Karachi's "charia" ward

ugh this is so sad.

i swear one day one of my dreams is to reform the mental institutes… not just in Pakistan but in other countries as well. You have to give them the opportunity to go out of their jail cell, can’t keep them cooped up forever.

  • There should be a defined time-limit for their trials being heard, otherwise the whole case should be thrown out of court.
  • They should have productive activities like crafts, or construction, or pottery, or carpentry, something that works their minds and their bodies.
  • They need exercise… books… have a book collection drive throughout Karachi. Give them responsibilities, make the ‘best’ among them responsible for supervising the prison library. Build up slowly on that… their minds and bodies are just vegetating in this current state.

It’s not just Karachi. Thousands of cities all across the world, particularly in Africa, have these problems with their mental institutions. It’s easy to ignore them, but they deserve some peace and joy in their lives just as much as any of us.

Hope in Karachi jail’s ‘mad’ ward, Masud Alam, BBC, 5 April 2004

The Central Jail in Karachi in Pakistan has a little compound which is, in the vocabulary of the jail staff and the rest of the prison population, the “charia” ward.

The term is slang for mad or stupid.

The compound has four cells that are bare except for sleeping mats. The only opening to each room is a door made of steel bars, through which the inmates can watch TV installed on the ceiling of the veranda.

There are six to eight men in each cell. Some of them realise they have a psychiatric problem, others say they were brought here because the police did not know what to do with them. Most are very quiet, a few mutter and groan continually, all have their heads shaved. None is allowed out of the cell and none seems capable of smiling.

Mohammed Hanif is the entertainer in his cell. Which is fine with him as he always wanted to be an actor. His repertoire includes dialogue from well-known films and songs that he says he writes and composes in his head. He has been awaiting trial for several years in a murder case. He does not want to comment on the case as he believes “talking about it may jeopardise my chances in court”.

But he adds enigmatically: “No one here is entirely innocent. But in a way we are all innocent, aren’t we?”

The only detail of his case he is willing to share is that it was his obsession with acting that got him in trouble, first with his family and then with law. He has sobered up a bit now but the desire is still there. “When I get out, I’ll keep trying to act on television, maybe for films too, but this time I’ll stay clear of trouble.”

He delivers some dialogue from the Indian film Sholay and follows it up with a song of his own. His cell mates clap along in encouragement - still without a trace of smile on their faces. As soon as Hanif’s song ends, another melody rises from the adjoining cell. The lyrics are touching and the voice is beautiful, though a bit too sad.

This is Munawwar Maseeh. He is suffering from tuberculosis and a few other diseases he does not know much about. His hollow cheeks, pale skin and wasted body speak eloquently about the state of his health. He used to live in the impoverished Christian neighbourhood of Eisa Colony and worked in the construction industry. He was picked up one night while roaming the streets and charged with “wandering”.

It has been nearly four years now and his case is still pending court action. Not everyone in this section is a closet artiste. Sarfaraz Ihtisham is just as passionate about joining the army. By the time they finished lashing me, they were breathless and sweating profusely, while I didn’t even let out a squeak

As a young boy he used to pester the army near his home with requests to make him a captain. He beat up older boys and passers-by to make his case stronger. Now he is in prison charged with bank robbery. He says he was forced to do it. Sarfaraz seems to be in late teens or early 20s.

He proudly talks about the incident in which he slapped a police officer. When he was hauled into the police station he was asked to suggest his own punishment.

“They asked me how many lashes I could take? I said 100. By the time they finished lashing me, they were breathless and sweating profusely, while I didn’t even let out a squeak.” Then he suffered a second form of punishment. “I was in another ward of the prison. I had an argument with four men. They drugged the guard in the night and raped me, all four of them.”

