Load Shedding during Dictatorships

Just before the newbies who think Musharraf is quiad-e-azam attribute Musharraf for inventing bijli in Pakistan, let me remind them that Pakistan did have electricity (load shedding free) before Musharraf came in. It is funny how load shedding only takes place during dictatorships. What good does it do to have every majja gammma carrying a cheap prepaid cell phone and gloat about it, when we have a thing called load shedding which even the developing countries are done away with. p.s. before anyone pin the blame to BB and NS, remember they ended load shedding in their times, and musharraf has been in power for 8 years and had ample time to fix the problem and couldnt…

Energy resources ‘Negligence led to power crisis’

Thursday, January 03, 2008
By Mansoor Ahmad

LAHORE: **Negligence to develop energy resources in time has remained the hallmark of the governments that came to power after removing democratic governments in the past three decades.

Economists pointed out that the country faced the first real loadshedding at the end of 11-year tenure of General Ziaul Haq and it was Benazir government that aligned the private sector to provide much-needed electricity for industrial and domestic use.

When Nawaz Sharif government was deposed in 1999 the country had surplus electricity as well as surplus natural gas. In fact, the Nawaz govt enjoyed the distinction to afford delay in entering into gas supply agreement for the gas discovered by the private sector.
**
The Zia government kept the Kalabagh dam project in cold storage during his tenure when the opposition to its construction was very weak. At the same time his regime failed to look for alternate sources of producing electricity.

The country felt acute shortage of electricity during the end of his tenure as the available surplus was consumed by GDP growth of six per cent during 11 years of his rule. The country entered the decade of 90’s with acute shortage of electricity that slowed industrial growth for a while.

The Benazir govt arranged over 5,500MW thermal power through private sector after it became clear that there was no possibility of exploiting the hydro-electricity generation of the country through construction of mega dams.

Then the Sharif government started the running of the river hydroelectric Ghazi-Brotha project that had the potential to produce 1,450MW of electricity. Both the governments realized that industrial growth would only be possible if the country retains enough electric power to run the industries.

The availability of this additional 7,000MW electricity enabled the present regime to sustain the high GDP growth. These two governments also started the reform process by opening economy and enhancing the creditability of the regulatory institutions by providing full autonomy to the

State Bank of Pakistan and SECP that took over from ineffective Corporate Law Economists giving full credit to the Musharaf regime for not only continuing reforms but further strengthening the process started in the 90’s.

This encouraged the private sector to enhance capacities and productivity. The robust growth during last eight years is even higher than the average growth achieved during the Zia regime. However, the economists pointed out that the government again committed the same folly made by the Zia government of neglecting the additional energy and power that the country would require after accelerated growth.

The Pak-Iran gas pipeline project was unnecessarily delayed to accommodate India. They said: “We should have preferred our national interest instead of waiting for India that adopted delaying tactics.”

They said the private sector had not vigorously approach to new thermal power projects although WAPDA had timely warned the government in 2003 that there would be acute electricity shortage from 2006 onwards if new capacities were not added. Had the government initiated thermal power projects either through private sector or through WAPDA, the current crisis would not have taken place.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

this is indeed a shame, the govt should have factored in that with all the industrial growth in this time the energy needs would only increase.

after a while the pace of the industrial growth would suffer if there is not enough power to support it. The pace of growth simply can not be maintained when issues like power shortages can serve as speedbumps and roadblocks.

good post

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

I should also point out that in 1999, Pakistan had surplus electricity...

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

dude, have you heard of google? load shedding was a serious problem in the 90's. want me to posta couple of links from dawn?

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

No it wasnt, read the article, and I remember it was gone after Zia's times, only to resurface now... Also, even if it was a problem in the 90s, why is it still going on during musharraf's perfect dictatorial regime, I thought there was a BOOM BOOM afridi style ecaaanmy going on?

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

I did read that since it was in the article, but thank you for pointing it out again. energy needs increase when periods of economic growth come by, look at china how their growth has put demands on global energy resources, but they planned appropriately for that. Pakistan failed to do that and as a result people suffer.

Economic and industrial growth has to be matched witrh power growth.

although I do recall load shedding in summers of 93 and 94 in Karachi, as well as dec 97-jan 98, and dec 98-jan99 . not sure what caused that.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

Pakistan has seen unprecedented growth in the past eight years. You are indirectly praising President Musharaf for the boom in economy. Pakistan is investing money in the energy sector to allow for the continued boom in the economy. God Bless Pakistan. May the energy sector improve due to the investment and foundation that is being laid in this sector. :k:

