<<<<<<My other point for your question is , by the rule of Logic and the rules of any court of laws you cannot declare a person guilty by just one point , it needs at least three evidences , so declaring a person wrong by just one evidence is wrong.No offence to anyone , just a piece of knowledge about logic.
Yeah you may result by just pointing out one mistake , but this come in the part of inductive logic. >>>>>
If i murder someone, do i have to do it 3 times before i can be prosecuted
People get convicted on basis of DNA tests alone - ergo, convicted on basis of one evidence!
Where R you going with this? Could be interesting!
if you don't have to do murder thrice but , you will need evidences to be proved a murder, without three evidence no court can claim you to be a murder.
its a differnt case if you agree you have murdered.
[This message has been edited by Logic Bomb (edited September 20, 2000).]
Everything started when somebody called Abu Hurarira a liar, ok ok ok , mypoint was it is wrong to call him a liar when somebody who gathered the Hadiths by giving reference Abu Huraira says Abu HUraira said this , where is the evidence Abu Huraira really said that or where is the point the person who is giving reference is not a liar , so calling a person of that time a liar is wrong and when it is no sure that he really did it.
Salaaam
Logic sahaab i still don't get your point,
Exactly what kinda evidences are you looking on the issue, you want me to give you three evidences that there is a ayat in the Quran asking the wives of Prophet not to leave their houses, or you want me to give you three evidences that there Bibi Ayesha left her house went in the battle of Jamal against Hazrat Ali.
Read the Ayat 32 and 33 of surah Ahzaab which is the 33 surah of the Holy Quran it states clearly that wives of Prophet shouldnt leave the House.
[This message has been edited by Mr. Pakistani (edited September 22, 2000).]
RE: ABU HURRAIRA
This is one of the most notorious chatacter of early Islam. Abu Hurraira has been called a thief & a liar by Hazrat Umer(ra) and a liar by bibi Ayesha(ra).
Abu Hurraira was one of the largest contributors of hadiths most of them 'alleged' to be fabrications.