Khuda ke Liye- the hottest anti-Islamic movie in Pakistan

[system]

Re: Khuda ke Liye- the hottest anti-Islamic movie in Pakistan

@Crescent_

LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
Yes mr scholar sir, Way ta go and refute the works of the world’s most reknown scholars.

If your dream is to be a scholar, i’m sorry you’re FAR from it.

Re-read your post and just comprehend how LOST you seem to be. nice try at your analysis, but again you’re farrr from taking on the works of scholars.

Try spending 10-15 years in the path of Islam, then come up with some statements.

EVEN a average joe in Islam knows that every aspect in Islam is verified AND proven by facts pretaining to different Ambiya, Situations, Circumstances, and Quranic references, as well as the consensus of all the muslims who established the deen based on the Sunnah of the Prophet pbuh.

People dont just take words and explain them, they have comprehensive knowledge of their deen and then they come up with verdicts.

So my first advice to you, learn your religion, respect your scholars, and close the dictionary and pick up the Quran.

You talk about Logic, but fail to provide it when it comes to referencing it from the works of Religion.

And yet you still pray behind a Scholar who upholds these values, and you still adhere to the religion of the Prophet pbuh who condemned these acts.

LOL…

If some so called scholor told you to wipe your rear end with sand because toilet paper is haram, I suppose you would start doing that to:hehe:

If you dream is to be a good and knoweldgable Muslim, then Im sorry, you lightyears from that…

My intention is to understand Islam through logic… Your intention is to blindly follow whatever beard pops his head out of a madrassa door.

Try spending one day trying to think logically and then start dictating to others what is or isnt haraam.

Even the avergae Joe knows that whatver is proven, has to stand up to the test of logic.. And since Islam is the truth in every sense, then nothing in Islam can be beyond logic.. And yet, here you are trying to defend something as illogical and stupid as “music is haraam.” and all you have to defend it is some vague understanding of some hadeeth based on some idiot scholar, who himself, like you, took everything to be literal.

The term comprehensive, is ambiguis at best… The Koran and hadeeth are all open to interpretation… And just because one scholar thinks it should be interpreted in one, way, that doesnt mean we have to agree…
Particularly when its completely illogical…

I HAVE YET TO FIND A SCHOLAR WHO CAN EXPLAIN TO ME WHY MUSIC IS HARAAM, LOOOOOOOGGGGGICALLLLYYYYY!

YOU EXPLAIN THAT TO ME, OTHERWISE GIVE IT UP… If its not logical, its not ISLAM.!