve even half of what maududi (ra) did in his life, does not mean that u start such propagandas agsint him....
Why would i hate him?i m just presenting illness thoughts and work yea tu khud in ke zindagaye kah rahi hai mainne apni taraf se kuch kaha hi nahi.By te way i tell u that Maudodi sahab was not a Alim e din he was Just a writer who only seems his jamaat favour in ever aspect chahay woh din hoo yea duniya
Re: Maudodi Sahab
yaar no body is perfect and every one passess through his crisis of confidence in Allah and life after death when someone embarks on this journey so did he as per his interview in Urdu digest. so he must have committed mistakes, however i think give him some leverage, he was not that a bad person
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Agar App Aag ko Aag aur PAni ko Pani nahi kahaoo gaye tu yea app ka kasoor hai aur App borayee ko borayee nahi kahaoo gaye tu is ka hisaab dia jaye ga maine tu woh halaat bata raaha tu jo ke pakistan ke Tarikh Main Mullaaoo nay kiye Aur Maudodi sahaab nay islam k libada urh kar aisi kahrafaatein k jis k misaal hi nahi milty
Re: Maudodi Sahab
ok, i am not from jimaat nor a mullah however i must ask you one thing
do not take your impressions about any one for granted, truth lies somewhere in between.
then we should not spare even quaid-e-azam muhammad ali jinnah from criticism, he did mistakes as well. mullah's had a principled stand that you cannot leave a large percentage of muslims in india to make an islamic state of pakistan, either all get it or no one gets it in the name of islam, get it in the name of geography not islam
Re: Maudodi Sahab
do not take your impressions about any one for granted, truth lies somewhere in between.
then we should not spare even quaid-e-azam muhammad ali jinnah from criticism, he did mistakes as well. mullah's had a principled stand that you cannot leave a large percentage of muslims in india to make an islamic state of pakistan, either all get it or no one gets it in the name of islam, get it in the name of geography not islam
My brother why Quid e azam left thickly populaed area of muslim in india because stupid thinking of mulla's at tht time.u know when sir syed was calling muslim to learn english and science subject whole party stood againt him give him a fatwa tht Sir syed is kafir and the learning of english subject and Science subject were also come in same league.Abb bataoo yaar k yea mullah ka dimagh tha Sub continent main
Mullah ke door sirf masjid taak hi achi hai
Woh kafir sir syed kia kar gaya pata hai humhe ek pakistan day gaya na Ali garh se parhay likhay muslim nikaaltay na Tahrikh pakistan main in k soooch se pakistan milta Aur tu Aur in ko Kafir qaraar dainay ke liye Mullah Makkah aur madinay taak pooch gaya sahaab hum main ek Munkir hai jo muslim ko Engrazi taleem dilana chahta hai is ke khilaf fatwa tu day dain
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Imranjaff..name me one scholar in modern history who had absolutely no faults in his methodology or in his aqeedah or the way in which he lived...and who was not hated by anyone.
The time you spend slandering and defaming scholars...if you'd take the good what Maududi had to offer, you'd be a much better person.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
imran you are right and wrong both!
You know what Aligarh university had to say about creation of Pakistan, they grouped their scholars in 1944 to come up with what problems the future state of Pakistan will confront if it is pursued in the manner it is being pursued. the intellectual excercise they carried resulted into a famous report still present in the library of Aligarh. The predictions came almost true. the core was that Pakistan is being demanded but no thought is being made in Muslim league how to handle that country post creation. The report suggested that this Pakistan will remain unstable and confounded by serious ideological problems. The one question no one could answer at that time and still now, by Making Pakistan we actually divided one muslim nation of India into two.
I agree that these narrow minded Mullahs should stay in the mosques but we can only push them behind the walls of mosques if we learn our religion independently and through research and questioning. till the time it is only the duty of these poor village dwellers to learn Islam and just tell them in simplified form what it is, the situation will remain grim. Islam's brightest period was when there was no bar on questioning and the scholars in wordly sciences were the scholars in religion as well.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
The time you spend slandering and defaming scholars...if you'd take the good what Maududi had to offer, you'd be a much better person.
Simply Quran its perfect answer for question
Re: Maudodi Sahab
it is true but i cannot relate where you have quoted, what is it to do with discussion on modudee sahab
Re: Maudodi Sahab
Maududi can be best described as an conservative politician. Which in the prospective of South Asian politics means a religious politician. On top of that he was a prolific writer and had charisma. And as politicians usually work towards gaining support in order to gain power, they do flip-flop on their own beliefs in order to do that. Maududi did just that.
I don't think he actually believed against the idea of Pakistan but he was definitely against Jinnah and most other Muslim leaguers who were western educated. He disliked Jinnah in particular for his secular ways and his eloquent\snotty English. So being a politician he did what most politicians do, go against the ideas of your opponent to gain support and rally your base.
Had he actually believed that Pakistan as 'Paledistan' he would have never migrated to it. But looking at the partition he knew that he is far more likely to get in power in Pakistan than in India. Had he stayed in India, he would have certainly been over shadowed by more prominent Congress Muslims like Abdul Kalam Azad etc.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
well being against an idea once being debated or in the implementation stage does not mean that you necessarily do not accept it once it becomes into a reality.
To my understanding these religious leaders switched sides because they were astute politicians, they had seen that Pakistan will give them greater leverage for implementing their agenda then present India once creation of Pakistan became a reality. They were only against its creation because it was being created in the name of Islam by those people whom they thought to be no where near Islam. They thought that perhaps their birthright to be flag bearers of Islam will be robbed away from them by these western educated and stayled politicians, however they rightly calculated later in the game that they have better chances here than there. I really give credit to Maulana Abul Kalam Azad that the man had guts to stay on his principled stand and not to put his foot in his mouth.
It is still to be seen who will have the last laugh, secularists or Mullahs. However with the current trend, i think we are drifting in favor of the laters. By demanding Pakistan in the name of Islam we actually played into their hands. Quaid knew that as soon as Pakistan is created he has to quell those forces which he unleashed to revitalize Muslim League, However he did not get enough time to close the genie in the bottle. It is debatable if it could ever be closed regardless of Jinnah died later or earlier but he did try at least. You can see the difference in tones of his post and pre independence speeches.
Re: Maudodi Sahab
He asked me about scholar so mentioned Quran