Lest We Forget

Brilliantly expressed by Angela Williams!

:lajawab:

http://dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2007\09\17\story_17-9-2007_pg3_3

Lest we forget
By Angela Williams

Nawaz Sharif and Benazir Bhutto are being hailed as returning heroes, the gallant saviours of democracy, and Asif Zardari is being referred to by some as the Pakistani Nelson Mandela! Has everybody lost their marbles?

Friday, November 28, 1997 should surely be indelibly printed on the minds of all those who respect and believe in the rule of law in Pakistan. This was the day on which members and supporters of the second government of Nawaz Sharif stormed the Supreme Court and brought to a halt, with their violence, the contempt of court proceedings against the prime minister which could have led to his disqualification from office. I remain, to this day, open-mouthed at the outrageousness of that act, caught on CCTV so that the shock troops could actually be identified, and testified to by respectable witnesses that included Ardeshir Cowasjee and Zahid Hussain.

Mr Hussain corroborated the testimony of fellow journalist Fakhar Rehman who was beaten up by PML leaders; he also stated that some of the cadres were overheard saying that their task had now been accomplished and that they should go back to Punjab House where Shahbaz Sharif was waiting for them.

Fifteen days after the outrage, Mr Cowasjee addressed an open letter to the Acting Chief Justice, requesting that “it be accepted as a petition and that he take suo moto action for the gravest contempt committed in the face of the court, against those who stormed the Supreme Court on November 28, 1997 as well as those responsible for organising them to so do, and that severe deterrent punishment be handed down to all of them. Collectively responsible and guilty is the entire federal cabinet and the primus inter pares.”

After the storming, the same bench could never hear the case, as Chief Justice Sajjad Ali Shah was removed from office by an order passed by a ten-member bench declaring that his appointment three years previously had been illegal! Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif was later exonerated of the contempt charges by another bench.

Deliciously ironic, is it not, that upon being unceremoniously bundled off to Saudi Arabia last week, Nawaz Sharif immediately applied to the courts of law! Lest we forget, please note also that Sharif it was who, in 1998, incurred economic sanctions against Pakistan for testing nuclear devices (just what the malnourished, illiterate masses needed, of course), and thus poisoned the land for ages to come. And just as a footnote, I can’t forgive that large hoarding near Lahore’s Kalma Chowk which trumpeted Nawaz Sharif’s landslide electoral victory in February 1997 with the words: “Congratulation to the nation On Good change”. God save all English teachers from death by cringing.

But now, let us move on to the other honourable contestant in the competition to bring what Sharif last week called ‘undiluted democracy’ back to this long-suffering country, the lady who has been referred to as a ‘political genius’. Prior to her first premiership, she had no administrative or parliamentary experience. Although she had done fairly well in the elections, she was short on majority having been defeated in the Punjab, the most populous province, by Sharif. After a mere 20 months in office, she was dismissed by President Ghulam Ishaq Khan on allegations of corruption and owing to widespread kleptocracy (I hope you were paying attention last week when I defined kleptocracy!).

Nothing daunted, the Pakistani electorate saw fit to re-elect her in 1993. But again she was dismissed, this time by her own appointed president and party member, Farooq Leghari, in 1996. The dismissal came amid accusations of having stolen hundreds of millions of dollars via the kind offices of her husband Asif Zardari by demanding ‘commissions’ on government contracts and tenders. The New York Times, not noted for unsubstantiated scandal-mongering, published an article in 1998 claiming that a network of bank accounts had been uncovered, all linked to the Zardari-Bhutto family lawyer in Switzerland, with Asif Zardari as principal shareholder in the corporations involved. There’s more, much more, but it gets rather repetitively monotonous.

Institutionalised corruption aside, Bhutto promised, during her election campaigns, that the Hudood and Zina ordinances, an affront to the humanity of women, will be repealed. Upon election to office, she did no such thing.

