Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Art encourages change and advancement of social progressive movement. It is very brave that the artists in Karachi are taking bold steps to restore and revive the culture that was destroyed by government and extremism.

KARACHI (AFP)](http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20070903/lf_afp/lifestylepakistanculture_070903055015) - Karachi is alone among its mega-city peers to have no significant public artworks, victim of decades of religious fanaticism likened to the Taliban destruction of the Bamiyan Buddhas, but artists here are beginning to turn the tide.

“What the Taliban have done to the ancient Buddha’s statue in Bamiyan a few years ago, fanatics and ruthless government functionaries did to Karachi’s statues long ago,” says Shahid Rassam, lamenting the dearth of public artworks in Pakistan’s biggest city.

Rassam is one of a handful of local artists working to revive Karachi’s public art, which flourished under the British Raj in India and survived for a couple of decades until the early years of military dictator Zia ul-Haq.

But public art crumbled under Zia, as culture became an early casualty of a regime that nurtured religious fanaticism.

The rot had set in under Zia’s predecessor, Abub Khan, the first in a long line of military rulers, who held power from 1958-1969.

“The religious extremists launched the first campaign against beautiful statues in Karachi during Ayub Khan’s rule when the city was stripped of most of its street artifacts,” says former city official Saifur Rehman Grami.

Art enthusiast Grami says old Karachi was dotted with huge statues, at that time appreciated across religious boundaries.

The monuments survived sporadically until Zia seized power in a military coup in 1977 as Pakistan reverted to military rule.

His 11-year tenure encouraged sectarian Islam and religious extremism prospered as he imposed curbs on cultural activities. In the process, he gave extremists the freedom to ruin the remnants of Karachi’s glorious statuary, says Rassam.

**“General Zia ul-Haq’s period remains a nightmare for art and culture during which Karachi suffered the most, because this city was the cultural hub of Pakistan,” Rassam says.

“Even many years after the creation of Pakistan most of these statues were allowed to be erected at various gardens and public places but since the late 1970s the wave of extremism uprooted all these monuments,” Grami says.**

Scores of sculptures depicting British rule are now little more than a folk memory after being uprooted and destroyed.

Mohammad Ahsan, a resident of Karachi’s Old Town, says he witnessed the destruction of his locality’s history.

"Khori Garden was one of the most beautiful parks of old Karachi. There were many statues of those who played a great role in making Karachi the cleanest city in the world, including a huge statue of Queen Victoria.

“All these monuments were either destroyed or displaced in the 1970s and 80s and the old fountains and water troughs were completely ruined,” he says.

It was the mid-1990s before a large number of old statues and monuments were discovered heaped in a municipal storeroom. Most were extensively damaged with what Grami says is a mixture of official apathy and nature’s ravages.

Apart from marbles and bronzes depicting British royals, some depicted girls in educational settings, carrying books and writing boards – anathema to extreme practitioners of Islam.

Grami says although some old statues were recovered and restored by the authorities, most were either destroyed or stolen. They included many statues of historical significance at Karachi’s former municipal headquarters, Frere Hall.

“We had found some broken pieces like limbs and busts lying neglected under the debris of the municipality’s stores, but found it impossible to put them together,” Grami says.

What could be salvaged and restored has been given a safe haven at the city’s Mohatta Palace Museum, but their absence from their original sites around the city has created an artistic vacuum.

However, municipal officials say that, politically, now is not “the appropriate time” to re-install the statues.

“We could not restore them this time round because of possible reaction from religious fanatics and indoctrination against cultural entities in the general mindset of society,” says a municipal official.

In a country once again under military rule and wracked by political and religious turmoil, Karachi’s mayor Mustafa Kamal has made a bold stand to “invest” in culture as a buffer against rising extremism.

“We have started investing in culture, encouraging cultural activities, as it is the only way to combat extremism and terrorism,” Kamal says.

City hall has commissioned two statues from Rassam to be erected in the heart of city – a Whirling Dervish and a woman in chains symbolizing earth’s vulnerability in the universe.

“This contribution of mine could help give Karachi some places where people could proudly identify themselves with, as people do elsewhere,” Rassam says.

Anjum Ayaz, another internationally-recognised sculptor, is busy erecting his latest monumental work in the midst of a maze of flyovers in the city’s eastern neighbourhood, Korangi.

His 30-tonne, 67-foot (20-metre) high monument depicts sea, birds, animals, people, rituals, holy verses and galaxies. “What I’ve tried to depict is the universe,” Ayaz says.

Ayaz, whose works stands in Tokyo, Beijing and Dubai, has voluntarily created and installed a dozen mini-sculptures at the city’s busy Seaview beach in what he says is a bid to bring art into the public domain.

“I am committed to my cause to work for the people,” says Ayaz, globally famous for his work in stone, marble and metal.

A Karachi city hall official says those who ruined Karachi’s sculptures did so on the pretext that the art of sculpture was “un-Islamic”.

“They stripped the whole city of its beautiful art on such pretexts,” said the official on condition of anonymity.

“And their terror is still reigning so supreme that most artists and authorities seldom dare think about a revival.”

Talat Hussain, a Pakistani artist who teaches at the National Academy of Performing Arts in Karachi, says these works are part of the heritage of fine art and of Karachi itself, and one cannot erase the colonial period however much one tries.

“Nothing in history should be destroyed, not even the statues of despotic English rulers. They should remind us of our past of being slaves and goad us to protect our freedom.”

