Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

Society Pakistan & World Affairs
1

He is Manjit Singh or Sarabjit Singh? He is a RAW agent or a Scapegoat for Pak police’ all around failures?

As per the Pakistan court verdict his name is Majit Sing. He is a RAW agent and made 14 trips to Pakistan from 1987 to 1990 without visa and is responsible for five bomb explosions in different parts of Pakistan.

The Supreme Court of Pakistan has sentenced him the death sentence… ‘to be hanged till death’.
His lawyer says that he is just a liquor smuggler.

His family in Punjab (India) says that his name is Sarbjeet Singh and he crossed the border by mistake under influence of liquor doses, was caught by the Pakistan security personals and charged in false cases.

(The report is published in many Indian news papers and telecasted on TV channels. But I could not find a supporting link on web.)

2

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

stupid drunk indians.

3

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1468163,000900010001.htm

Is he a spy? Must he hang? Family threatens suicide

For the family of Sarabjit Singh, it is now a race against time. Last Friday, upholding the judgement of an anti-terrorist court, the Pakistan Supreme Court in Islamabad awarded the death sentence to the farmhand from Bhikhiwind, Amritsar.

Mistaken for a RAW agent, Sarabjit was charged in a case of serial bomb blasts and sentenced to death as “Manjit Singh”.

On Sunday, Sarabjit’s sister Dalbir Kaur wrote to the president, the prime minister and Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, saying her brother was innocent and that his was a clear case of mistaken identity.

“If Sarabjit isn’t freed, we will be left with no alternative but to hang ourselves the day he is executed. We’ll put everything at stake to fight this long legal battle. I appeal to human-rights bodies to help us,” she said on behalf of Sarabjit’s wife Sukhpreet Kaur and daughters Swapndeep and Poonam.

Continued…

4

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

He is Manjit Singh or Sarabjit Singh? He is a RAW agent or a Scapegoat for Pak police’ all around failures?

Just like your tomato katchup war HEROES???:rotfl: :rotfl:
Indian soldiers have faked killing terrorists many times to claim medals and India police have claimed many awards for killing and capturing ISI agents, infact some of those poor people were handed in by Norther Alliance (Afghanistan) and they were shot in head by Indian police and claimed that they belonged to Jaish e Mohammad and were about to attack Indian Shopping Mall.

Even If you are right, then it’s your turn to get that back.

5

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

Mistaken identity, that's what they all say!!

Phaansi pe latkao saaley Sikrrey ko... Indians have been killing Pakistanis in Kashmir everyday and others as pretend ISI agents, do teen Indian maarey gaey to koi qayaamat nahein aa jaaey gi.

I say close down all their Gurdawara's, too risky with Indians coming into our country for pilgrimage..

6

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

^ i think they should close down all mosques because you breed terrorists in there. especially pathans need to leave PAkistan.

(* ^ see how stupid my statment sounds. your replay #5 was just as stupid. * Dont blame sikhism or sikhs for something one person might or might not have done. Thanks.)

7

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

Don't worry your people have already took care of that... Today it's Madrassah's, tomorrow it'll be Mosques and as for Pathans they're already being killed in WANA.

I don't klnow if Sikhi is to blame or not but Sikhs hate Muslims and Pakistan more than anyone else, this fact is not hidden from anyone, just go to an Indian website and see for yourself. There Muslim coethnic men and women got a good share of it during partition and before that when the Sikhs ruled over them, turning Mosques like the Badshahi into drug stores and donkey stables.

I knew it, me talking bad of Hindus gives the aulaad of Hindu forefathers mirchi up their bottoms, this is what pisses me off about Pakistanis you guys can't decide whether your with Indians or against them..

Aaisi Janat Ko Kya Kare Koi
8

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

Close down the Gurdwaras? R U for real? That’s the kind of sentiment that has led to the current state of Islamic extremism and intolerance.

As to killing of Pakistanis in Kashmir - what are they doing there in the first place?

i wonder
9

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

http://www.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=53256

PM to try stop execution of ‘RAW agent’ in Pak

New Delhi, August 23: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh will speak to his Pakistani counterpart in an effort to stop the execution of an Indian man convicted of spying, a Congress party leader said on Tuesday.

Singh was speaking to lawmakers from Punjab, a day after family members of the convicted man threatened to kill themselves if the execution was carried out.

“I will speak to my counterpart,” Punjab Congress chief Shamsher Singh Dullo quoted Manmohan Singh as telling him when he met the Prime Minister with other Congress leaders and urged him to save the man.

Media reported that Pakistan’s Supreme Court last week upheld the death sentence for Manjit Singh for spying for India’s intelligence agency, the Research and Analysis Wing, and being involved in five bombings in Pakistan.

The family insists Singh is not a spy and has appealed to Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf to spare his life.

Kaur says the man’s name is actually Sarabjit Singh, a farmer who lived in a village in Punjab, who accidentally wandered into Pakistan in 1990.

10

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

May be he is innocent, but here the religion will create hindrances even if he is…what funny laws they have?

Mush can’t pardon Sarabjit:

ISLAMABAD: As the family of Sarabjit Singh, sentenced to death for his alleged involvement in explosions in Pakistan, pleaded for clemency, Information Minister Sheikh Rashid said under Islamic law he could be pardoned only by the relatives of the victims of the blasts.