Lest we forget it should also be noted that the unfortunate Mir Murtaza Bhutto, Benazir Bhutto’s brother, had accused his sister of corruption in 1995 and had formed a group which split from the ruling PPP. He and six other party activists were gunned down in a “police encounter” on September 19, 1996. It was less than two months later that Bhutto’s government was dismissed on corruption charges for the second time.

Now in 2007, Nawaz Sharif and Benazir Bhutto are being hailed as returning heroes, the gallant saviours of democracy, and Asif Zardari is being referred to by some as the Pakistani Nelson Mandela! Has everybody lost their marbles? Are these power-and-wealth-crazed creatures the only viable candidates that their demented parties can throw up? Have all their truly shocking acts of the past couple of decades been forgotten? Does none of this matter? Pakistanis are actually going to vote for them? Hey out there! Is there a principle in the house?

Re: Lest We Forget

Ms Williams defined:
*‘kleptocracy’ *(rule by thieves: a government that extends the personal wealth and political power of government officials and the ruling class at the expense of the population).](http://dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2007\09\10\story_10-9-2007_pg3_3)

Re: Lest We Forget

In a plutocracy, power and opportunity are centralized within the affluent social class. The degree of economic inequality is high while the level of social mobility is low.

Re: Lest We Forget

this is opportucracy. either Pakistani govt will change for good OR each one of the current opportunes will fall flat on their faces, while taking the state down with themselves
but the stakes are for the whole nation
no where in the world today, a better leadership can make a huge positive impact than in Pakistan, but i only that leadership appears now.
so the liability lies on everyone's shoulders!

Re: Lest We Forget

Well isn't it Musharraf's fault for dealing with these corrupt *******s? If he had done what he originally promised all three would be in prison.

Re: Lest We Forget

I don’t think people have forgotten at all how BB and Nawaz mismanaged the country, twice over throughout the 1990’s. That is why Nawaz Sharif got the most humiliating turnout in the history of Pakistan on Sep 10th and then Sep 11th, and why BB will not get much a reception to as well next month. Unlike the 1990’s we now have one of the most freest media in the region now who are regularly exposing and lampooning politicians and leaders. Tens of millions of Pakistani people have access to the internet and the very latest in communications technology, as well as a growing middle class of 35 million people. BB and Nawaz left a closed, almost Soviet-style society and will be returning a more open and freer one where people are well aware of their past actions, and wary of what they offer for the future.

Re: Lest We Forget

ISLAMABAD: The National Accountability Bureau’s most important but now abandoned files on the alleged corruption of Benazir Bhutto and her spouse Asif Ali Zardari claim that Rs 90 billion was swindled and that the ex-ruling couple has dozens of offshore bank accounts, business interests and real estate.

But even those at the top in the NAB do not know today how this alleged amount – Rs 90 billion ($1.5 billion) – was calculated. Whether this is an exaggerated figure or real, the NAB and its forerunner the Ehtesab Bureau have been quoting this in the past as being the “stolen” money. However, both Benazir and Zardari never admitted to it. Rather they have been consistently pleading their innocence, claiming that the corruption cases against them were filed with malice to politically victimize them.

The NAB files on the ex-ruling couple are voluminous and in bundles. But to the good luck of the duo after early this year’s closure of the bureau’s special cell, which was probing the couple’s cases, these files are rarely touched.

Speaking informally and strictly off the record, NAB officials admit in their background interviews that the bureau’s special cell probing and pursuing the Benazir-Zardari corruption cases continues to be inactive.

An official has been assigned to look after Benazir-Zardari cases following the closure of the special cell but there are many, even within the bureau, who believe that the cases would not be seriously pursued. One of the top NAB officials, when contacted, denied having received instructions from the top rulers to become soft on Benazir-Zardari cases.

