Re: Khuda ke Liye- the hottest anti-Islamic movie in Pakistan
was just quoting what is in quran
and i have shown that in Quran only men are allowed to marry Ahley kitab women , clearly mentioned about men and not about women
and you are interpreting that if that is not written there it means womens are allowed to marry Ahley kitab men which is contrary to any scientific analysis method
first of all go back and read my post , i have not given fatwa of any body
i
What kind of scientific analysis is that . It is actually circular reasoning. I can not find a verse in Quran which allows me the use of mobile phone. I assume it is allowed because I can not find a verse which prohibits it. Even a two year old child can think more logically in this case than your reasoning. This is the exact mental gymnastic you are performing and I mentioned earlier…
i have also said , should Allah repeat name of every nation (people) that they are mushrik after each ayat
Although you know in various ayats in Quran Allah have said that jews and christens worship other then Allah
and who ever worship other then Allah is musrik and one is not allowed to marry any musrik
you are stuck with one ayat and left all others and demanding why Allah haven't write the thesis , that after each ayat , Allah should have write a, b, c.....z are musriks or Allah should have write ,muslim are not allowed to marry a , not allowed to marry b , not allowed to marry c ................................ not allowed to marry c
Allah have told they are not allowed to marry musriks ( who worship other then Allah ) , other then Muslims womens they are allowed to marry Ahley kitab ( to whom Allah had revealed the book) and they have believe in oneness of Allah
Of course I’ll stick with each and every Ayat as that’s where I get my guidance from. I cannot ignore 29:45 as you are suggesting. Allah revealed four books for the guidance of Humankind. Torah, Bible, Zaboor, and Quran. As the followers of Hazrat Daud did not exist at that time only Ahlekitaab left were Jews and Christians. If you think Quran refers to some alien ahlekitaab who do not reside on this planet you can continue to live in your fantasy. My understanding is ahlekitaab are Jews and Christians. You are writing a thesis on Ahlekitaab, challenging Allah’s wisdom. I am just looking at the verses how they were understood by Muslims for centuries, and how it was understood by our Holy Prophet at the time of revelation.
not your wisdom , do you think yourself Allah
Allah have told , every nation that had been given books and acted on that are Ahley kitab and who worship other then Allah is mushrik and Allah had told that jews and christens , worship other then Allah
keeping your theory in mind (if some one are separately define , some where in quran then they are separted in general ), i have shown you that in quran in various parts Allah have separted jews and christens from Ahley kitab
Allah has referred to Momineen with several names in Quran as well. Does it mean Allah is referring to somebody else. If Allah call them Jews and Christians sometime and Ahlekitaab sometimes how does it prove that they are not the same.
i can just smile on your childish arguments
so you are quoting that no other nation on the earth were given books
what can i say to you now
plz let me know , why Quran some where told Jews and christen do this etc etc
and some where said Ahley kitab , although only Ahley kitab word was enough if ahley kitab means jews and christen only
I have already answered it !
my favourte mullah is Hazoor PBUH and without his guidence no one can understand true knowledge of Quran
Than show me from Quran and sunnah the evidence in support of your argument. Don’t tell me the Prophet comes in your dreams to tell you what you are saying. Show me the ayats which prohibit marriages with Christains and Jews or Ahlekitaab (as you say they are separate). Show me the refrences…