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

http://www.chowrangi.com/load-shedding-in-karachi-and-elsewhere.html

One of key difference between a developing country and a developed (a.k.a civilized) country is the power management. Electricity has become a basic need, and its unhindered, continuous and smooth supply is the necessity, but in countries like Pakistan, its still a luxury and more or less an elusive dream.
Whether it is the mega city like Karachi or a remote small city like Kohat, the aggravated story of dismal power supply remains the same. Throughout the country, in all the four provinces, in every major or minor city, in every town or village, there nothing exist like solid and robust power supply.
The so-called load-shedding remains the integral part of rural and urban life. It docent even go away in winter, but in the summer, it becomes the thorn in the eye. The abuse and curses WAPDA gets in summer, if written on paper and loaded on Titanic, Titanic wouldn’t require a storm to get drowned.
Hide and seek role played by electricity only irate the consumers more. It not only snatches the mental and physical peace, but also results in massive financial losses in regard of electronic appliances. Frequent power breakdowns have turned lives of people miserable.
Whenever the protests are raised, government’s obstinate clowns shrug and with an intelligentand scornful frown blame the scarce water storage units. Whose fault it is? Who has to resolve these issues? of course, its the government duty. That is why they are the government. Its their responsibility provide the people with basic utilities like power supply and others. If there are problems, they are the ones to resolve them, if they can’t do it, they have no right to remain in power. And people, why in the hell we always elect these people with vested interest who always deceive us?

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

And where did I say pakistan got unprecedented economic growth in the past 8 years?

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

a post from another forum to support the viewpoint?

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

i am not sure if there is any point in interacting with people who have not heard of google:

http://www.lib.virginia.edu/area-studies/SouthAsia/SAserials/Dawn/1997/03May97.html

Unscheduled loadshedding to cover up power crisis

I H Raashed

LAHORE, April 26: With the atta crisis still persisting, Pakistan is
facing yet another serious crisis  the acute power shortage forcing WAPDA
to resort of unscheduled loadshedding to the extent of 1,700 megawatt (MW).

WAPDA s present capacity is reduced by about 40 per cent from 11,000 MW to 6,300 MW due to a big drop in hydel power following depletion of two
reservoirs at Mangla and Tarbela and repairs being undertaken at some of
the thermal power plants.

http://www.lib.virginia.edu/area-studies/SouthAsia/SAserials/Dawn/1996/04Jl96.html

…Also, the present generation capacity of 13000 MW has been found to be
extremely insufficient to meet the demand on a year round basis, at
different times of the year, particularly during the period of low river
flows, when consumers are subjected to load-shedding.

The magnitude of this shortage is estimated to be around 2,300 MW, about 38 per cent of the computed demand, persisting for several months during peak load hours.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

Yes, whats wrong with that? Honestly, I dont see any posters over there who regard Musharraf as the new 'Qauid-e-Azam', just well written thought out articles, and this one really speaks the truth about load shedding being one of the main failure of this present regime.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

king faisal, what years dude?

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

its against forum rules, so when it gets removed please realize that its not the viewpoint that is a problem but forum rules that do not allow links to other discussion forums. Thats what is wrong with that.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

lol This ‘unscheduled’ load shedding lasted only a few weeks, and happened when the flour crisis took place due to the caretaker governement. There were also massive repair operations going on all over the country, especially at Tarbela which demanded them to shut down dynamos frequently. With Musharraf’s regime, load shedding has been ‘regular’ and ‘steady’ so far.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

links are from 1997 and 1996 respectively. the article quoted in the topic of the thread is bs and is almost certainly written by a journalist in the jaib of nawaz sharif. press is among the most corrupt institutions in pak and the original article is a good example of lifafa journalism.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

ANY PERSON WHO HAS LIVED IN PAKISTAN IN THE 90S KNOWS THAT ONCE ELECTRICY WENT OUT, IT STAYED OUT FOR 3 DAYS, NOW IT HARDLY GOES OUT FOR 30 MINUTES.

FACT
IN THE 90S THERE WAS NO ELECTRICTY AVILAVLE IN VILLAGES, IT WAS ONLY THE MUSHARRAF ADMINISTRATION THAT POWERED ALL VILLAGES

FACT NO,2
ANY PERSON WITH A BRAIN KNOWS THE RAPID COMMERCIALIZATION AND INDUSTRIALIZATION HAPPENED IN THE LAST 8 YEARS, THERE IS A MUCH BIGGER DEMAND FOR POWER TODAY, PAKISTAN HAS GROWN ALOT IN THE LAST 8 YEARS, LAHORE HAS NEARLY DOUBLED ITS SPACE.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

I really dont see any reasons to defdend musharraf regime on the topic of poor planning for power generation. the steps about building of diff dams are good but a little late, sadly even talking about dams like kala bagh become a huge ethnic issue in the country.

anyways, fact remains that musharraf regime needed to plan for better energy generation and mgmt to keep pace with the pace of economic growth. they did nto do that and that is simply inexcusable. as I said eventually the pace of economic growth will be impacted if power generation is not resolved.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

yaar that is all fine and goo, getting electricity to villages which no one bothered about previously, fine…good job musharraf..thank you. same for the economic growth pave and the energy needsw, good job musharraf. :salute: but while we have to appreciate the good that the regime did, we have to note their failures, and this is one.

Re: Load Shedding during Dictatorships

And another trend that emerged in mush’s rule, load shedding in both winters and summers… :hehe: