Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Has he been hanged or not?
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Who cares? Whats the point of executing some random muther because he is RAW. Anything he knows at this stageis ancient history. Let the poor guy go back to his family and exchange him for some Pakistani serf who's probably in an Indian prison.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
As per the latest scenario....the evidences produced in court were fake or misguided by police....it shows how poor is your court system.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
It is truly sad to see his family’s pictures on the BBC web site. The border between Bharat and Pak on most of the places is not well marked.
The villagers from the border areas do know where the boundary is. Mostly they respect the border because the border police on both side can be really brutal even to their own people.
When someone does get caught on the wrong side, he is quickly debriefed and mostly returned to his side. As long as you can quickly prove that you are not that far from your border village, things get resolved.
Here are the three possibilities that he is in fact innocent “border crosser”, and the fourth possibility that he went to Pakistan illegally:
-
This guy was too drunk to argue and pick up a fight with Pak border police. So instead of returning him to his village they handed him over to the state police.
-
He “wandered off” too deep to end up in state police jurisdiction (and not border police area). This type of incident can turn into serious disciplinary action against the local officer of border police. So to cover his a$$, border police chief could have turned this into terrorist infiltration.
-
When he did end up in state police’s hands, he was still too drunk to apologize and work out a deal with them.
-
He crossed the border intentionally and illegally.
No matter which of the possibility is true, it still is shameful that the two people of Punjab (East and West) can get death sentence for simply being in their own land , i.e. Punjab. I am all for respecting the borders, but the stupid suspicious thinking must go. Heck we are in 21st century and yet idiot enough not to allow free exchange between the too countries.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
i think it is a chance to prove to the world that we will follow a decision made by our courts, and the highest court in the lands decision should be respected, but then i think of the treatment the indiands will hand out 2 each and every pakistani languishing in indian jails. if india is so sure he is innocent and doesent want an innocent man to be killed then i think pakistan should ask for concrete evidence which is more solid then that presented in their courts and also milk the india government into releasing all 600 innocent pakistanis in indian jails!
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Already two of the evidences have backed up…
-
One says that he was just 10 years old boy and repeated in the court what police has asked him to say. And his testimony time took only 5-6 minutes…means no counter questioning.
-
Anothe evidence a Shukat Ali says that he never appeared in the court and the testimony was done in his name by some other person…means that the sarkari vakil did not bother to find out the correct identity of the evidence.
And you call it court system???
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
It is not the time to question pakistani judicial system or how efficient pak police is.If the president for that matter pardons him it will encourage more terrorism because if any RAW agent will be arrested for their activities they will repeat the same kind of story.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Your country and the family of this terrorist could not identify this terrorist agent in the last 15 years. Efforts were made 3 time. Even the family members denied knowing him.
How about this. 
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
It is true that India or Indian organizations did nothing in last fifteen years and we came to know about the matter recently when the Pak Supreme Court confirmed the death sentence.
Where did you get the idea that the family denied knowing him???
Or what efforts were made 3 times???
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
^ That is the objection Pakistani government is raising dude. Yes, the family denied his identity 3 times before....... came to know from a news paper.....
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Which News Paper???
Any supporting Web link???
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
And at last after the exposure of Supreme Court of Pakistan to the world that the prime evidences were either misled by police or were fake…the Pak Govt has started a counter propaganda.
Sarabjit Singh who very recently told the Indian Embassy personals that he was not guilty, tells the Pak people in a vedio clip that he was responsible for bomb blasts.
Long live Pakistan and Musharraf regime!
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1226879.cms
Sarabjijt admits killing Pakistan people
ISLAMABAD: Sarabjit Singh, an Indian prisoner facing death sentence in Lahore, on Saturday admitted he was responsible for a series of bomb attacks that killed several people across eastern Pakistan.
The confession by Sarabjit Singh came weeks after Pakistan’s Supreme Court upheld the death sentence handed to him in 1991 on charges of spying for India’s intelligence agency and carrying out the attacks.
Singh’s family, however, has said he was not a spy and that he strayed accidentally into Pakistani territory in August 1990 while farming his land near a border town of eastern Pakistan.
“Yes, I carried out bomb attacks,” Singh told state-run Pakistan Television. Singh’s photos have widely been published in Pakistani newspapers.
It was not clear when and where Singh’s statement was recorded, but it came a day after Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf told The Associated Press that the man had “carried out terrorist attacks and killed people here.”
This practice is mostly popular in China, or was a tradition in Communist Russia and Fascist Germany. Where Pakistan stands?
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Right next to it’s dear neighbor Bharat! In every aspect it resembles it’s joined at the hip, cousin. Modi burned 2000+ Muslims women, children, and men. Bharati middle class looted their Muslim neighbors’ shops. Another 30,000+ Muslims were thrown in concentration camps. Where is the Supreme court of Bharat and wher is Modi. This ultra right wing Hindu a la Hitler’s pupil runs around in brand new cars and opens up the old rivers all in the name of a religion that is so colorful, so peaceful, and so docile.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
Your celebrities who burnt innocents alive at Godhra train mishap are under trial in Gujurat but our Govt or the Court never paraded them before TV camera.
This is a difference of cultures.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1489123,0008.htm
Sarabjit’s confession under duress: Lawyer
A day after Pakistan’s state owned TV broadcast a purported statement of Sarabjit Singh confessing that he had carried out bomb blasts in 1990, his lawyer said on Sunday that he does not know anything about the existence of such a recording and it was not part of the court record.
Raha Abdul Hamid said there was nothing new in the PTV broadcast and it would have no effect on the case. Sarabjit, who Pakistan claims is Manjit Singh, has been been condemned to death for his alleged involvement in bomb blasts in Lahore and Multan.
Referring to the tape, he said, “I don’t know where it has come from or how it has come.”
“This confession on video or audio, to my knowldge has not been produced before court at any time of trial nor is it part of record, nor it can be presumed that it is a statement,” he said.
“Legally the statement is not on record nor is it on file of the case,” Hamid said. He said the purported statement was on the same lines as Sarabjit’s confession made before the area Magistrate as available in court records.
Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat
May be this is for the first time in the entire Court history that some prominent witnesses have pleaded in favor of a scapegoat and the Court and President of the country are justifying their ugly stands…
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1481961,0008.htm
Sarabjit innocent, says Pak witness
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/7598_1491636,000500020000.htm
Sarabjit deserves no leniency: Pak Supreme Court