Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

Am I an Extremist?

My views are different to many in the western society. According to Prime Minister Blairs’ speech I could possibly be classed as an extremist but would hope that his view is in the minority.

I would, like many Muslims who have not appeared on TV say that the bombings in London were wrong, I would say that indeed these were criminal acts. But would also say that those who kill innocents in Iraq are also criminals and they should also be brought to justice. Would this ever be possible? They hide behind concepts such as foreign policy, international law and other ideas such as vital interests.

Yes killing innocent civilians is wrong but why is it that when people are killed in London or New York it is an attack against a civilization, but when it’s Abu Gharaib, Chechnya, Andijan, Kashmir, Palestine or Iraq it’s called collateral damage. Does holding the Islamic belief make you into something that is less than human? Where was the silence held for these people?

Does living in this country or the Western world mean that I must adopt all values and ideas from this society? Would I be an extremist to hold different ideas? Would it be wrong of me if I did not support the British troops in Iraq? What if I see them as occupiers? What if I was sure that this was colonialism? What if I was saddened by the deaths of the soldiers as well, because of the fact that they are fighting not for justice or WMD but for oil interests? Surely if I was to be called an extremist for this, then the same title should be applied to Israelis who refuse to enlist in the Israeli army due to the atrocities committed in Palestine.

What happens if I don’t adopt root ideas of western society such as freedoms? Can someone really say that for this, I am extreme? What if I saw that these ideas results in children not looking after their parents? What if I felt sorry for old ladies and men who would stumble onto buses barely being able to walk or sit before the bus starts moving? Where I feel sorry for OAPs because their families have deserted them, their only companion is a dog to such an extent that the dog has become ‘a mans best friend’. So rather than freedoms I would teach my children the idea that they are obliged to look after their parents in old age and ensure their happiness.

Is it not the ideas of freedom that have resulted in a crime ridden society where no one is safe from muggings, rape, murder and violence? So if I chose teach about certainty of belief in one God, in accountability, heaven and Hellfire, then would I be a fundamentalist?

Would this not result in individuals that would abide by the law permanently rather than those that only do so when they fear getting caught? A society that did exist for over thirteen hundred years – and where crime was virtually non existent.

When socialists aspire to change society they are seen as people with a different view. So why am I called a terrorist for wishing for a different state of affairs. Why does Prime Minister Blair attack the idea of a Caliphate when almost all Muslims aspire to live under such a system in the Muslim world? Why is this seen as talibanisation and oppression and not as giving the Muslims the right to choose their own political destiny? We are banned and labeled as extremist when all we wish to do is remove and replace the rulers who act as stooges for western interests. Even though our work is peaceful.

Yes there are individuals in the Muslim lands who would not like to live under such a system initially. Would they not be free to leave? At the same time there are millions like myself who would see the establishment of the Caliphate as the happiest day of their lives and would rush to whichever country this is established in. And similar to what happened in the past, as testified to by many western historians I would envisage the whole of mankind wishing to live under such a system.

Individuals and groups who disagree with Labour still live in the UK, pay their taxes and live amongst the population, they are not asked to leave. Then why must I be asked to leave or be threatened with deportation if I disagree with the fundamentals of democracy? If I believe in a system (political Islam) which I think is better and more just than democracy then should I not be given the chance to discuss and debate this peacefully?

How can it be an incitement to terrorism to link the problems the world is facing - such as starvation in Africa, the killing of innocents and the suppression of political will to the real cause which is the capitalist system and its resultant colonialism?

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

If you want to live in a society without freedoms, why are you living in Britian? While many people have many different opinions (that's what makes a land of freedoms so wonderful), advocating a religious, totalitarian system goes against everything these societies stand for. The place to start this utopian Caliphate is not a country where the basics of their society are based on the freedoms you oppose. It would be like a non-Muslim living in Pakistan advocating to take Islam out of all aspects of governance. It's presumptuous, arrogant and a person has no place to demand such things. If you want your caliphate in Muslims lands, fine. But please don't be so insolent to think you can demand, let alone implement such a system in western nations. WE DON'T WANT IT.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

Yeah, Seminole SPEAKS FOR THE WHOLE WEST.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

now that is one great idea.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

ivgotnumber

Why do you care what blair says about muslims we know exactly what kind of liar he is, and you also know his viewpoint on life which is to dominate the world and squeeze it for every penny no matter what the consequences.

Blair and his government are an enemy of islam pure and simple no inbetweens!

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

^ That means Islam is the enemy of Blair and his government. So don't be so hard on Blair.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

glad we got that cleared up

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

As I said in the original Letter:

[QUOTE]

"Why does Prime Minister Blair attack the idea of a Caliphate when almost all Muslims aspire to live under such a system in the Muslim world"

[/QUOTE]

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

Yes, you are are an extremist. Why? Just pick up the freedom strugles of any country. Mostely the freedom fighters were always conscious not to target the innocents. In your case it is defferent, as your like minded people target only civilians.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

Please read the letter carefully before posting diatribe...

[QUOTE]
I would, like many Muslims who have not appeared on TV say that the bombings in London were wrong, I would say that indeed these were criminal acts. But would also say that those who kill innocents in Iraq are also criminals and they should also be brought to justice. Would this ever be possible? They hide behind concepts such as foreign policy, international law and other ideas such as vital interests.
[/QUOTE]

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

define innocent

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

It is a double talk. Have guts and say ‘no’ to terrorize civilians, whatever may be the circumstances.
Make army and fight, if you cannot, fight the oppressor thru other means. Use media, propaganda machinery, Internet and convince the world community. But instead what your freedom fighters (?) do? They kidnap children, highjack planes and blackmail nations, or bomb public areas.
This is not a freedom struggle from any angles.

And off course, when you use Religious forum for making hate propaganda, it is not a freedom struggle.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

^^ Media, propaganda, and all the other methods you suggested are being tied and tested since day 1.

But to what avail? For more than five decades, palestinians are being ruthlessly murdered and their land being ruled by the Zionists unlawfully. The West has been dictating the policies in the Middle East, and has been very successful at planting puppet regimes in the various muslim nations for more than 80 years.

All of this is common knowledge...The entire world is aware of whats happening in places like Palestine, Kashmir, Chechneya, and now Iraq...

What my argument is that, Revolutions are not brought about by sitting at home and writing papers, or posting articles on the internet. The American Revolution, the French Revolution, the Bolshevik Revolution, and every other revolution that has ever taken place....all demanded blood. They fought for their rights, they shed blood and then they achieved freedom, rights and liberty and then finally peace.

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

I absolutely agree with Sharaabi paje, for he is 100% correct:) .

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

Saharaabi, and dum_mast

  1. OK....Also inform me in which revolutionary movement and the freedom struggles the freedom fighters deliberately targeted the civilians?

  2. And where you find in Islam that attacking and killing civilians is allowed?

Re: Letter I wrote to the Media about the London Bombings

Attacking civillians are not allowed in Islam...period.

We must question the religeon(s) of those who commit crime against civilians. In my opinion and may be its true also..that those people are/were NOT MUSLIMS. People who commit these crimes are destined for hell. Now is this a clear statement or not? Media does not want to accept this Islamic attitude though.

We do know that non-muslims killed millions of innocentand civilians throughout the history.

WWI and WWII was not war started by muslims.

Islam is peaceful and muslims are peaceful till they are oppressed unjustly.

(War brings quick result but a peaceful attitude is long lasting.)