Khuda kay Liyay

system · November 2, 2007, 7:15am

Re: Khuda kay Liyay

I saw this film and I liked it. Well first of all, the production, acting, directing, and overall quality was really great, compared to typical Pakistani movies.

I don’t think it’s against anyone; neither Islam nor West. He is simply showing how some people brainwash youngsters and then how US kidnaps a Pakistani and how they treat him in prison and beat the crap out of him and paralyze him for life. Also, how sikhs were treated because they were mistaken to be from Middleast. I find the movie fair and this reviewer guy in the first post image is taking things in wrong context.

A few things I disagree with are how they are saying music is halal. Yes Hazrat Daa’ood had a beautiful voice but he didn’t sing songs with musical instruments. He used to praise his Lord with his voice only. Yes the Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) said to Hazrat Aisha (R.A) that if there was some music/singing at the wedding, but that’s not the kind of singing that takes place these days. Besides, I believe only “dafli” is really okay in Islam, not other instruments. I think there’s a hadith by Prophet (PBUH) where he was really angry when he heard the sound of a musical instrument. I can’t recall the entire hadith.

People who think it’s a piece of crap, just pointing fingers doesn’t help; what helps is when you actually offer suggestions. What exactly did you find crap?

thanks for the reply. Such kind of replies are welcome and appreciated.

I posted it because i heard and read in places that the movie had serious issues. What really prompted me to start this thread was shoaib mansoor (whom i initially really respected) spoke against junaid jamshed.

I haven’t watched the movie and maybe some writings I myslef have quoted have gone a little overboard. I would now like to watch the movie for myslef. Secondly I don’t trust Geo films. They are promoting it like anything.

The points you have mentioned regarding the music thing … are the real problem.

I will be honest, i do listen to music myself but that doesn’t mean i would change the religion because i like music. I listen to music and i know its wrong. However i don’t go around making a movie telling others that even Prophet David was into music and stuff. Thats something that is very wrong.