Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his report!

Aaj News Exclusive

Malakand commissioner had confirmed in his report given to government that the video of 17 year old girl flogged in swat is fake. Moreover, taliban had also denied that no such incident took place on 3 january but they confirmd that a woman was flogged about 7 months ago but not on 3 january and her film was also not made and this is a propaganda to subotagae swat peace process.

SWAT ( 2009-04-05 01:31:11 ) :Swat Taliban have termed fake the video of flogging a 17 years old girl released on Thursday last. Haji Muslim Khan during a press conference on Saturday denied the video and said that such incident had not happened in Swat.

Muslim Khan said the people who gave punishment to the girl were not resembling with Swat Taliban in their accent and face structures.

About the current video, he said this incident was not occurred in any area of the valley.

He said the woman was accused that she had affairs with her father in-law, however, independent sources had not confirmed.

He also acknowledged that an incident of such type had happened seven months ago in Kod Korak area of Charbagh in which a woman was flogged.

Muslim Khan claimed that locals had complained about the woman who was captured by Taliban and she was being forced to confess her guilty and she was flogged by four young children in a roadside old house, he said.

Taliban spokesman alongwith media team visited the area where this incident had occurred and met them with those four children who told the journalists that the incident was happened seven months ago.

The children also told journalists that they had flogged the woman seventeen times.

Muslim Khan asked why the government did not take notice of Jamia Hafsa incident and killing of innocent people in Swat.


Now, this news and confirmation of govt officials as a fake video is a powerful slap on the faces of propaganda machines who are highly operational to disintegrate Pakistan and cannot see Pakistan in peace.
I had constantly said that im against unIslamic acts of either taliban or by foreign terrorist agenciz and contriz but many traitors and propaganda machines are constantly propagating on GS to change the people mind according to their evil aims.
and those who think that the greatest threat to Pakistan are just taliban not US, NATO and other countriz then these people are living in “PARADISE OF FOOLS”, bcoz all this terrorism which is either conducted by taliban or largely by foreign terrorist intelligence agenciz to engage Pakistan in an intelligence war is all because of USA policiz and coalition with enemies which they are also.
They had under estimated ISI and our armed forces which is today becoming a tool for them to crush their own people but this is also a fact that the majority of our army and ISI personnels are against USA and they favour taliban because they are also muslims.
i also belong to a family of army but i shall never ever sell my conscious to these stupids and i shall fight against the traitors and enemies of Islam and Pakistan till the last drop of blood.
Our army and ISI just need one order of the government and their high command, and then all the world and enemies will see the capabilities of our armed forces and ISI when the world will see counter intelligence war in enemy countriz which must have to be launched immediately.
And today, the chakwal suicide attack is also a part of this intelligence war and it is so sad to see our own brothers and sisters crying and martyrying because of these stupid enemies and traitors who have sold their conscious to their indian, american and western masters.

Shame on Traitors!
Shame on America and NATO!
Shame on our government!
Shame on taliban!

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

^^

I have heard this guy Muslim Khan ( from his idealogy i guess neither he is Muslim nor a proud Khan) first admitted that yes this was done by local talibans and he added that because the WAR was on, so the investigation was not completed and punishment was served, later on, when the news caster asked him how can you issue a verdict when the investigation was not complete.. he said, well it was war going on, so no time for investigation and then later in the same interview he denied everything saying the girl was found guilty of going out with her Father-in-law and was subject to punishment... Now This is what he was talking online... later on he changed he statement..

First thing first … mods need to look at the title … don’t know when it happened but Muslim Khan has not become the commissioner of Malakand !!!

Coming back to the topic … this is turning out into a hilarious episode of “he said - she said” … of course Muslim Khan playing both sides. I have hightlighted the different parts where he contridicts himself. The news item is from “Pakistani media” so i would not have to worry about its authanticity :slight_smile:

Taliban term girl’s flogging visual fake | Pakistan | News | Newspaper | Daily | English | Online

MINGORA - In the wake of growing resentment over flogging of the young girl in public, the Taliban militants have taken another turn, when their spokesman Muslim Khan on Saturday termed the visual as fake.
Soon after making public the visual, the Taliban spokesman Muslim Khan contradicted the involvement of Taliban in such an inhuman punishment. But later in special interviews with several radio and TV channels, Muslim Khan not only confirmed such act on the part of TTP, Swat Chapter, but also defended it terming the same to be in accordance with the Islamic injunctions.
Talking to media in Dakorak village near Charbagh town of Swat district, Taliban spokesman Muslim Khan termed the visual pertaining to flogging of the girl as fake, saying “Certain elements are bent upon sabotaging the peace agreement in Swat.” He also dubbed such visuals as a part of conspiracies being hatched against the Taliban.
The TTP Swat spokesman on this occasion paraded four teenaged boys before media, who claimed flogging the woman in a village of Kabal Tehsil. All the four boys were part of Taliban militants. However, Muslim Khan contradicted the reports regarding the age of the victim and said, “She is not 17 but 34 years old, who according to him was involved in illegitimate relations with her father-in-law.” While the media reports reveal that the girl was charged for meeting a young boy, who was also flogged.
Muslim Khan also claimed that the woman was not put on ground and flogged through backside but she was punished with flogging in standing position. He said that such visuals seemed to be fake and mock, with aim of sabotaging the peace process in Swat.
Referring to the suo motu notice by the Chief Justice of Pakistan, Muslim Khan said that this notice was not against them but against those who had made what he claimed “fake visuals.” He said that the Chief Justice of Pakistan must take similar notice of killing of innocent people in Swat, tribal regions and other places at the hands of the security forces.
Muslim Khan said they had no other objective except the enforcement of Islamic Shariah. In this respect, he expressed satisfaction with the steps being initiated by the NWFP Govt.
He said that now Qazi Courts resumed functions and this could help them in getting easy and early justice.

fake video or not, whether they did it or not, Taliban who feel no remorse in suicide bombing and beheading civilians and security personnel indiscriminately, for them to flog a young woman in public is not beyond comprehension.

These animals have been lowering the bar for sometime with their increasingly repulsive acts of savagery and brutality

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

[note]Captain FT, please post link to the article

Thanks [/note]

I noticed that too. I'm waiting for him to provide link to the original article.

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

I guess Muslim Khan is now denying it as the after-effect of the video making it public, things gone wrong for some people :hehe:

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

so whats fake about this video?

Was it animated?

Were the people hired actors?

Or were they doing a drama show?

Man the excuses the Taliban and their supporters will come to defend this animals never fails to amuse me

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

Cannot believe the dramabaazi - if people belive this guy, then Pakistanis are an even bigger mess than I imagined.

I also would not be surprised if there are direct links with the Taliban posting on this website trying to sway public opinion. Be wary of who posts and whose paying them.

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

Those who denied this or questioning its originality I have question for them "How on earth the **SCREAM **of this girl can be fake?" I mute it whenever I watch the video.

Relax PCG, you hav gone over to the paranoid side.

I don't think you will find many supporters of the Taliban agenda. Considering the fact that Pakistan has become a de-facto US puppet state rankles many nationalists (rightfully so), therefore you're not going to see outright condemnations of such policies.

This is blowback for the ill advised Pakistani involvement in the war on terror. When we were killing fellow Muslims to support the Amriki agenda where was the outrage? When Pakistani jets were destroying civilin reas of FATA, where was the outrage?

I am not here to condone any floggings or takeovers of Swat and elsewhere, but we should not be blind to the atrocities committed against our own people.

Bottom line is that we need to engage the TTP and other militant outfits and esure that they work with us for the Pakistani national interest, not to cause destruction of our own country. Don't buy my argument? then carry on with Americans using drones to attack Pakistani soil, while TTP and others place our major cities in flames.

You will NOT be abl to beat this insurgency through military means.

I never considered Taliban proper Muslims, nor the criminals they harbor as being anything other then terrorists.

So I dont see it as killing other Muslims, I see this as no different from Saudis beheading a Muslim criminal. The fact is, these are criminals and a disgrace to Islam. We should view them no differently.