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

What idiots.

Religion is not even as issue here, the statues of the British monarchs are a reminder of the slavery and subjugation of our people.

Why should we honour our ex-masters by keeping their statues in our cities? Hello! It's been 60 yrs since independence.

It's not art, it's kameenapun, bund-chaatna as they would say in Punjabi.

Have some self-respect.

Brown-Sahib coconuts piss me off.

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

^^ now who is acting like an idiot here?

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

^
Those who moan and whine about Queen Victorias “beautiful” statue being destroyed and lost forever by them mean mean mean fanatics. :crying:

It’s a good job they were destroyed, it’s Karachi not Manchester for heavens sake, we have a giant one here in the city center, everyone kept urininating around her so they had to install street-urinals in the area.

It makes me laugh when brown sahibs call British rule part of our heritage, do these people even have an identity of their own?

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Not admirable!

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Religous idiots... Nothing has harmed the country more then them.
They should put each and every statue back up and let those a hole Fantic rats come out and try to take them down... Atleast it will be enough to get them out of their holes, making it easier to throw them in jail or better yet, beat their ass.

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Why do you lot label anyone who doesn't agree with your opnion a fanatic and extremist?

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

^ it is not about disagreements, its about destroying the infrastructure. If these people are opposed to the statues than make a plea or peaceful demonstration. Going about and dismantling is not going to help. This is art, part of our history and culture. We have to respect our heritage and putting the statues back up does not mean we are enslaving our selves. Why not destroy harappa mohenjo daro and all of the other Indus Valley civilization? How else are you supposed to learn from your mistakes when you don't even remember the past?

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Sure…A Rs. 10 million statue will feed a lot of hungry people…

Talk about priorities…Why not donate that money to Edhi? I am sure he could use a few more ambulances in a country with lack of them…

And I am absolutely against putting up statues as its totally non-Islamic…

I remember the story when the Holy Prophet :saw: was invited to visit a city to teach them about Islam, but he refused to go because there was a statue in the center of that city…So the city dwellers, who were non-Muslims, out of love and respect for the Messenger tore it down so the Holy Prophet :saw: could visit them and teach them about Islam…The Holy Prophet :saw: visited them and the whole city became Muslim due to the message he brought them…

And look at these people who claim to be Muslims…Putting up statues in a Islamic country…

And yet, during an argument, they will claim the most knowledge about Islam…

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

We are not talking about idols that are meant to be worshiped.

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Every Hindu will tell you, he does not worship the statue but the deity behind the statue…Same with Christians…

And the statue that our holy prophet :saw:, was not a statue of a deity but rather just a statue of someone important…

I am leaving right now, but if this thread is bumped up, I will see if I can nail down the source of this incident…

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

damn bro ppl were worshipping queen's statue or err the queen to which teh statue was attributed to? wowzers..

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

are brown sahibs really any worse than desi bedouin sheikhs? :wink:

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

Pakistan has lots of statues from ancient civilizations as a part of history and cultural heritage.

The “Priest King” statue, Mohenjo-daro.

The “dancing girl” of Mohenjo Daro.

“Ancient Hindu wood carving from Kashmir Smas, Peshawar District (now Pakistan)”

“Three statues of Bodhisattvas” from Jamal-Garhi, Peshawar district (now northern Pakistan)

“The Birth of Buddha.” Buddhist sculpture slab excavated at Lorian Tangai, Peshawar District.

In 2002, Pakistan rescued ancient Buddhist statues.

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

not every mud man is a piece of art.

it could b piece of S***. ;)

so have precise defintion. :o

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

I think the idea is to emulate the Prophet they follow...Not the Bedouin...

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

I agree with the Edhi suggestion, a starving poverty stricken country like Pakistan has more pressing needs than “art”. :k:

Our children are dying cold, naked and hungry and these people want to restore the statues of their British masters. :rolleyes:

Thanks for the story, that is true 'Ishq-e-Rasool :saw:, some of us Pakis will sing empty words about loving him till we go blue in the face but when it comes to doing his Itibaa we don’t want to know him anymore, flesh is weak and falls short but some of us even refuse to acknowledge his orders choosing to shun and reject them.

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

So I guess it would be alright for the Spaniards to destroy remnants of Islamic heritage by that logic?

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

The Spanish did a lot worse than that, they murdered, converted by force and drove out Muslims and Sephardi Jews, the Christian Priests kidnapped Muslim children to bring them up as Christians.

Aaj bhi Spain mein Masjidon ko Girjaghar banaa rakha hai. :(

When Ferdenand and Isabella conquered Iberia, the Muslims (Spaniard as well as Moorish), Sephardi Jews and Orthodox Christians had to pretend to convert to Catholicism and live as Crypto-Muslim/Jews (which didn't work because they were forced to marry into Christian families and publicly eat pork to prove their loyalty).

Moors liberated oppressed Jews and Orthodox Christians, when Muslims ruled Iberia it was a beacon of light for the rest of Europe. When we lost it, it was the Muslims again (Turks) who came to the rescue of the oppressed communities (Sephardi Jews etc.) and gave them reffuge in Islamic lands.

The British on the other hand enslaved us, the Muslim rulers of South-Asia opened their land to the British to let them trade amongst us but they repaid Muslim hospitality by dismantling our Empire and conquering our land and enslaving our people, the poor Moguls had to pretend to be other religions and castes to escape genocide at British hands.

Re: Karachi bids to revive heritage ravaged by extremism

sorry, double post