Lahore-based lawyer of Singh, who Pakistan claims is Manjit Singh and a RAW agent involved in the 1990 bomb blasts in Lahore, said he would file a review petition in the Supreme Court which has upheld Singh’s death sentence recently. “As per the Pakistan Islamic law, only families of those who died in the bomb blasts can give him pardon and no other person. This is my understanding of the Islamic law. The President cannot pardon the accused,” said Rashid. He said if the victims’ families did not forgive him “nobody else can give him any relief”. His comments came a day after Foreign Minister Khurshid Mehmood Kasuri said an appeal for clemency can be made to the President.

11

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

Why would islamic law apply to Mr.Singh? he is not a moslem

Time Pass
12

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

^ Anjjan not quite,

http://www.dawn.com/2005/08/25/top7.htm

Musharraf to decide fate of Indian spy: Kasuri

ISLAMABAD, Aug 24: Foreign Minister Khursheed Mehmood Kasuri said on Wednesday it was up to President Pervez Musharraf to decide whether to pardon an Indian man facing execution for spying and involvement in bomb attacks. He said he discussed the issue with president on Tuesday.

“As far as clemency is concerned, it’s in nobody’s hands. It has to go to the president of Pakistan,” he told reporters. “If a mercy petition comes, then the president will decide on merit.”

Talking to newsmen about the claims of “mistaken identity” by the family of Sarabjit Singh, the minister said he could not comment on it.

“He has been tried here for fifteen years by a trial court, high court and in the Supreme Court and all the three courts awarded death sentence to him,” Mr Kasuri added.

The minister recalled that capital punishment still existed both in Pakistan and India and such mercy petitions were always made to the presidents.

Commenting on reports by some Indian channels quoting his family members on Sarabjit Singh’s health, the minister said a high official of the foreign office contacted the Kot Lakhpat jail authority on Wednesday and was told that the prisoner was in good health.

“It is a humanitarian issue and even condemned prisoners have their rights,” he added.

OTHER PRISONERS: About other prisoners in both countries, the minister called for softening of procedure by Pakistan and India to address on humanitarian grounds the issue of their early release. “Both the governments should soften the procedure and make it more humanise, it is a very lengthy procedure,” he said when asked to comment on reports on the plight of hundreds of prisoners held by the two countries, after a ground-breaking ceremony of new foreign office building.

The minister said he raised this issue at almost every meeting he held with his Indian counterpart Natwar Singh during the last two years.

He particularly mentioned the cumbersome identification process — from the interior ministry to provincial governments down to district governments — which extended to months and even years.

Mr Kasuri said if needed he would even speak to the prime minister on the issue but stressed that both the governments would have to do something to change the procedure.

The minister said in the absence of any interaction between the two countries, such matters could not be addressed in the past.

“But things are now changing, a dialogue is going on and we should look at this issue on humanitarian grounds,” he added.

The minister also called on the human rights organisations in the two countries to take special interests in addressing the issue of prisoners’ plight.—Agencies

13

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

He (Manjit Singh or Sabarjit Singh) was so lucky to be innocent, otherwise, minority members leaving India for some reason are often declared as terrorists by khatris.

14

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

I’m talking about Kashmiri civillians and every Kashmiri is a Pakistan you Hindu fool…

15

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

every kashmiri is a pakistan, and every pakistani is a burkina faso. kaye ko lafda karta ay beh..

Matt iss khaab k peechay bhaagoo.......a wonderful nazam!!!
16

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

He should be executed right away. Look at what Indians consider about such issues. Here is a most recent example. Read below :rolleyes:

Pakistani man, Indian wife and their kids languish in Indian jail

KARACHI: The arrest of one, Mohammad Shahid, on charges of spying for Pakistan sealed the fate of Najma Perveen, who had taken her husband and five children to permanently settle in India with her parents there.

This was revealed in the investigations conducted by The News. Najma Perveen was an Indian national before she arrived in Karachi after marrying Mohammad Shahid and later returned to India only to land in Tihar jail on charges of spying for Pakistan.

Shahid’s parents migrated from India and after their death he was looked after by some of his close relatives living in Karachi. These relatives arranged his marriage with an Indian girl of Meerath state.

Najma gave birth to five children, four daughters and one son. Mohammad Shahid started working in a real estate business in Surjani Town and later set up his own business. However, the family could not come out of the vicious circle of poverty.

They went to India where Najma and her five children were arrested and put in jail by Indian authorities, who declared them ‘Pakistani spies’.

Courtesy: The News, Lahore, August 23, 2005 ( By Rauf Klasra )

17

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

“The News” independent investigations indeed. :hehe:

If this were true, is the pakistani leadership full of morons to not care? Look at how India made a big deal out of Sarabjit Singh.

18

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

I believe it, Indians are the worst kinds of Humans on the planet, only they would stoop so low..

19

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

I saw we give him life, death is to much even in my book… Although, I think a good punishment would be allowing to live in Pakistan freely but never allowing him to return to that poop infested country of his :hehe:
Or is that a reward?!?!?

20

Re: Manjit singh or Sarabjit Singh/ RAW agent or a Scapegoat

Zee news and other Indian TV channels are in fact making much noise these days on the issue of prisoners living in Indian and Pakistani jails just for none of their fault.

You have not given any date, web link of the incident in your post. Or if you really need to serve your people just write directly to Indian TV channels. And I hope that Pak TV chennels must raise the issue as our channels have done.

Why? Because Najma and her children are in Indian jails. interesting…eye for eye, hand for hand and person for person???