Pakistan is in trouble for supporting and legitimizing criminals, not because they are helping kill so called Muslims.

The TTP cant be engaged. You dont engage murderers. Regardless of whether they surrender or promise not to do it again, justice and rule of law dictate that criminals be punished for their crimes.
Islam teaches us that you punish criminals!

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

[note]Thread closed for violation of forum rules. No link posted to original article despite given enough time to do so. [/note]

Girl Flogged in swat-link to article sent to shamraz khan!

Shamraz khan! this is the link to that article which i posted about the girl flogged in swat.

AAJ TV : Pakistan Ki Awaz

aur dusri baat! aur wo ye keh mein job kerta hun aur apki tarah yahan farigh nahe betha hua keh ji 24 ghantay GS pe online reh ker siraf posting hi kerta rahun.

aur wesay bhi aplog mods hn apkay pas sara data computer pe show hota ha kuch poochnay aur thread close kernay se pehlay ye zarur dekh liya kerein ke koi offline ha ya nahen.

aesay hi ikhtalaf e raey kernay per thread close na ker diya kerein.

teesri baat keh mein ne kahen bhi apni post me taliban k kisi bhi rehnuma ko malakand ka commissioner nahe banaya. ok??

neechay alehda se taliban wali khabar ka article bhi diya tha.

uskay bawajud taliban ko malakand ka commissioner bna diya hai chund logon ne.

aur ye baat bhi yaad rakhna keh jub mein ne koi baat ki hai na to mein kaheen bhaag nahe jaunga apkay her swal ka poora jwab dunga. haan ye zarur ho sakta ha keh kaam ki waja se ya chutti walay din kaam ki waja se offline ho jaun

aur ye jo malakand commissioner ki video fake declare kernay wali khabar hai ye kisi article se nahe li ye kal subah aur aaj tv ki slides aur neechay chalnay wali khabron ki headlines e suni aur dekhi ha.

aur agar kisi ne phir bhi nahe suni ye khabar to isme mera nahe uska qasur ha

THANK YOU

aur janab aik aur baat jo propaganda machines k liye ha takeh unhe aaj clear ker hi dun! aur wo yeh keh mein koi taliban kay acts ka himayati nahe hun, haan ye zarur ha keh mein sirf taliban ko hi blame kernay k sakht khilaf hun aur USA aur NATO ko bhi ziada qasur waar kehta hun bcoz sb kuch unhi ka kiya dhara aur unhi ki ghatia policiz aur naam nehad war against terrorism ki waja se ho raha hai.

lekin agar taliban kay tumam acts aur terrorism khatm ho jaen aur wo true muslim ki tarah apne apko tabdeel ker lein to mein unki himayat bhi karunga.

isliay aaj jo kuch bhi ho raha hai usme taliban aur foreign intelligence war donon involve hn, na keh sirf taliban!

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

Bla bla bla, you keep repeating the same excuses, but none of your posts will erase the reality of talib barbarity that the entire world knows about. Also, please stop righting in roman urdu, it is very difficult to read.

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

Oh mr. kehkashan! offcourse urdu will definitly be difficult to read for the people who know just english and hindi, and who sideline urdu!

propaganda machine! plz dont raise my blood pressure. ok?

i wonder how many times i have to tell you that im not favouring taliban in their UnIslamic acts, but i will also favour them in the case if they stop terrorism bcoz they are muslims and to favour any good muslim is also a teaching of Islam which so far taliban are not.

and that doesnt mean that talibs cant become true muslims it just depends upon ones conscious but every unIslamic act of taliban or any muslim must be strictly condemned.

but we must also crush every move of propaganda campaigns to destabilize Pakistan and to make full advantage of the situation by traitors and our enemies who could not see Pakistan in success!

Damn! i shall fight against such enemies and traitors as well as unIslamic acts of talibans!

:hoonh:

Re: Malakand Commissioner confirmed the swat girl flogging video as fake in his repor

Here is another analysis, this guy have raised some important points.. can any one answer them…