About the high-profile foreign cases in British, Swiss and Spanish courts against the couple, the NAB seems to have got cold feet. A senior NAB official did not hesitate in saying that the prosecution of these cases was the responsibility of the respective host countries and not that of the government of Pakistan. He said Pakistan would figure only when its legal aid was sought. He confirmed that in the case of Mardid, the NAB had already informed the foreign court in writing that it was no more a party to the case. Madrid has charged Benazir, Rehman Malik and a close relation of the PPP chairperson of serious corruption in the UN’s oil-for-food programme.

The Spanish government, the source however disclosed, is serious in pursuing the case and is not much bothered about the lack of interest by the government of Pakistan. While the NAB is giving confusing signals, the voluminous files on Benazir and Zardari talk of 11 frozen bank accounts in London, eight frozen bank accounts in Madrid, dozens of frozen bank accounts in Geneva and a long list of inland and foreign property business concerns. The couple is also said to have seven bank accounts in the US.

Benazir and Zardari, according to the NAB files, own eight properties in the UK, including the 131-hectare Rockwood estate in Surrey, eight properties in the US, including a country club in West Palm Beach, and a stud farm in Texas, four bank accounts and two properties including a lion home in the name of Zardari’s father and a lot more. The couple is also said to have properties and bank accounts in Dubai.

The couple has been accused of amassing a fortune in foreign banks and in foreign lands by taking kickbacks and commissions on government contracts, including SGS-Cotecna, ARY, Ursus Polish tractor deal, Swedish aircraft deal, Agosta submarine purchase, etc.

It was alleged that in a $4 billion 32 Mirage aircraft purchase deal, a document indicated that an agreement was reached to pay 5% “remuneration” – about $200 million to a foreign company owned by Zardari.

Two Swiss companies, the SGS and Cotecna, were implicated in $11.8m pay offs for a $131m contract to supervise Pakistan’s customs service. The amount was said to have been paid to an offshore company, owned by Zardari.

A letter of the-then managing director of Cotecna Robert M Massey, addressed to Zardari’s reported offshore Swiss company, also makes part of the NAB files. The letter confirms, “Should we receive, within six months from today, a contract from the Government of Pakistan for the inspection and the price verification of goods imported in Pakistan, we Cotecna Inspection SA, Geneva will pay you 6% (six percent) on the total amount invoked and paid to us by the Government of Pakistan for such a contract during the duration of that contract and its renewal. These payments will be made to you by us quarterly, on the basis of amounts effectively received by us in Geneva.”

These files also talk of bank transfer details of another pay-off from a Dubai-based gold dealer, who allegedly paid cash to Capricorn Trading, a Virgin Island firm controlled by Zardari in return for an exclusive license to import gold into Pakistan. The documents show two transfers of $5 million into Capricorn’s accounts from the Dubai-based Company’s account. The company, nevertheless, denied paying kickbacks and claimed that the documents were forgeries. These files speak of documentary evidence of pay-offs from Ursus, a Polish tractor company.

The NAB files also give details of foreign and local accounts and the properties they own, under their name or otherwise, both within Pakistan and outside.

According to a NAB source, the kind of evidence collected by the Bureau against Benazir and Zardari is exceptional and even appreciated by the foreign courts, which entertain such cases of corruption only on the basis of strong evidence.
http://thenews.jang.com.pk/top_story_detail.asp?Id=10212

totally shameless

Re: Lest We Forget

sure that neither Nawaz nor BB did anything for the betterment of the country in terms political stability or economic prosperity. Musharraf, on the other hand may have done somewhat more than them, however, he and his marshalls failed at many a crucial thing.

Pakistan is a high inflation country, we all know that for a fact. During BB's or Sharif's reign, however, the situation was not as bad. With the low property prices, a middle class individual/family could still think of buying property in one of the major cities. Pre 2000, you could buy a 10 marla plot in one of the decent areas of Lahore (johar town etc) for less than Rs 5 lac. Now the same plot would cost you Rs. 50 Lac. Do you honestly think that with the current income level almost any individual who's starting his life from scratch can think of buying property in one of the major cities of Pakistan? It's like a 'cieling' has been created between the economic classes, and the poor, regardless of how hard they try, can not get past that. They, in Sartre's words are 'condemned to stay' poor. Musharraf's government not only has failed at not letting the buffer between the rich and the poor widen, it has facilitated its widening. Musharraf also helped is fellow army men take most of the spoils, through massive allotments in the land grabbing schemes as DHAs or AWT housing schemes.