The incident strengthened his fixation with becoming an army officer. “He wears a uniform, everyone salutes him, he fights with the enemy when needed and he doesn’t get raped.”

thats so sad :( im in tears from the last story

this happens in so many countries. Why arent these peopel given a chance? I was talking abotu this today with a friend

remember the lady who said all those things to me about going back to india? i saw her yesterday and i was so scared. As she passed me i realised she was not in her senses... its so sad

all these people need is love and care.. if from the beginning they are given the rigth amout of attention and affection, i doubt they'd land in palces like these

my chacha is mentally handicapped, and im so grateful to my dadi ma that she didnt just throw him away. Hes beautiful Mashallah. Sometimes he does odd things.. but so what.. he's human for goodness sake

very saddening. Reminds you of Dostoevsky's House of the Dead.

also of the movie "3 Deewarien"

sort of off topic.. a few years ago a young couple (not married) were on karachi beach when the police came and beat the guy up (i think cus they were both like 17 and dating). They took the girl to the police station and about 30+ men raped her.. they then took her to the hospital, but she died on the way.. sick!

why is the headline ‘hope’ in the mad ward?

i realise that its probably a lot of cost to bear for a country like pakistan, but i believe that proper management could see a significant percentage of these people contribute significantly to society.

John Nash, for example.

Something I found very interesting is the work of Thomas Szasz. In 1961 he wrote a book titled The Myth of Mental Illness.

Quoting from his site:

Bear in mind that this is not a random oddball with a theory of his own. He is professor emeritus in a very good university.

Im going to read more of his work before I recommend anything specific to read. To get a headstart.. go here..

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by sadzzz: *
also of the movie "3 Deewarien"

sort of off topic.. a few years ago a young couple (not married) were on karachi beach when the police came and beat the guy up (i think cus they were both like 17 and dating). They took the girl to the police station and about 30+ men raped her.. they then took her to the hospital, but she died on the way.. sick!
[/QUOTE]

fkin true sadzz. its unbelievable how brutal and inhuman people can be.

i was sitting in this shop in karachi waiting for my computer to get fixed and happened to have to misfortune of being in the company of another guy engaging in smalltalk with the rest of the four/five computer tech people.

conversation (between them, im just a passive, unwitting listener) turned to this chump being the nephew of a police officer. common knowledge that policewalay roam about the beach looking for potential couples in the hope of collecting bribes. they chanced upon one such pair, and it was a 15 year old daughter of the chief justice gauging from the number plate.

they blackmailed her with her fathers reputation, and proceeded to gang rape her. apparently they were five of them.

this ass clown then proceeded to say how he wished he could join the police since their life was such fun.

sadly, that for all my glaring and anger, the only thing that evinced from him was a snicker and a change of topic. i couldnt bring myself to get up and break his head because i know what these people can do to one's family in response (since he had narrated one story about wrecking another fellows life who dared to stand up to the policeman's nephew).

and heres the most sickening part: none of the other four, and i know because i was searching around for some ally, but none shared my indignation. the four of them were laughing and cracking jokes. one of them being a mulla. one i remember ended up sharing the nephew's interest in becoming a policewalla.

i frikkin lost a great deal of my faith in our 'cultural values' that day. assholes.

^ yeah im so disgusted... i just went to google to search for the story and what do u know... all these other horrific stories of policemen gang raping women came up... im so disgusted

i couldnt find the story i wanted, but i know it happened cus ive read up on it before. When jahil laug rule a country... this is what happens...

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by sadzzz: *
thats so sad :( im in tears from the last story

this happens in so many countries. Why arent these peopel given a chance? I was talking abotu this today with a friend

*remember the lady who said all those things to me about going back to india? i saw her yesterday and i was so scared. As she passed me i realised she was not in her senses... its so sad
[/QUOTE]
*

You saw her again, Sadzzz? Are you okay about it? Did she say anything to you?

i saw this piece on BBC... a 70-something year old man was found in a Russian mental institution...where he had spent the past 50 odd years as a prisoner of war from WWII. He was captured by the Russians when he was around 19 or 20, then spent the next 50 years in some mental institution, literally forgotten by history.

If someone isn't insane to begin with, they are likely to become insane very shortly after going through an experience like that.

i was kinda shocked in the beginning.. but as she passed she was smiling and singing or something really loud, so i realised she wasnt all very there in the head... i felt extremely sorry for her, thinking where are her loved ones and why do they let her go out like this..

thats so sad about the 70 yr old captive.. humans are the cruelest beings on this planet