Lal Masjid Siege Thread - Operation Silence (merged)

Sa1eem · March 3, 2013, 8:46pm

Re: Lal Masjid Siege Thread - Operation Silence (merged)

Whom do you feel more comfortable talking to?

Please read above, I made those comments about the posts above.

The morality and humanity champions have not come out to show remorse rather they feel it was justified that so many lives were lost, which could have easily been avoided.

I think we are not talking on same wavelength.

All I have said that there should be a clear distinction between real culprits and misguided followers. This fact has been ignored all too often.

Any life including the soldiers could ave avoided if there was a good will gesture by those who ultimately were in charge.

Moreover, what was the need for any ultimatum at all? They were surrounded already in there.

What was the need for the rush at all? How long do you think those people would stay there? Month, two months, three months?

Do you get my point sir?

I got your point and I am really amazed reading your post.

Well, the way you are writing I believe you would even accuse Ali (RA) who fought Kharjees killing all of them except few who fled.

Here is story of battle Naharwan: Initially 12000 men started fitna in around Kufa, doing takfeer, harassing and killing people in order to impose their version of Islam (as what present day Kharjees are doing and Lal-Masjid goons were doing).

Ali (RA) turned towards them. After talk, most kharjees left their deviant belief. Some even joined Ali (RA) force. Still, 1800 hard-core stayed in their Kharjee belief under the command of ‘Abdullah bin Wahab’ and decided to fight Ali (RA).

[It is same what happened at lal-Masjid, where most danda-bardar brigade surrendered, though around 130 hard-core stayed adamant with young devil to fight Pakistan army]

Result: Kharjee fought Ali (RA) and all 1800 got killed except 9 who fled to spread their fitna.

[Just like lal-Masjid event, where around 80 got killed and around 50 surrendered]

Now, you can say (the way you are saying about hard-core terrorists who got killed at lal-masjid operation) that Ali (RA) should have found another way to save life of these Kharjees instead of engaging them in fight where Ali (RA) army killed around 1800 Khajrees.

Right?