"Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

:salam2:

I heard many times (in dramas/news etc.,) that some peoples from Karachi, says ‘Hum Karay Thy’, ‘Aisa karay Thy’ etc. This accent, lingo, and/or dialect spoken only by some Karachiites and I believe I never heard such from any others i.e., Sindhi, Punjabi, Balochi and Pakhtun. I found peoples of India saying in such accent, lingo and/or dialect. :hmmm:

Anyone, would like to shed some light? :slight_smile:

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

I’m shedding light.

http://www.ramblingbarba.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Spotlight.jpg

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

:hehe:

shedding light text pr :slight_smile: where is your text (comments) :rule:

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

I think its Bihari dialects. But similar words are used in Sindhi and Punjabi.

In Sindhi : Karyan tho (kar raha hoon)... TahwaaN karyo (aap karen)

In Punjabi: KaraN main Nazaara jadon ondi tasweer da.

Karachi's urdu is now different than the Urdu spoken in Delhi and Lucknow six decades back. Urdu as spoken in today's Lucknow and Delhi is different from Urdu as spoken in Karachi and other parts of Pakistan. Same is true for other langaues of the region.

ab khush hai LKK bhai?

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

Bhai, Sindhi or Punjabi jo urdu boltain hain, at least woh Urdu ya Urdu ki tarha hoti hy (dialect, accent) ke lihaz se. Magar yeh jis andaaz mein bola jata hy, is se to lagta hi nahi hy k yeh urdu bol rahain hain :nono:

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

Lethal Bhai: aisa Bihari boly hay....

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

Urdu got different dialects like other languages. When it mixes with other languages new words and accents are created, which looks alien to those who don’t know other langauges. Rajhistani style Urdu, contain Thaaro maaro… Hyderabadi style Urdu conatin batiyyan, rataan type words which are otherwise not spoken in other areas.

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

Thaaro Maaro :hmmm: kiya Mahool bhai ki taraf ishara kr rah ho :emmy:

Lekin urdu ka aik standard hota hy or hona chahiyeh jis mein accents/dialect at leat aik jaise hony chahiyeh.

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

waqai, ye to Urdu bolne waalon ne kabhi socha hi nahin :hmmm:

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

Believe me or not I think some Pakhtun face difficulties while speaking Urdu but somehow they try to speak Urdu as it is. However, those who "karay Thy" don't.

And i don't know why.

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

nahi mae aisi urdu nahi bolty :nahi: no no :nono:

han kara zaroor bol dety hun soemtimes :stuck_out_tongue: like mae ney ye nahi kara tha which is wrong :Dtiger bhai ney pakri meri urdu :vivo:

kuch loog lijiyo dijiye bhi khetey hain …

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

I think ranghars speak similar words

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

Kiya ab theek howi ke nahi?

Ranghars, koun?

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

ham abhi aankay behtya hian.. :hmmm:

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

KaraN (Punjabi) is derived from the Urdu word karon. Kar liya hai aur kiya hai are both Urdu words. But "kara hai" is not. It sounds very bonga. I don't know why people do it.

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

Its like the way ranghars speak Urdu! (tatti phirnay jana).

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

Hai tu ghalat par it looks cute when you people speak :hehe:

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

There are a lot of other words, like:

While we say: Oye, ye kia baat ki?
They say : ARAY, ye kia baat kari?

Re: “Karay Thy” - Heard Said By Karachiites

:no:

“Kara tha” gets on my nerves. It just sounds jarring. I’ve heard it from two Punjabis. One is a friend, whom it seems, doesn’t know better cuz Urdu is not a dominant language for her. And the other is my cousin who does know better par pata nahi kahan se yeh “kara tha” kehne ki aadat pakar li hai. So, the latter is worse. :mad:

Re: "Karay Thy" - Heard Said By Karachiites

ham ne bhi yeh observe kiye hain.