The rich or upper middle class families who held land/property have now become much richer, giving rise to massive consumerism in the upper echelons of the society, and thus very high inflation. In Pakistan food inflation is in the neighborhood of 16-20 % per year, which does not really matter to the rich class, as food expenses are nothing but a tiny part of their incomes. However, it is a nightmare for the poor, who spend most of what they earn on food.

No wonder the rich, educated and ultra-liberal pseudo-intellectuals love Musharraf for all what he has done, but very few of them would actually like to see what this governments' actions have done to poor.

Re: Lest We Forget

Yes, and when ppl realize that what this regime has given them as free press, judiciary and somewhat awareness and a freer society which perhaps may last a long time and keep them safe from future trouble by these figures say in 5, 10,15 yrs from now, they will start realizing and accepting and establishing what valuable things Musharraf actually gave Pakistan. But for that the society, media and judiciary will have to be honest, brave and responsible and not selective, selfish or hypocritical as they're famed to be for decades.

Re: Lest We Forget

:rotfl: yeah Angela Williams kaisay Pakistanion mai uth beth rahi hay? Kaheen “North Pole” pe to nahi hai? Mr 10% ka naam ek hi jumlay mai Nelson Mandela ke saath ?? toba toba Mr Nelson Mandela koi chahiye lawsuit file karayn.

I hope the “lack of supporters” in recent drama for NS was a real sign of his “support”. Busharraf has completely failed in “criminalising” NS, he failed to prove that NS was corrupt and Busharraf is not, he failed to prove that NS was opportunist and he is not, Busharraf failed to prove that there was no accountability in NS govt and his govt has it… the list goes on and on. so why would anyone disregard NS esp when SCP said that NS can come back and still Busharraf sent him out?

Re: Lest We Forget

I think a lot of people do realise that, despite what the rabble rousers in opposition parties or certain journalists might say. The pathetic turnout that Nawaz Sharif received on 10 Sept was the most humiliating political failure suffered by his party - in fact it was one of the most humiliating in Pakistan's political history. Then the following day the APDM received an equally poor show. The politcial opposition is more divided than ever, especially at this critical juncture, and ordinary people are not taking any of them seriously. It all shows a general apathy and almost complete distrust by the people in the scare mongering and promises of the opposition, and an acceptance by many of the actual developments made over the last 8 years.

Re: Lest We Forget

The voting awaam at its best again today, as Benazir returns...:(

Re: Lest We Forget

You cant lose things you don’t have. BTW, I was chatting with one of my friend in Karachi and she said that PPP is promising people up to Rs 700 per person who come to welcome BB at the Karachi airport. So, I guess it fair to say that BB “supporters” are more like rented crowd.

Re: Lest We Forget

Probably.
But the prob is, these same masses and more will be rented on poll day as well, if need be even for 7000/head.
And unfortunately thats what decides Pakistan's fate...:(

Re: Lest We Forget

What people may not forget this time is how their bahdur Pak fauj has openly sided with biggest looters in history. They may also not forget how the army of Pakistan has acted more like mercenaries of some in West since 60 years.

People may also never forget how Pakistani nation (if at all it is a nation) is being fooled yet again that secular terrorists may bring moderation, the essence of Islam.

:jhanda:

Just as Aalsi goes:… Let me continue the tradition…

Long live Pakistan Army :jhanda:

Long Live Mush:jhanda:

Long Live Our US Masters :jhanda:

Long Live Pakistan and its slavery :jhanda: